Skip to main content

Full text of "Taxation of technical services personnel : section 1706 of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 : a report to the Congress"

See other formats


TJ-eas. 

HJ 

2M12     i 

.T71 

Taxation  of  Technical  Services  Personnel: 
Section  1706  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986 


A  Report  to  The  Congress 


Department  of  the  Treasury 
March  1991 


,77/ 


Taxation  of  Technical  Services  Personnel: 
Section  1706  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986 


A  Report  to  The  Congress 


•*^*--  '•'.*/ 


UBBAfiy-i.^-ft^'i 


^t5lVk^^^ 


_  ^5030 


TUMSURy-OEPABTMENi- 


Department  of  the  Treasury 
March  1991 


DEPARTMENT  OF  THE  TREASURY 

WASHINGTON 


March    1991 

ASSISTANT  SECRETARY 


The  Honorable  Dan  Rostenkowski 
Chai  rman 

Committee  on  Ways  and  Means 
House  of  Representatives 
Washington  D.  C.  20515 

Dear  Mr.  Chairman: 

Section  6072  of  Public  Law  100-647,  the  Technical  and 
Miscellaneous  Revenue  Act  of  1988,  provides  that  the  Secretary  of 
the  Treasury  shall  conduct  a  study  of  the  treatment  provided  by 
section  1706  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986  (relating  to  treatment 
of  certain  technical  personnel). 

Pursuant  to  that  section,  I  hereby  submit  the  "Taxation 
of  Technical  Services  Personnel:   Report  on  Section  1706  of  the 
Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986." 

I  am  sending  a  similar  letter  to  Senator  Lloyd  Bentsen, 
Chairman  of  the  Committee  on  Finance. 

YH^H8i-^    Sincerely, 


Kenneth  W.  Gideon 
A'ssistant  Se 
(Tax  Policy) 


■\i/^  iMTiiA*^30   "^'■'^■^'  'A'ssistant    Secretary 
'''  '  (Tax   Poli( 


Enclosure 


ASSISTANT  SECRETARY 


DEPARTMENT  OF  THE  TREASURY 

WASHINGTON 

March  1991 


The  Honorable  Lloyd  Bentsen 

Chairman 

Committee  on  Finance 

United  States  Senate 

Washington  D.  C.  20510 


Dear  Mr.  Chairman: 

Section  6072  of  Public  Law  100-647,  the  Technical  and 
Miscellaneous  Revenue  Act  of  1988,  provides  that  the  Secretary  of 
the  Treasury  shall  conduct  a  study  of  the  treatment  provided  by 
section  1706  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986  (relating  to  treatment 
of  certain  technical  personnel). 

Pursuant  to  that  section,  I  hereby  submit  the  "Taxation 
of  Technical  Services  Personnel:   Report  on  Section  1706  of  the 
Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986." 

I  am  sending  a  similar  letter  to  Representative  Dan 
Rostenkowski ,  Chairman  of  the  Committee  on  Ways  and  Means. 


Sincerely, 


r(sciLd.  %~J-^-^ 


Kenneth  W,  Gideon 
Assistant  Secretary 
(Tax  Policy) 


Enclosure 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 


PART  ONE:    EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY     1 

CHAPTER  1:    EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY 3 

I.  BACKGROUND  OF  REPORT 3 

n.         REPORT  MANDATE    4 

m.       EVALUATION  OF  ISSUES     4 

IV.  OPTIONS  FOR  FURTHER  CONSIDERATION 6 

PART  TWO:    BACKGROUND  INFORMATION 9 

CHAPTER  2:    SOURCES  OF  EMPLOYEE  MISCLASSIFICATION    11 

I.  OVERVIEW 11 

n.        DETERMINATION  OF  EMPLOYEE  STATUS     12 

m.       DIFFERENCES  IN  TAX  TREATMENT  BETWEEN  EMPLOYEES 

AND  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTORS    12 

A.  Differences  Favoring  Independent  Contractor  Status 12 

B.  Differences  Favoring  Employee  Status 14 

C.  Five  Hypothetical  Examples  of  Differential  Tax  Treatment 15 

D.  Validity  of  Differences     26 

CHAPTER  3:    ORIGINS  OF  SECTION  1706 29 

I.  SECTION  530 29 

n.        SECTION  3509    31 

m.       SECTION  1706    32 

PART  THREE:    DISCUSSION  OF  ISSUES 35 

CHAPTER  4:    GENERAL  POLICY  ISSUES 37 

I.  OVERVIEW 37 

n.         EFFICIENCY  OF  LABOR  MARKETS 37 

A.  Arrangements  Between  Workers  and  Firms 37 

B.  Government  Policy 40 

m.   NEUTRALITY  IN  TAX  TREATMENT  40 

A.  Maintaining  Labor  Market  Efficiency 40 

B.  Tax  Equity 42 

rV.       ADMINISTRATIVE  COSTS 45 

V.  NON-TAX  POLICIES    46 

CHAPTER  5:    TAX  COMPLIANCE  ISSUES 47 

L  OVERVIEW 47 

n.         RATE  OF  MISCLASSIFICATION    47 


m.       RATE  OF  NONCOMPLIANCE 50 

A.  1985  TCMP 51 

B.  1984  SVC-1  Employee  Survey 54 

C.  Summary 55 

CHAPTER  6:    TAX  ADMINISTRATION  ISSUES    57 

I.  OVERVIEW 57 

n.         ADMINISTRATIVE  PROBLEMS  WITH  SECTION  1706 57 

m.       ADMINISTRATIVE  PROBLEMS  WITH  COMMON  LAW  TESTS  OF 

EMPLOYEE  STATUS 58 

PART  FOUR:    APPENDICES 61 

APPENDIX  A:    DIFFERENCES  IN  TREATMENT  OF  EMPLOYEES  AND 

INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTORS-DETAILED  ANALYSIS    63 

I.  OVERVIEW 63 

n.         FEDERAL  TAX  LAW 63 

A.  Employment  Taxes 63 

B.  Income  Taxes 66 

C.  Determination  of  Employee  Status 75 

m.       OTHER  LAWS    78 

A.  Federal  Labor  Laws    78 

B.  Patent  and  Copyright  Laws 80 

C.  State  Laws 80 

D.  Determination  of  Employee  Status 81 

IV.       SUMMARY    82 

APPENDIX  B:    COMMON  LAW  FACTORS  USED  TO  DETERMINE  EMPLOYEE 

STATUS   . 83 

APPENDIX  C:    ADDITIONAL  BACKGROUND  TO  TCMP  AND  SVC-1 85 

I.  TCMP 85 

II.  SVC-1 86 


VI 


LIST  OF  TABLES 

Chapter  2 

2-1       Major  Differences  in  Treatment  of  Employees  and  Independent  Contractors  for 

Federal  Tax  and  Other  Purposes     16 

2-2       Comparison  of  Income  and  Taxation  of  $1,000  of  Total  Compensation  for  an 
Employee  or  Independent  Contractor,  Worker  with  a  Typical  Mix  of  Fringe 
Benefits  and  no  Worker  Expenses 18 

2-3       Comparison  of  Income  and  Taxation  of  $1,000  of  Total  Compensation  for  an 
Employee  or  Independent  Contractor,  Worker  with  a  Typical  Mix  of  Fringe 
Benefits,  no  Worker  Expenses,  and  5  Percent  Non-Compliance  by  the 
Independent  Contractor    20 

2-4       Comparison  of  Income  and  Taxation  of  $1,000  of  Total  Compensation  for  an 
Employee  or  Independent  Contractor,  Worker  with  a  Typical  Mix  of  Fringe 
Benefits  and  Worker  Expenses  of  10  Percent 21 

2-5       Comparison  of  Income  and  Taxation  of  $1,000  of  Total  Compensation  for  an 
Employee  or  Independent  Contractor,  Worker  with  Only  Statutory  Benefits  and 
no  Worker  Expenses 23 

2-6       Comparison  of  Income  and  Taxation  of  $1,000  of  Total  Compensation  for  an 
Employee  or  Independent  Contractor,  Worker  with  Only  Statutory  Benefits,  no 
Worker  Expenses,  and  a  "Wedge"  Between  Employee  and  Independent 
Contractor  Total  Compensation    25 

Chapter  5 

5-1       Percentage  of  Employers  with  Some  Misclassified  Employees,  by  Industry 49 

5-2       Reporting  of  Income  and  Expenses  by  Employees  and  Independent  Contractors   .  .    52 

Appendix  A 

A-1      Tax-Favored  Benefits  Available  to  Employees  and  Independent  Contractors    ....    73 


vu 


PART  ONE 


EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY 


CHAPTER  1:   EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY 
I.  BACKGROUND  OF  REPORT 

Despite  the  wide  variety  of  relationships  between  workers  and  firms,  there  are  generally 
only  two  classifications  of  workers  for  Federal  tax  purposes:  self-employed  workers  (sometimes 
called  independent  contractors)  and  employees.  The  proper  classification  is  self-evident  for 
many  workers;  for  others,  it  is  ambiguous.  When  the  proper  classification  is  ambiguous,  the 
potential  for  worker  misclassification  increases.  Inadvertent  misclassification  may  occur  if 
employers  lack  sufficiently  detailed  guidance  to  determine  the  correct  classification.  In  addition, 
the  various  legal,  economic,  and  tax  consequences  of  the  alternate  classifications  may  provide 
incentives  for  deliberate  misclassification. 

Historically,  misclassification  of  employees  as  independent  contractors  was  a  concern 
because  self-employed  workers  faced  significantly  lower  Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  rates 
than  the  combined  rate  for  employers  and  employees.  Misclassification  was  perceived  as 
producing  large  losses  of  employment  tax  revenues.  Now  that  self-employed  workers  face 
Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  rates  comparable  to  the  combined  rate  for  employees  and 
employers,  concern  about  misclassification  has  shifted  to  potential  losses  of  all  tax  revenues. 
Income  and  employment  tax  revenues  may  be  lower  due  to  differences  in  the  income  and 
employment  tax  bases  and  differences  in  compliance  between  employees  and  the  self-employed. 

In  the  late  1960s,  when  significant  employment  tax  rate  differentials  still  existed,  the 
Internal  Revenue  Service  (IRS)  began  to  increase  its  employment  tax  enforcement  activities, 
which  previously  had  been  sporadic,  to  address  the  misclassification  of  workers.  Classification 
of  a  worker  directly  affects  employment  tax  obligations  and  indirectly  affects  a  worker's  income 
tax  treatment.  As  a  result  of  the  IRS'  actions,  the  number  of  reclassifications  increased 
substantially.  Many  reclassifications  resulted  in  large  retroactive  assessments  against  employers. 

Congress  subsequently  took  several  actions  to  address  taxpayer  concerns  about  worker 
reclassification.  In  section  530  of  the  Revenue  Act  of  1978  (section  530),  it  provided  statutory 
relief  from  reclassification  for  certain  employers  involved  in  employment  tax  controversies  with 
the  IRS.  Section  530  generally  prohibited  the  IRS  from  challenging  an  employer's  erroneous 
treatment  of  an  employee  as  an  independent  contractor  for  employment  tax  purposes  if  the 
employer  had  a  reasonable  basis  for  such  treatment  and  certain  other  requirements  were  met. 
It  also  generally  prohibited  the  IRS  from  issuing  regulations  or  publishing  revenue  rulings 
addressing  the  status  of  workers  as  employees  or  independent  contractors  for  employment  tax 


purposes.  Section  530  was  initially  intended  as  an  interim  measure.  In  1982,  Congress 
extended  it  indefinitely,  and  also  limited  employer  liabilities  in  certain  cases  of  retroactive 
reclassification. 

Section  1706  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986  (section  1706)  removed  the  statutory  relief 
of  section  530,  but  only  for  taxpayers  that  broker  the  services  of  technical  services  workers,  i.e., 
engineers,  designers,  drafters,  computer  programmers,  systems  analysts  and  other  similarly- 
skilled  workers  engaged  in  a  similar  line  of  work.  Thus,  section  1706  only  applies  in  multi- 
party situations  involving  (1)  technical  services  workers,  (2)  companies  that  use  the  workers,  and 
(3)  firms  that  supply  or  broker  the  services  of  the  workers. 

Section  1706  does  not  change  the  rules  for  classifying  workers  as  employees  or 
independent  contractors,  nor  does  it  change  the  legal  status  of  anyone  covered  by  the  provision. 
It  only  permits  the  IRS  to  interpret  and  enforce  the  underlying  rules  for  employment  tax 
purposes  for  the  covered  technical  services  workers  without  regard  to  section  530.  However, 
in  practice  the  worker's  employment  tax  classification  generally  determines  whether  the  worker 
is  treated  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor  for  Federal  income  tax  purposes. 

n.        REPORT  MANDATE 

This  report  was  prepared  in  response  to  a  congressional  mandate  in  the  Technical  and 
Miscellaneous  Revenue  Act  of  1988  (TAMRA).  Section  6072  of  TAMRA  directed  the  Secretary 
of  the  Treasury  or  his  delegate  to  conduct  a  study  of  the  treatment  provided  by  section  1706  of 
the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986  (TRA  1986). 

in.      EVALUATION  OF  ISSUES 

According  to  the  Conference  Report  on  TAMRA,'  the  Treasury  report  was  to  include 
an  evaluation  of  five  issues.  These  issues,  and  the  general  findings  of  the  report  with  respect 
to  each,  are  described  below. 


H.R.  Conf.  Rep.  No.  1104,  100th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  167-68  (1988). 


Administrability  of  section  1706.  The  Conference  Report  questioned  whether  there  were 
difficulties  in  the  adniinistration  of  the  provisions  of  section  1706.  The  report  finds  that: 

•  Section  1706  itself  presents  few  administrative  problems,  particularly  in  comparison  with 
section  530; 

•  Section  1706  actually  improves  the  administrability  of  the  present-law  rules  for 
classifying  individuals  as  employees  or  independent  contractors  by  partially  repealing  the 
prohibition  in  section  530  against  the  issuance  of  guidance;  but 

•  The  occupations  covered  by  section  1706  could  be  clarified  {see  Chapter  6,  section  11). 

Abuses  in  the  reporting  of  income  by  independent  contractors.  The  Conference  Report 
questioned  whether  there  were  any  abuses  in  the  reporting  of  income  by  independent  contractors 
that  would  justify  the  adoption  of  section  1706,  including  any  evidence  of  greater  noncompliance 
by  independent  contractors  when  compared  to  employees.   The  report  finds  that: 

•  Existing  IRS  data  suggest  that  there  are  errors  in  the  classification  of  employees  as 
independent  contractors  and  in  the  reporting  of  income  by  such  individuals,  which  may 
call  for  legislative  or  administrative  changes— 

►  Underreporting  of  income  by  such  individuals,  and  the  more  favorable  treatment 
of  independent  contractor  trade  or  business  expenses,  reduce  tax  revenue; 

►  Misclassification  of  employees  as  independent  contractors  increases  tax  revenues, 
however,  and  tends  to  offset  the  revenue  loss  from  undercompliance  by  such 
individuals,  because  direct  compensation  to  independent  contractors  is  substituted 
for  tax-favored  employee  fringe  benefits; 

•  Evidence  suggests  that  compliance  is  somewhat  better  for  technical  services  workers  who 
are  classified  as  independent  contractors  than  for  workers  in  general  who  are  classified 
as  independent  contractors  {see  Chapter  5). 

Chilling  effect  of  section  1706  on  the  ability  of  technical  services  personnel  to  get  work.  The 
Conference  Report  questioned  the  effect  of  section  1706  on  the  ability  of  technical  services 
personnel  to  get  work.   The  report  concludes  that: 

•  Section  1706  does  not  affect  the  cost  to  firms  of  technical  services  workers  relative  to 
other  workers,  and  does  not  affect  the  demand  for  firms'  products;  it  is  unlikely, 
therefore,  that  section  1706  affects  the  overall  ability  of  technical  services  workers  to  get 
work; 


•  Section  1706  may,  however,  have  had  some  transitory  effects  on  the  ability  of  some 
workers  to  find  work  in  their  accustomed  classification  (jee  Chapter  4). 

Administrability  of  the  present-law  standards  for  classifying  individuals  as  employees  or 
independent  contractors.  The  Conference  Report  questioned  whether  the  present  law  standards 
for  distinguishing  between  employees  and  independent  contractors  were  administrable.  The 
report  finds  that: 

•  The  task  of  classifying  workers  as  employees  or  independent  contractors  under  the  20- 
factor  common  law  tests  generally  used  under  present  law  can  be  difficult,  in  particular 
in  the  multi-party  situations  affected  by  section  1706; 

•  Section  530  has  exacerbated  this  problem  by  preventing  theTRS  from  issuing  guidance 
in  this  area  for  over  ten  years;  and 

•  Section  1706  may  have  improved  tax  administration  by  permitting  the  IRS  to  issue 
guidance  with  respect  to  certain  workers  and  by  denying  the  section  530  safe  harbors  to 
certain  employers  {see  Chapter  6,  section  IE). 

Equity  of  distinguishing  between  independent  contractors  who  work  through  brokers  and  those 
who  do  not.  The  Conference  Report  questioned  the  equity  of  providing  rules  that  distinguish 
between  independent  contractors  who  work  through  brokers  and  those  who  do  not.  The  report 
finds  that: 

•  This  distinction  unnecessarily  limits  the  beneficial  effects  of  section  1706,  and  may  have 
an  adverse  effect  on  the  efficiency  of  the  labor  markets  for  such  workers; 

•  Data  are  not  available,  however,  to  determine  whether  the  distinction  can  be  justified  on 
the  basis  of  differences  in  compliance  rates  between  the  two  groups  {see  Chapter  4). 

IV.       OPTIONS  FOR  FURTHER  CONSIDERATION 

The  significance  of  the  effects  of  section  1706  must  be  viewed  in  the  context  of  existing 
substantive  tax  differences  between  independent  contractors  and  employees,  especially  with 
respect  to  the  exclusion  of  fringe  benefits  from  gross  income,  the  deductibility  of  employee 
business  expenses,  and  differences  in  the  Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  base.  In  that  context, 


and  based  on  the  findings  of  this  report,  the  following  options  are  presented  for  further 
consideration  and  analysis: 

•  Eliminate  the  difference  in  treatment  under  section  1706  between  technical  services 
workers  working  through  brokers  and  those  not  working  through  brokers.  This 
difference  is  difficult  to  justify  on  equity  or  other  policy  grounds.    (See  Chapter  4.) 

•  Clarify  the  occupations  covered  by  section  1706.  Difficulties  in  determining  the 
occupations  covered  by  section  1706  present  an  administrative  problem.    {See  Chapter 

6.) 

•  Repeal  the  prohibition  in  section  530  against  the  issuance  of  guidance  by  the  IRS 
concerning  employee  status.  This  prohibition  has  significantly  reduced  taxpayers'  ability 
to  classify  workers  correctly  as  employees  or  independent  contractors  and  has 
exacerbated  the  difficulty  of  applying  the  20-factor  common  law  standards.  {See  Chapter 
6.) 


PART  TWO 


BACKGROUND  INFORMATION 


CHAPTER  2:   SOURCES  OF  EMPLOYEE  MISCLASSIFICATION 

I.  OVERVIEW 

A  wide  variety  of  relationships  between  service-providers  and  service-recipients  exists 
in  the  modem  economy.  They  differ  with  respect  to  the  degree  of  control  exercised  by  the 
service-recipient,  whether  the  services  are  full-time  or  part-time,  the  method  of  compensation 
(e.g. ,  salaried  versus  hourly),  the  level  of  material  support  provided  by  the  service-recipient,  and 
many  other  factors.  Despite  this  diversity,  service-providers  are  generally  grouped  into  one  of 
two  broad  categories  for  Federal  tax  purposes:    employees  and  independent  contractors. 

Misclassification  of  individuals  as  employees  or  independent  contractors  results  when 
service-recipients  and  service-providers  misapply  the  tests  oised  to  distinguish  employees  from 
independent  contractors  under  the  Code.  Deliberate  misclassification  of  employees  as 
independent  contractors  results  in  part  from  the  fact  that  there  are  numerous  differences  under 
the  Internal  Revenue  Code  (Code)  between  the  treatment  of  employers  and  employees,  on  the 
one  hand,  and  independent  contractors  and  their  clients,  on  the  other,  and  from  the  perception 
that  these  differences  systematically  favor  the  second  group. 

Differences  in  treatment  between  employers  and  employees,  on  the  one  hand,  and 
independent  contractors  and  their  clients,  on  the  other,  also  occur  under  a  number  of  other 
Federal  and  State  laws,  primarily  those  dealing  with  workers'  compensation  and  unemployment 
insurance,  labor-management  relations,  employment  discrimination,  and  other  labor  issues. 
Misclassification  designed  to  benefit  from  these  differences  in  non-tax  treatment  can  also 
contribute  to  misclassification  for  Federal  tax  purposes,  since  inconsistent  treatment  of  an 
individual  under  these  laws  and  Federal  tax  laws  might  invite  scrutiny. 

Misclassification  of  individuals  as  employees  or  independent  contractors  is  problematic 
to  the  extent  that  it  circumvents  a  policy  decision  to  limit  certain  tax  benefits  or  burdens  to  one 
group  or  the  other,  or  results  in  a  loss  of  revenue  through  noncompliance. 

This  chapter  provides  a  general  description  of  the  factors  used  to  distinguish  employees 
from  independent  contractors  under  Federal  tax  and  other  laws,  and  of  the  differences  in  the 
treatment  of  employees  and  independent  contractors  that  may  encourage  misclassification  under 
each.    A  more  detailed  description  of  these  issues  is  provided  in  Appendix  A. 


11 


12 
n.        DETERMINATION  OF  EMPLOYEE  STATUS 

The  status  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor  for  purposes  of 
Federal  employment,  income  and  other  tax  laws  is,  with  few  exceptions,  determined  under  the 
common  law  tests  for  determining  whether  an  employment  relationship  exists.  These  tests  focus 
on  whether  the  service-recipient  has  the  right  to  direct  and  control  the  service-provider,  not  only 
as  to  the  result  to  be  accomplished  by  the  work,  but  also  as  to  the  details  and  means  by  which 
that  result  is  accomplished.  Over  the  years,  the  IRS  has  identified  20  important  factors  useful 
in  determining  whether  the  common  law  tests  have  been  satisfied.  These  factors  are  listed  in 
Appendix  B. 

The  status  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor  for  purposes  of 
Federal  and  State  labor  and  related  laws  is  generally  determined  under  standards  that  resemble 
the  control-based  common  law  standards  applied  under  the  Code.  Depending  on  the  purpose  of 
the  law  involved,  however,  different  factors  are  often  emphasized  in  making  this  determination. 
Thus,  IRS  determinations  of  employee  status  based  on  the  common  law  tests  are  generally 
persuasive  but  not  determinative  in  other  areas,  and  it  is  possible  for  an  individual  to  be 
classified  as  an  employee  for  some  purposes  and  as  an  independent  contractor  for  others. 

m.      DIFFERENCES     IN    TAX    TREATMENT    BETWEEN    EMPLOYEES    AND 
INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTORS 

Current  law  does  not  consistently  favor  status  as  either  an  employee  or  an  independent 
contractor.  Employers  and  employees  are  treated  differently  than  independent  contractors  and 
their  clients  under  a  number  of  Federal  and  State  laws,  however.  Thus,  depending  on  individual 
circumstances,  misclassification  may  sometimes  be  advantageous  to  the  service-provider,  the 
service-recipient,  or  both. 

A.        Differences  Favoring  Independent  Contractor  Status 

Federal  Tax  Law.  Prior  to  1982,  compensation  earned  by  independent  contractors  was 
taxed  at  substantially  lower  rates  under  the  Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  provisions  of  the 
Code  than  wage  income,  apparently  creating  a  significant  incentive  for  misclassification.^ 
Subsequent  legislation  has  essentially  eliminated  this  important  difference.  The  Social  Security, 


^  To  some  extent,  however,  the  rate  differential  may  have  been  offset  by  differences  in  the 
compensation  base  to  which  the  taxes  applied. 


13 

Medicare,  and  income  tax  provisions  of  the  Code  may  still  favor  classification  as  an  independent 
contractor,  however,  where  an  individual  has  a  small  or  unpredictable  cash  flow  or  significant 
employee  business  expenses.    This  is  primarily  because: 

(1)  Independent  contractors  face  significantly  fewer  restrictions  on  their  ability  to 
deduct  trade  or  business  expenses  than  employees.  In  particular,  employees 
generally  may  not  deduct  their  trade  or  business  expenses  unless  they  "itemize" 
their  deductions  on  their  tax  returns,  and  then  only  to  the  extent  the  expenses 
exceed  two  percent  of  their  adjusted  gross  incomes  from  all  sources.  They  must 
also  satisfy  additional  requirements  before  they  may  deduct  their  automobile 
depreciation,  home  office,  home  computer  and  certain  other  expenses.  These 
requirements  are  difficult  for  many  employees  to  meet  and  in  some  cases 
constitute  an  effective  barrier  to  a  deduction. 

(2)  The  estimated  tax  system  used  to  collect  Social  Security,  Medicare,  and  income 
taxes  from  independent  contractors  largely  avoids  the  problem  of  over-withhold- 
ing that  can  result  when  an  employee  incurs  large  business  expenses,  has  net 
income  that  fluctuates  during  a  year,  or  is  employed  for  only  part  of  a  year.  It 
also  generally  permits  later  and  less  frequent  payments  than  the  withholding 
system  used  to  collect  such  taxes  from  employees. 

As  an  essentially  voluntary  reporting  system,  the  estimated  tax  system  also  provides  fewer 
checks  against  underreporting  of  income  and  taxes  than  the  withholding  system  and  may, 
therefore,  be  favored  by  service-providers  and  service-recipients  willing  to  violate  the  law  and 
risk  detection  on  audit;  it  also  does  not  ensure  the  collectability  of  taxes  to  the  same  extent  as 
the  withholding  system.  Finally,  the  withholding  system  involves  overhead  costs,  which 
employers  may  seek  to  shift  to  employees  by  classifying  them  as  independent  contractors. 

The  unemployment  insurance  tax  provisions  of  the  Code  (and  corresponding  State  laws) 
may  in  some  cases  also  favor  classification  as  an  independent  contractor.  Independent 
contractors  and  their  clients  generally  are  not  subject  to  unemployment  insurance  taxes.  On  the 
other  hand,  independent  contractors  generally  are  not  eligible  for  unemployment  insurance 
benefits.  Other  things  being  equal,  employers  will  have  an  incentive  to  classify  a  worker  as  an 
independent  contractor  in  order  to  avoid  unemployment  insurance  taxes  on  an  employee's  wages 
(and  the  administrative  costs  of  remitting  such  taxes  and  complying  with  other  associated 
statutory  requirements).  Workers  may  prefer  to  be  classified  as  independent  contractors  if  they 
are  not  (or  perceive  that  they  are  not)  dependent  on  a  single  employer  for  their  income. 


14 

Other  Laws.  State  and  Federal  labor  and  related  laws  may  in  some  cases  also  favor 
classification  as  an  independent  contractor.  Such  laws  typically  do  not  apply  to  independent 
contractors,  providing  protection  only  to  employees.  This  is  generally  beneficial  to  clients  of 
independent  contractors,  since  it  may  allow  them  to  avoid  the  direct  costs  of  providing  additional 
benefits  and  protections  to  the  independent  contractors,  as  well  as  the  administrative  cost  of 
explaining  the  benefits  and  assuring  that  various  other  statutory  requirements  have  been  met. 
Thus,  the  difference  in  treatment  may  provide  an  incentive  for  employers  to  misclassify 
employees  as  independent  contractors.  Employees  may  also  prefer  to  be  misclassified  as 
independent  contractors  in  order  to  avoid  coverage  under  these  laws,  if  they  are  not  willing  to 
pay  the  indirect  cost  for  the  specific  protection  provided. 

B.        Differences  Favoring  Employee  Status 

The  Social  Security,  Medicare,  and  income  tax  provisions  of  the  Code  may,  on  the  other 
hand,  favor  classification  as  an  employee  in  cases  where  an  individual  prefers  to  receive  some 
of  her  compensation  in  the  form  of  fringe  benefits  rather  than  cash.  This  is  because,  under  the 
Code,  an  employer  may  provide  fringe  benefits,  such  as  pensions,  accident  and  health  and 
group-term  life  insurance,  on  a  tax-favored  basis  to  its  employees  but  not  to  its  independent 
contractors.  Such  benefits  are  generally  excluded  from  employees'  gross  incomes  subject  to 
income  tax  as  well  as  wages  subject  to  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes.  While  independent 
contractors  can  generally  establish  their  own  fringe  benefit  plans,  amounts  used  to  purchase  such 
benefits  generally  cannot  be  deducted  or  excluded  from  gross  income  subject  to  income  tax,  or 
from  compensation  subject  to  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes.  Limited  exceptions  are 
provided  for  certain  of  the  most  significant  benefits,  including  pensions  and  accident  and  health 
insurance;  amounts  used  to  purchase  these  benefits  can  to  some  extent  be  deducted  or  excluded 
from  gross  income  subject  to  income  tax  by  independent  contractors,  although  they  cannot  be 
deducted  or  excluded  from  compensation  subject  to  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes. 

An  employer  may  be  reluctant  to  allow  an  independent  contractor  to  participate  in  a  plan 
as  an  employee,  however,  since  that  might  involve  additional  costs  to  the  employer.  This  is 
particularly  true  if  the  independent  contractor  is  highly  compensated,  in  which  case  her 
participation  might  require  the  employer  to  provide  additional  benefits  to  its  non-highly 
compensated  employees  under  the  minimum  coverage  and  nondiscrimination  requirements  of  the 
Code.  Also,  short-service  independent  contractors  may  not  derive  any  significant  benefits  from 
participation,  and  may  therefore  prefer  to  receive  additional  cash  compensation,  instead. 


15 

The  various  differences  in  tax  treatment  between  employees  and  independent  contractors 
discussed  above  are  summarized  in  Table  2-1. 

C.        Five  Hypothetical  Examples  of  Differential  Tax  Treatment 

The  preceding  discussion  indicates  that  Federal  and  State  tax,  labor  and  related  laws  do 
not  systematically  favor  classification  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor. 
The  most  beneficial  classification  for  a  particular  individual  depends  instead  on  her  circumstanc- 
es, preferences,  and  negotiating  skills.  This  section  illustrates  the  effects  of  these  differences 
using  five  hypothetical  examples. 

Each  example  begins  with  $1,000  which  an  employer  or  service-recipient  could  spend 
on  worker  compensation.  In  the  employee  situation,  most  of  the  $1,000  is  used  to  pay  the 
employee  her  normal  salary  plus  holiday,  vacation  and  sick  pay.  The  remainder  is  used  to  pay 
employment  taxes  (including  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  and  State  and  Federal 
unemployment  insurance  taxes)  and  to  provide  statutorily-required  or  voluntarily-provided  fringe 
benefits  (including  contributions  to  retirement  plans,  health  insurance  premiums,  and  workers' 
compensation  premiums).  The  employee  pays  any  Federal  and  State  income  taxes  and  the 
employee  share  of  the  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  due  on  her  salary,  and  also  pays  any 
work-related  expenses  (for  tools,  etc.).^ 

In  the  independent  contractor  situation,  the  $1,000  spent  for  worker  compensation  by  the 
client  is  generally  assumed  to  be  paid  to  the  independent  contractor,  although,  depending  on  the 
knowledge  and  relative  negotiating  skills  of  the  two  parties,  some  might  be  retained  by  the 
client.  The  amount,  if  any,  retained  by  the  client  is  assumed  to  pass  directly  to  the  client's 
"bottom  line"  and,  therefore,  to  be  subject  to  Federal  and  State  corporate  income  taxes. 

In  order  to  maintain  the  comparison  between  the  employee  and  the  independent 
contractor,  the  independent  contractor  is  assumed  to  incur  the  same  costs  as  the  employee 
(although  the  tax  treatment  may  be  different)  and  is  assumed  to  purchase  directly  the  same 


^  Since  the  examples  show  the  impact  of  additional  income  to  the  employee  or  independent 
contractor,  a  28  percent  Federal  income  tax  rate  and  a  7.5  percent  State  income  tax  rate  are 
assumed  to  apply  to  the  additional  taxable  income.  The  assumed  Federal  corporate  income  tax 
rate  is  34  percent,  and  the  assumed  State  rate  is  eight  percent.  The  various  tax  rates  are  based 
on  those  that  would  be  paid  by  or  for  a  middle-income  worker. 


Table  2-1 

M^or  Differences  in  Treatment  of  Employees  and  Independent  Contractors 
for  Federal  Tax  and  Other  Purposes 


Employees 


Value  of  many  employer-provided  fringe  benefits 
excluded  from  income  and  employment  tax  bases 


Independent  Contractors 


Fringe  Benefits' 


Qualified  retirement  plan  contributions  excluded  from 
income  but  not  self-employment  tax  base 

25  percent  of  health  insurance  costs  deducted  from 
income  but  not  self-employment  tax  base 

Few  other  fringe  benefits  excluded  from  income  or 
self-employment  tax  bases 


Trade  or  Business  Expenses 


May  be  deducted  from  income  tax  base  only  by  itemizers 
and  only  to  the  extent  expenses  exceed  two  percent  of 
adjusted  gross  income 

May  not  be  excluded  from  employment  tax  base 

Certain  expenses  subject  to  additional  business  purpose 
requirements 


May  be  deducted  from  income  tax  base 


May  be  excluded  from  self-employment  tax  base 


Administrative  Costs 


Withholding  involves  more  administrative  costs  for 
employer  but  less  for  employee 


Estimated  tax  system  involves  more  administrative 
costs  for  independent  contractor  but  less  for  client 


Estimated  tax  system  allows  modest  delay  in  tax 
payments  relative  to  withholding 


Compliance 


Somewhat  more  ability  to  be  noncompliant  due  to  lack 
of  withholding,  larger  trade  or  business  expenses,  and 
somewhat  more  limited  business  purpose  requirements 
with  respect  to  such  expenses 


Non-Tax  Differences' 


Less  flexibility  in  choosing  among  fringe  benefits;  value 
of  employer  contributions  to  retirement  plan  may  be  lost 
if  worker  changes  jobs  frequently 

Administrative  (and  other)  costs  associated  with  Federal 
and  State  laws  applicable  to  employees,  e.g.,  minimum 
wage 


May  be  unable  to  obtain  fringe  benefits,  including 
statutory  fringe  benefits  such  as  unemployment 
insurance  and  workers'  compensation 

May  be  unable  to  negotiate  worker  protections  such  as 
minimum  wage  and  overtime 


Dcpartmctit  ot  the  Tre«5ury 
Office  of  T«x  Pobcy 

1.        For  a  detailed  comparison  of  the  tax  treatment  of  fringe  benefits  and  business  expenses,  see  Appendix  A.    Employer- 
provided  fringe  benefits  may  be  subject  to  nondiscrimination  requirements  and  other  limits. 


Some  of  the  non-tax  differences,  such  as  minimum  wage  laws,  may  be  more  applicable  to  less  advantaged  workers  than 
to  occupations  covered  by  section  1706. 


17 

benefits  that  the  employee  would  receive  as  employer-paid  fringe  benefits."  It  is  further 
assumed  that  the  independent  contractor  can  purchase  these  benefits  at  the  same  cost  an  employer 
could  when  purchasing  for  all  of  its  employees  as  a  group/ 

Example  1--Typical  Mix  of  Fringe  Benefits.  Example  1  (Table  2-2)  shows  a  situation 
in  which  an  employee  receives  a  typical  mix  of  fringe  benefits  but  does  not  incur  any  deductible 
trade  or  business  expenses.  The  employer  pays  the  employer  share  of  Social  Security  and 
Medicare  taxes,  as  well  as  the  total  cost  of  workers'  compensation  premiums  and  Federal  and 
State  unemployment  insurance  taxes.  The  employer  also  makes  contributions  to  retirement  and 
medical  insurance  plans  for  the  employee,  each  costing  six  percent  of  total  compensation.  The 
employee  receives  regular,  vacation,  holiday  and  sick  pay  of  $806,  out  of  which  the  employee's 
share  of  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  as  well  as  Federal  and  State  income  taxes,  are  paid. 
The  independent  contractor  receives  the  entire  $1,000  in  cash.  Out  of  that,  she  pays  Federal  and 
State  income  taxes.  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  buys  health  insurance,  and  contributes 
to  a  tax-favored  "Keogh"  retirement  plan.  As  shown  in  Table  2-2,  the  independent  contractor 
pays  $12  more  in  Federal  income  tax,  $4  more  in  State  income  tax,  and  $18  more  in  Social 
Security  and  Medicare  tax. 

Taxes  are  higher  for  the  independent  contractor  in  Example  1  because  the  part  of  her 
cash  income  that  was  used  to  provide  fringe  benefits  in  the  case  of  the  employee  is  subject  to 
Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  and  some  is  also  subject  to  income  taxes.  Current  Federal 
law  attempts  to  equate  the  tax  rate  for  employees  and  self-employed  persons  for  Social  Security 
and  Medicare  tax  purposes.  Nevertheless,  there  are  differences  in  the  tax  base.  Self-employed 
persons  may  not  exclude  the  value  of  fringe  benefits  they  purchase  for  themselves  from  the 
Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  base  (other  than  the  employer  portion  of  Social  Security  and 
Medicare  taxes),  while  the  value  of  employer-provided  fringe  benefits  is  typically  excluded  from 
that  base  in  the  case  of  employees.  Hence,  in  Example  1,  the  Social  Security  tax  is  $18,  or  15 
percent,  higher  for  the  independent  contractor  than  for  the  employee.  The  income  tax  system 
does  provide  deductions  for  self-employed  persons  for  contributions  to  retirement  plans  (and  for 
the  equivalent  to  the  employer  portion  of  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes),  but  it  only 


*  In  practice,  the  lower  after-tax  price  for  voluntarily-provided  fringe  benefits  would  likely 
result  in  greater  expenditures  for  these  items  in  the  employee  case.  Conversely,  the  lower  after- 
tax price  of  certain  trade  or  business  expenses  for  independent  contractors  would  likely  result 
in  higher  trade  or  business  expenses  for  such  individuals. 

'  This  assumption  is  made  for  simplicity  and  may  be  approximately  correct  for  small 
employers.   For  large  employers,  economies  of  scale  are  probably  important. 


Table  2-2 

EXAMPLE  1:   COMPARISON  OF  INCOME  AND  TAXATION  OF  $1,000  OF  TOTAL  COMPENSATION 
FOR  AN  EMPLOYEE  OR  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR, 
WORKER  WITH  A  TYPICAL  MIX  OF  FRINGE  BENEFITS  AND  NO  WORKER  EXPENSES 


Employer/Employee 


Employer   Employee   Combined 


Independent  Contractor 
Service 
Recipient       Worker  Combined 


Money  Payment  or  Regular  Salary 733            733                                  1,000          1,000 

HolidayA^acation/Sick  Pay 73 73 

MONEY  PAYMENT  OR  TOTAL  SALARY 806             806~                                  1,000          1,000 

Employer-Paid  Taxes  and  Benefits 194                               194 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION  TO  WORKER 1.000                                                      1,000 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient 0 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION 1,000                                                      1,000 

TAXES  AND  STATUTORY  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 74  331  405  0            427  427 

Federal  Income  Tax   1/2/  209  209  0            221  221 

State  Income  Tax   1/3/  60  60  0              64  64 

Social  Security  (FICA/SECA)  4/                                                        62  62  123  141  141 

Unemployment  Insurance  (FUTA  and  State)  5/4  4 

Workers'  Compensation   6/                                                                       8  8 

VOLUNTARY  FRINGE  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 120  0  120  0  120  120 

Retirement/Keogh  Contribution  60  60  60  60 

Health  Insurance  Premiums  60  60  60  60 

WORKER  EXPENSES  (DEDUCTIBLE),  TOTAL 0  0  0 

Income  and  Social  Security  Tax  Compliance  Rate 100.0%  100.0% 

For  Worker 

Total  Compensation  less 

Taxes  and  Statutory  Benefits 595  573 

Money  Income  less 

Worker  Taxes 475  573 

Money  Income  less  Worker  Taxes, 

Worker-Paid  Benefits,  and  Worker  Expenses 475  453 

For  Employer  (Service  Recipient) 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient  less  Taxes 0  0 

Department  of  the  Treasury 
Office  of  Tax  Analysis 

Note:   Detail  may  not  add  to  totals  due  to  rounding. 

1/     Taxable  amount  is  money  payment  to  the  worker  less  deductions  consistent  with  worker  status.   Employee  has  itemized  deductions 
for  state  income  taxes  (for  federal  tax  purposes  but  not  for  state  tax  purposes)  and  for  worker  expenses  in  excess  of  2  percent  of 
adjusted  gross  income  (assumed  to  be  4  percent  of  money  payment).    Independent  contractor  deducts  worker  expenses,  Keogh 
contributions,  25  percent  of  health  insurance  premium,  and  50  percent  of  SEC  A  tax. 

2/       28  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  34  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

3/      7.5  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  8  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

4/      7.65  percent  rate  for  the  employee  and  for  the  employer,  or  14.12955  percent  rate  ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%)  paid  entirely  by  the 
independent  contractor. 

5/       Assumed  to  be  0.55  percent  of  total  salary. 

6/       Assumed  to  be  I  percent  of  total  salary. 


19 

permits  a  deduction  for  25  percent  of  medical  insurance  costs  (and  then  only  in  some 
circumstances),  and  it  does  not  permit  a  deduction  for  the  cash  equivalent  of  other  fringe 
benefits,  which  in  this  example  only  consist  of  the  costs  of  unemployment  insurance  and 
workers'  compensation. 

Example  2-Noncompliance.  Independent  contractors  may  have  greater  opportunity  than 
employees  to  be  less  than  fully  compliant  with  tax  laws.  Employees  are  subject  to  withholding, 
and  the  amount  of  their  wage  income  is  reported  with  great  precision  to  the  IRS.  Independent 
contractors  may  be  able  to  omit  some  of  their  income  on  their  tax  returns,  although  that  becomes 
more  difficult  when  their  gross  income  is  reported  to  IRS  on  information  returns  (generally 
Forms  1099-MISC).  Even  if  independent  contractors  report  100  percent  of  their  income, 
however,  they  may  be  able  to  lower  their  reported  tax  liability  by  overstating  expenses.  Since 
the  workers  in  Example  2  do  not  have  trade  or  business  expenses,  the  noncompliance  consists 
solely  of  the  failure  to  report  all  of  gross  income.  Example  2  (Table  2-3)  illustrates  the  effect 
of  a  lower  compliance  rate  on  the  independent  contractor's  tax  liabilities.  Example  2  is  the  same 
as  Example  1 ,  except  that  the  independent  contractor  is  assumed  to  report  only  95  percent  of  her 
net  income  from  self-employment.  As  a  result  of  this  underreporting  by  five  percent,  the 
independent  contractor's  Federal  and  State  income  taxes  are  now  virtually  the  same  as  for  the 
employee,  although  the  Social  Security  tax  is  still  $11,  or  nine  percent,  higher.*  At  greater 
levels  of  noncompliance,  the  taxes  of  the  independent  contractors  would  be  lower  than  those  of 
the  fully  compliant  employee.^ 

Example  3-Trade  or  Business  Expenses.  Employee  business  expenses  can  also 
differentially  affect  the  tax  treatment  of  employees  and  independent  contractors.  Example  3 
(Table  2-4)  is  similar  to  Example  1,  except  that  the  worker  is  now  assumed  to  have  expenses 
equivalent  to  ten  percent  of  total  compensation.  The  independent  contractor  is  able  to  deduct  all 
of  these  expenses  in  calculating  income  subject  to  both  income  and  Social  Security  and  Medicare 
taxes.  In  contrast,  the  employee's  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  are  not  adjusted  at  all  to 
reflect  these  expenses.  For  income  tax  purposes,  these  expenses  may  be  reflected  if  the  worker 
itemizes  deductions  on  her  income  tax  return,  but,  even  then,  they  are  only  deductible  to  the 
extent  that  they,  together  with  other  miscellaneous  deductions,  exceed  two  percent  of  her 


*  See  Table  5-3  for  a  summary  of  the  compliance  rates  found  in  one  recent  IRS  study. 

"^  See  Table  5-2  for  a  summary  of  compliance  rates  actually  found  in  one  IRS  study.  For 
technical  services  workers  in  that  study,  reporting  of  gross  receipts  was  97.0  percent,  and 
reporting  of  net  income  {i.e.,  gross  receipts  minus  business  expenses)  was  83.4  percent. 


Table  2-3 

EXAMPLE  2:   COMPARISON  OF  INCOME  AND  TAXATION  OF  $1,000  OF  TOTAL  COMPENSATION 
FOR  AN  EMPLOYEE  OR  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR. 
WORKER  WITH  A  TYPICAL  MIX  OF  FRINGE  BENEFITS,  NO  WORKER  EXPENSES, 
AND  5  PERCENT  NON-COMPLIANCE  BY  THE  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR 


Employer/Employee 


Employer   Employee    Combined 


Independent  Contractor 
Service 
Recipient       Worker  Combined 


Money  Payment  or  Regular  Salary 733             733  1,000           1.000 

Holiday/Vacation/Sick  Pay 73 73  

MONEY  PAYMENT  OR  TOTAL  SALARY io6             156"  1,000          1,000 

Employer-Paid  Taxes  and  BeneFits 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION  TO  WORKER 1.000                                                       1,000 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION 1,000                                                       1.000 

TAXES  AND  STATUTORY  BENEFITS.  TOTAL 74  331  405  0             404  404 

Federal  Income  Tax   1/    2/  209  209  0  209  209 

Sute  Income  Tax   1/3/  60  60  0  61  61 

Social  Security  (FICA/SECA)  4/  62  62  123  134  134 

Unemployment  Insurance  (FUTA  and  State)  SI  4  4 

Workers'  Compensation  6/  8  8 

VOLUNTARY  FRINGE  BENEFITS.  TOTAL 120  0  120  0  120  120 

Retirement/Keogh  Contribution  60  60  60  60 

Health  Insurance  Premiums  60  60  60  60 

WORKER  EXPENSES  (DEDUCTIBLE),  TOTAL 0  0  0  0 

Income  and  Social  Security  Tax  Compliance  Rate 100.0%  95.0% 

For  Worker 

Total  Compensation  less 

Taxes  and  Statutory  Benefits 595  596 

Money  Income  less 

Worker  Taxes 475  596 

Money  Income  less  Worker  Taxes, 

Worker-Paid  Benefits,  and  Worker  Expenses 475  476 

For  Employer  (Service  Recipient) 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient  less  taxes 0  0 

Department  of  the  Treasury 
Office  of  Tax  Analysis 

Note:   Detail  may  not  add  to  totals  due  to  rounding. 

1/     Taxable  amount  is  money  payment  to  the  worker  less  deductions  consistent  with  worker  status.   Employee  has  itemized  deductions 
for  state  income  taxes  (for  federal  tax  purposes  but  not  for  state  tax  purposes)  and  for  worker  expenses  in  excess  of  2  percent  of 
adjusted  gross  income  (assumed  to  be  4  percent  of  money  payment).    Independent  contractor  deducts  worker  expenses,  Keogli 
contributions,  25  percent  of  health  insurance  premium,  and  50  percent  of  SECA  tax. 

2/       28  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  34  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

3/      7.5  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  8  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

4/       7.65  percent  rate  for  the  employee  and  for  the  employer,  or  14. 12955  percent  rate  ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%)  paid  entirely  by  the 
independent  contractor. 

5/       Assumed  to  be  0.55  percent  of  total  salary. 

6/       Assumed  to  be  1  percent  of  total  salary. 


Table  2-4 

EXAMPLE  3:   COMPARISON  OF  INCOME  AND  TAXATION  OF  $1,000  OF  TOTAL  COMPENSATION 
FOR  AN  EMPLOYEE  OR  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR, 
WORKER  WFTH  A  TYPICAL  MIX  OF  FRINGE  BENEFITS 
AND  WORKER  EXPENSES  OF  10  PERCENT 


Employer/Employee 


Employer   Employee   Combined 


Independent  Contractor 
Service 
Recipient       Worker  Combined 


Money  Payment  or  Regular  Salary 733  733  1,000  1,000 

Holiday/Vacation/Sick  Pay 73 73_  

MONEY  PAYMENT  OR  TOTAL  SALARY 806  806  1,000  1,000 

Employer-Paid  Taxes  and  Benefits 194 194  

TOTAL  COMPENSATION  TO  WORKER 1.000  1,000 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient 0 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION 1,000  1,000 

TAXES  AND  STATUTORY  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 74  308  382  0              381  381 

Federal  Income  Tax    1/    2/  191  191  0              197  197 

State  Income  Tax    1/3/  55  55  0                57  57 

Social  Security  (FICA/SECA)  4/  62  62  123                                        127  127 

Unemployment  Insurance  (FUTA  and  State)   5/  4  4 

Workers'  Compensation   6/  8  8 

VOLUNTARY  FRINGE  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 120  0  120  0  120  120 

Retirement/Keogh  Contribution  60  60  60  60 

Health  Insurance  Premiums  60  60  60  60 

WORKER  EXPENSES  (DEDUCTIBLE).  TOTAL 0  100  100  0  .100  100 

Income  and  Social  Security  Tax  Compliance  Rate 100.0%  100.09! 

For  Worker 

Total  Compensation  less 

Taxes  and  Statutory  Benefits 618  619 

Money  Income  less 

Worker  Taxes 498  619 

Money  Income  less  Worker  Taxes, 

Worker-Paid  Benefits ,  and  Worker  Expenses 398  399 

For  Employer  (Service  Recipient) 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient  less  Taxes 0  0 

Department  of  the  Treasury 
Office  of  Tax  Analysis 

Note:    Detail  may  not  add  to  totals  due  to  rounding. 

1/      Taxable  amount  is  money  payment  to  the  worker  less  deductions  consistent  with  worker  status.    Employee  has  itemized  deductions 
for  state  income  taxes  (for  federal  tax  purposes  but  not  for  state  tax  purposes)  and  for  worker  expenses  in  excess  of  2  percent  of 
adjusted  gross  income  (assumed  to  be  4  percent  of  money  payment).   Independent  contractor  deducts  worker  expenses,  Keogli 
contributions,  25  percent  of  health  insurance  premium,  and  50  percent  of  SECA  tax. 

2/       28  jjercent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  34  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

3/       7.5  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  8  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

4/      7.65  percent  rate  for  the  employee  and  for  the  employer,  or  14. 12955  percent  rate  ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%)  paid  entirely  by  the 
independent  contractor. 

5/       Assumed  to  be  0.55  percent  of  total  salary. 

6/       Assumed  to  be  1  percent  of  total  salary. 


22 

adjusted  gross  income  from  all  sources.  In  Example  3,  it  is  assumed  that  the  effective  deduction 
floor  is  equivalent  to  four  percent  of  total  compensation,  so  that  only  the  excess  over  that  level 
is  deductible.  As  a  result  of  the  differential  treatment  of  these  trade  or  business  expenses,  the 
extra  Federal  income  tax  paid  by  the  independent  contractor  has  been  reduced  from  $12  to  $6, 
and  the  extra  State  income  tax  has  been  reduced  from  $4  to  $2.  The  extra  Social  Security  tax 
has  been  reduced  from  $18  to  $4,  however. 

Effect  of  Expenses  on  Noncompliance  Rates.  The  noncompliance  rate  for  net  income 
generally  does  not  equal  the  noncompliance  rate  for  gross  income.  The  rates  are  equal  only 
when  gross  income  and  net  income  are  equal  because  the  worker  has  no  trade  or  business 
expenses.  When  the  worker  has  such  expenses,  the  noncompliance  rate  for  net  income  exceeds 
the  noncompliance  rate  for  gross  income.  The  higher  the  level  of  expenses,  the  greater  the 
difference  between  noncompliance  rates  becomes.  Consider  a  worker  with  gross  income  of 
$1,000  and  expenses  of  $400;  net  income  is  $600.  If  the  worker  understates  gross  income  by 
ten  percent,  net  income  will  be  understated  by  16.7  percent.* 

The  noncompliance  rate  for  net  income  and  the  difference  between  the  gross  and  net 
income  compliance  rates  will  be  greater  if  the  worker  can  use  the  existence  of  trade  or  business 
expenses  to  understate  net  income  further  by  overstating  expenses.  In  the  example  above,  if  the 
worker  both  understates  gross  income  by  ten  percent  and  overstates  expenses  by  ten  percent,  net 
income  will  be  understated  by  23.3  percent.' 

Example  4-Statutorily-Required  Fringe  Benefits  Only.  In  Example  4  (Table  2-5),  the 
employer  is  assumed  not  to  provide  any  voluntary  fringe  benefits.  In  addition  to  salary,  the 
employer  pays  only  for  the  employer  portion  of  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  the  Federal 
and  State  unemployment  taxes,  and  workers'  compensation  insurance  premiums.  Since  fringe 
benefits,  which  cause  the  disparity  between  Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  levels  for 
employees  and  independent  contractors,  have  been  greatly  reduced,  there  is  only  a  $1  difference 
in  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  between  the  employee  and  the  independent  contractor. 
The  additional  Federal  income  tax  paid  by  the  independent  contractor  is  $4,  and  the  additional 


*   Net  and  gross  income  are  both  understated  by  $100.    The  noncompliance  rate  on  gross 
income  is  $100/$1,000;  the  noncompliance  rate  on  net  income  is  $100/$600. 

'  Gross  income  is  understated  by  $100.   Expenses  are  overstated  by  ten  percent,  or  $40. 
Net  income  is  understated  by  $140.  The  noncompliance  rate  on  net  income  is  $140/$600. 


Table  2-5 

EXAMPLE  4:   COMPARISON  OF  INCOME  AND  TAXATION  OF  $1,000  OF  TOTAL  COMPENSATION 
FOR  EMPLOYEE  OR  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR. 
WORKER  WITH  ONLY  STATUTORY  BENEFITS  AND  NO  WORKER  EXPENSES 


Employer/Employee 


Independent  Contractor 


Service 


Employer   Employee   Combined  Recipient       Worker  Combined 


Money  Payment  or  Regular  Salary 916  916  1.000  1,000 

HolidayA'acation/Sick  Pay 0 

MONEY  PAYMENT  OR  TOTAL  SALARY 916  916  1,000  1.000 

Employer-Paid  Taxes  and  Benefits 84 84 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION  TO  WORKER 1.000  1,000 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient 2 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION 1.000  1,000 

TAXES  AND  STATUTORY  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 84  376  460  0            452  452 

Federal  Income  Tax   1/    2/  237  237  0  241  241 

State  Income  Tax   1/3/  69  69  0  70  70 

Social  Security  (FICA/SECA)  4/  70  70  140  141  141 

Unemployment  Insurance  (FUTA  and  State)  5/  5  5 

Workers'  Compensation  6/  9  9 

VOLUNTARY  FRINGE  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 0  0  0  0 

Retirement/Keogh  Contribution  0  0 

Health  Insurance  Premiums  0  0 

WORKER  EXPENSES  (DEDUCTIBLE),  TOTAL 0  0  0  0 

Income  and  Social  Security  Tax  Compliance  Rate 100.0%  100.0% 

For  Worker 

Total  Compensation  less 

Taxes  and  Statutory  Benefits 540  548 

Money  Income  less 

Worker  Taxes 540  548 

Money  Income  less  Worker  Taxes, 

Worker-Paid  BenefiU,  and  Worker  Expenses 540  548 

For  Employer  (Service  Recipient) 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient  less  Taxes 0  0 

Department  of  the  Treasury 
Office  of  Tax  Analysis 

Note:   Detail  may  not  add  to  totals  due  to  rounding. 

1/     Taxable  amount  is  money  payment  to  the  worker  less  deductions  consistent  with  worker  status.   Employee  has  itemized  deductions 
for  state  income  taxes  (for  federal  tax  purposes  but  not  for  state  tax  purposes)  and  for  worker  expenses  in  excess  of  2  percent  of 
adjusted  gross  income  (assumed  to  be  4  percent  of  money  payment).   Independent  contractor  deducts  worker  expenses,  Keogh 
contributions,  25  percent  of  health  insurance  premium,  and  50  percent  of  SECA  tax. 

2/       28  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  34  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

3/       7.5  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  8  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

4/      7.65  percent  rate  for  the  employee  and  for  the  employer,  or  14. 12955  percent  rate  ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%)  paid  entirely  by  the 
independent  contractor. 

5/       Assumed  to  be  0.55  percent  of  total  salary. 

6/       Assumed  to  be  1  percent  of  total  salary. 


24 

State  income  tax  is  $1.    The  situation  illustrated  in  Example  4  is  typical  of  many  temporary 
employees,  whose  fringe  benefits  are  often  restricted  to  those  required  by  law.'° 

Note  that  in  Example  4,  as  a  result  of  higher  cash  wages  exactly  offsetting  the  reduction 
in  fringe  benefits,  both  workers'  total  current  tax  bills  have  increased  compared  with  the  workers 
in  Example  1.  For  the  employee,  the  sum  of  the  Federal  and  State  income  taxes  and  the 
combined  employer-employee  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  has  increased  by  $53,  or  13 
percent.  For  the  independent  contractor,  the  combined  bill  has  increased  by  $25,  or  six  percent. 

Example  5-Lower  Independent  Contractor  Compensation.  Example  5  (Table  2-6)  is 
similar  to  Example  4,  except  that  the  independent  contractor's  compensation  is  slightly  lower 
because  she  has  been  unable  to  negotiate  from  her  client  the  equivalent  of  the  value  of  the 
employer's  costs  for  workers'  compensation  and  unemployment  insurance  (i.e.,  her  bargaining 
power  is  lower  than  in  Example  4).  Since  this  wedge  between  total  employee  compensation  and 
total  payments  to  the  independent  contractor  is  small,  the  resulting  tax  differences  are  also  small. 
Because  the  independent  contractor  now  has  less  income,  her  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes 
are  now  slightly  lower  ($1)  than  those  paid  by  the  employer  and  the  employee.  Also,  the 
independent  contractor's  Federal  and  State  income  taxes  are  now  the  same  as  those  of  the 
employee.  However,  because  the  client  must  pay  income  tax  on  the  funds  it  has  retained,  the 
combined  income  taxes  of  the  independent  contractor  and  her  client  are  still  $6,  or  two  percent, 
higher  than  those  of  the  employee." 

Summary.  These  examples  illustrate  that  the  difference  in  income.  Social  Security  and 
Medicare  taxes  paid  by  employers  and  employees,  on  the  one  hand,  and  independent  contractors 
and  their  clients,  on  the  other,  on  the  same  amount  of  total  compensation  depends  on  the 
proportion  of  compensation  the  individual  takes  as  fringe  benefits,  the  extent  of  the  individual's 
work-related  expenses,  and  the  relative  compliance  of  employees  and  independent  contractors. 
With  typical  patterns  of  fringe  benefits  and  worker  expenses,  independent  contractors  and  their 
clients  tend  to  pay  higher  levels  of  taxes,  especially  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  than 


'°  U.S.  Department  of  Labor,  Bureau  of  Labor  Statistics,  BLS  Reports  on  its  First  Survey 
of  Pay  and  Employee  Benefits  in  the  Temporary  Help  Supply  Industry,  88-260,  page  8  (1988). 

"  Employees  with  substantial  trade  or  business  expenses  and  sufficient  bargaining  power 
may  be  able  to  negotiate  with  their  employers  to  structure  computer  and  auto  expenses  as 
required  business  expenses.  In  such  a  situation,  the  worker  would  still  be  subject  to  the  two- 
percent  floor,  but  would  be  able  to  deduct  expenses  that  would  normally  not  be  deductible. 


Table  2-6 

EXAMPLE  5:   COMPARISON  OF  INCOME  AND  TAXATION  OF  SI  .000  OF  TOTAL  COMPENSATION 
FOR  EMPLOYEE  OR  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR, 
WORKER  WITH  ONLY  STATUTORY  BENEFITS.  NO  WORKER  EXPENSES. 
AND  A  "WEDGE"  BETWEEN  EMPLOYEE  AND  INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTOR  TOTAL  COMPENSATION 


Employer/Employee 


Employer   Employee    Combined 


Independent  Contractor 
Service 
Recipient       Worker  Combined 


Money  Payment  or  Regular  Salary 916             916                                       986             986 

Holiday/Vacation/Sick  Pay 0 

MONEY  PAYMENT  OR  TOTAL  SALARY 916             916                                       986             986 

Employer-Paid  Taxes  and  BeneHts 84                                  84  

TOTAL  COMPENSATION  TO  WORKER 1,000                                                         986 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient 14 14 

TOTAL  COMPENSATION 1,000                                                   1,000 

TAXES  AND  STATUTORY  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 84  376  460  6            445  451 

Federal  Income  Tax   1/2/  237  237  4  237  242 

State  Income  Tax   1/3/  69  69  1  69  70 

Social  Security  (FICA/SECA)  4/  70  70  140  139  139 

Unemployment  Insurance  (FUTA  and  State)  5/  5  5 

Workers'  Compensation   6/  9  9 

VOLUNTARY  FRINGE  BENEFITS,  TOTAL 0  0  0  0 

Retirement/Keogh  Contribution  0  0 

Health  Insurance  Premiums  0  0 

WORKER  EXPENSES  (DEDUCTIBLE),  TOTAL 0  0  0  0 

Income  and  Social  Security  Tax  Compliance  Rate 100.0%  100.0% 

For  Worker 

Total  Compensation  less 

Taxes  and  Statutory  Benefits 540  541 

Money  Income  less 

Worker  Taxes 540  541 

Money  Income  less  Worker  Taxes, 

Worker-Paid  Benefits ,  and  Worker  Expenses 540  54 1 

For  Employer  (Service  Recipient) 

Retained  by  Service  Recipient  less  Taxes 0  9 

Department  of  the  Treasury 
Office  of  Tax  Analysis 

Note:    Detail  may  not  add  to  totals  due  to  rounding. 

1/     Taxable  amount  is  money  payment  to  the  worker  less  deductions  consistent  with  worker  status.    Employee  has  itemized  deductions 
for  state  income  taxes  (for  federal  tax  purposes  but  not  for  state  tax  purposes)  and  for  worker  expenses  in  excess  of  2  percent  of 
adjusted  gross  income  (assumed  to  be  4  percent  of  money  payment).   Independent  contractor  deducts  worker  expenses,  Keogh 
contributions,  25  percent  of  health  insurance  premium,  and  50  percent  of  SECA  tax. 

2/       28  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  34  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

3/       7.5  percent  rate  for  the  worker,  and  8  percent  rate  for  the  service  recipient. 

4/       7.65  percent  rate  for  the  employee  and  for  the  employer,  or  14. 12955  percent  rate  ([100%-7.65%]xl5.3%)  paid  entirely  by  the 
independent  contractor. 

5/       Assumed  to  be  0.55  percent  of  total  salary. 

6/       Assumed  to  be  1  percent  of  total  salary. 


26 

employees  and  employers,  provided  that  the  income  and  expenses  are  reported  correctly.'^ 
When  independent  contractors  receive  few  fringe  benefits  that  are  not  statutorily-required  (as  is 
typical  for  temporary  workers),  however,  and  have  few  or  no  trade  or  business  expenses,  they 
and  their  clients  may  pay  about  the  same  level  of  taxes  as  employees  and  employers,  provided 
that  the  income  and  expenses  are  reported  correctly. 

D.        Validity  of  Differences 

It  is  evident  from  the  preceding  discussion  that  a  mere  change  in  classification  of  an 
individual  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor  can  result  in  differences  in  the  total  tax 
liability  of  the  individual  and  the  service-recipient,  regardless  of  whether  there  has  been  any 
change  in  their  economic  circumstances.  While  such  differences  may  seem  arbitrary  or  unfair 
in  the  case  of  individuals  whose  relationship  with  a  service-recipient  places  them  close  to  the  line 
between  employee  and  independent  contractor  status,  these  differences  can  generally  be  justified 
for  more  "typical"  employees  and  independent  contractors.  For  example,  withholding,  the 
partial  disallowance  of  trade  or  business  expense  deductions,  and  the  imposition  of  additional 
business  purpose  requirements  on  those  deductions,  may  be  more  administratively  appropriate 
for  employees  than  independent  contractors,  on  the  assumption  that  independent  contractors 
typically  have  more  volatile  net  incomes  and  larger  trade  or  business  expenses,  and  typically 
change  jobs  more  frequently  than  employees.  Similarly,  the  special  treatment  accorded  to 
employee  fringe  benefits  under  the  Code,  and  the  special  protections  for  employees  found  in 
Federal  and  State  labor  laws,  may  be  justified  if  employees  typically  have  less  bargaining  power 
than  independent  contractors  and  are  more  dependent  on  a  single  business  for  their  livelihoods. 

Even  if  these  assumptions  regarding  "typical"  employees  and  independent  contractors  are 
correct,  the  fact  that  a  single  broad  distinction  is  drawn  under  the  Code  between  employees  and 
independent  contractors  means  that  some  "atypical"  individuals  may  not  be  treated  properly. 
For  example,  withholding  and  the  partial  disallowance  of  trade  or  business  expense  deductions 
may  not  be  appropriate  (except  as  a  compliance  measure)  for  an  employee  who  regularly  incurs 
large  expenses  and  changes  jobs  frequently:  in  such  situations  it  might  be  preferable  to  treat  the 
individual  as  an  employee  for  one  purpose  and  an  independent  contractor  for  another.  Similarly, 
independent  contractors  who  lack  significant  bargaining  power  or  financial  sophistication  may 
be  better  off  being  treated  as  employees  under  the  fringe  benefit  provisions  of  the  Code  and 
under  Federal  and  State  labor  laws.    Nevertheless,  the  costs  of  such  inappropriate  results  in 


'^    The  higher  levels  of  Social  Security  taxes  may  in  some  cases  result  in  a  comparable 
increase  in  Social  Security  benefits. 


27 

some  cases  must  be  balanced  against  the  benefits  of  maintaining  a  single  standard  that  applies 
for  all  purposes. 

Of  course,  it  may  be  that  these  assumptions  regarding  the  characteristics  of  "typical" 
employees  and  independent  contractors  are  not  generally  correct.  If  this  is  the  case,  and  the 
current  scheme  therefore  results  in  inappropriate  results  in  too  many  cases,  it  may  be  desirable 
to  develop  new  definitions  of  employee  or  even  to  reexamine  the  need  for  the  current-law 
distinctions  between  employees  and  independent  contractors.  For  example,  if  most  independent 
contractors  lack  the  means  or  the  foresight  to  provide  for  their  own  retirement  income  or  health 
insurance  coverage,  there  may  be  no  reason  to  limit  the  fringe  benefit  provisions  of  the  Code 
to  employees,  except  perhaps  in  the  case  of  wealthier  or  more  sophisticated  individuals. 
Similarly,  there  may  be  no  reason  for  the  differences  in  treatment  of  employees  and  independent 
contractors  with  respect  to  the  excludability  of  fringe  benefits  from  the  Social  Security  and 
Medicare  tax  base,  which  arose  at  a  time  when  fringe  benefits  made  up  only  a  small  portion  of 
total  income. 


CHAPTER  3:   ORIGINS  OF  SECTION  1706 

I.         SECTION  530 

In  the  late  1960s,  the  IRS  began  to  increase  its  employment  tax  enforcement  activities, 
which  had  previously  been  sporadic,  to  address  the  misclassification  of  employees  as  independent 
contractors.  Since,  as  noted  above,  independent  contractors  and  their  clients  at  that  time  faced 
significantly  lower  Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  rates  than  employers  and  employees,  such 
misclassification  was  perceived  to  produce  large  revenue  losses.  As  a  result  of  the  IRS'  action, 
the  number  of  reclassifications  increased  substantially."  Many  of  these  reclassifications 
resulted  in  large  assessments  against  the  employers  involved  for  employer  Social  Security, 
Medicare,  and  Federal  unemployment  insurance  taxes,  and  unwithheld  employee  Social  Security, 
Medicare,  and  income  taxes. 

Taxpayers  complained  to  Congress  that  the  reclassifications  amounted  to  a  change  of 
position  by  the  IRS  in  how  it  was  applying  the  common  law  tests  for  determining  an  individual's 
status  as  an  employee  or  an  independent  contractor."*  House  and  Senate  conferees  reporting 
on  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1976  urged  the  IRS  "not  to  apply  any  changed  position  or  any  newly 
stated  position  which  is  inconsistent  with  a  prior  general  audit  position  in  this  general  area  to 
past,  as  opposed  to  future[,]  taxable  years"  until  the  completion  of  a  study  by  the  Joint 
Committee  on  Taxation  on  the  independent  contractor  issue." 

The  Joint  Committee  asked  the  General  Accounting  Office  (GAG)  to  examine  the  IRS 
administration  of  employment  taxes.  This  study  was  completed  by  the  GAO  in  1977."^  The 
study  recommended  that  a  safe  harbor  test  of  independent  contractor  status  dealing  with 
situations  where  an  individual  carries  her  own  trade  or  business  be  added  to  Code,  and  that 


"  See  IRS  Annual  Reports  for  1971-1978. 

'*  See  Staff  of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Taxation,  96th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.,  General  Explanation 
of  the  Revenue  Act  of  1978,  300-01  (Comm.  Print  1979);  H.R.  Conf.  Rep.  No.  1800,  95th 
Cong.,  2d  Sess.  271  (1978);  H.R.  Rep.  No.  1748,  95th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  5-6  (1978);  S.  Rep. 
No.  938,  94th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  604  (1976). 

"  H.R.  Conf.  Rep.  No.  1515,  94th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  489  (1976). 

'*  GAO,  Tax  Treatment  of  Employees  and  Self-Employed  Persons  by  the  Internal  Revenue 
Service:  Problems  and  Solutions,  GGD-77-88  (1977). 

29 


30 

certain  other  changes  be  made  to  reduce  the  financial  burden  of  retroactive  employment  tax 
assessments.  The  study  also  found  that  employees  misclajsified  as  independent  contractors  on 
average  reported  96  percent  of  their  wages.  This  finding,  however,  was  based  on  payments  by 
a  sample  of  only  five  employers  involved  in  employment  tax  audits.*^  Noting  limitations  in 
the  GAO  sample,  the  IRS  undertook  its  own  study.  Based  on  payments  by  a  sample  of  2,600 
employers  to  7,109  individuals  that  it  had  previously  proposed  to  reclassify  as  wages,  the  IRS 
found  an  average  income  tax  reporting  compliance  rate  of  76.2  percent  and  an  average 
employment  tax  reporting  compliance  rate  of  70.0  percent.'*  It  also  found  that  compliance 
rates  varied  less  by  industry  than  by  the  size  of  payment  and  other  factors,  with  small  payments 
and  those  likely  to  have  been  made  in  cash  much  less  likely  to  be  reported. 

In  the  Revenue  Act  of  1978,  Congress,  without  mentioning  the  GAO  study,  provided 
statutory  relief  for  certain  taxpayers  involved  in  employment  tax  controversies  with  the  IRS. 
Section  530  of  the  Act  prohibits  the  IRS  from  challenging  an  employer's  treatment  of  an 
individual  as  an  independent  contractor  for  employment  tax  purposes  if  the  employer  (1)  has  a 
reasonable  basis  for  such  treatment  and  (2)  consistently  treats  the  individual,  and  any  other 
individual  holding  a  substantially  similar  position,  as  an  independent  contractor.''  Section  530 
does  not  merely  provide  relief  from  retroactive  assessments:  as  long  as  these  requirements  are 
met  with  respect  to  an  individual,  the  IRS  is  prevented  from  correcting  an  erroneous 
classification  of  that  individual.  Section  530  applies  solely  for  purposes  of  the  employment  tax 
provisions  of  the  Code  (e.g..  Social  Security,  Medicare,  unemployment  insurance  taxes,  and 
income  tax  withholding).  It  does  not  affect  an  individual's  classification  as  an  employee  for 
income  tax  purposes;  treatment  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  for  income  tax  purposes  may, 
however,  violate  the  consistency  requirement  noted  above  and  thereby  cause  the  employer  to  lose 


25. 


"  Id.  at  25  and  71.   A  larger  sample  showed  compliance  rates  of  only  87  percent.   Id.  at 


18 


See  id..  Appendix  V;  Hearings  Before  the  Subcommittee  on  Select  Revenue  Measures 
of  the  House  Ways  and  Means  Committee,  96th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.  (June  20,  1979)  (Statement  of 
Donald  C.  Lubick,  Assistant  Secretary  of  the  Treasury  (Tax  Policy)). 

''  Revenue  Act  of  1978,  Pub.  L.  No.  95-600,  §  530,  92  Stat.  2763,  2885  (1978).  These 
requirements  must  be  met  before  the  commencement  of  any  IRS  compliance  procedures  with 
respect  to  an  individual.   Rev.  Proc.  85-18,  §  3.03(C),  1985-1  C.B.  518. 


31 

protection  under  section  530.  Section  530  treats  reasonable  reliance  on  any  of  the  following  as 
a  reasonable  basis  for  treating  an  individual  as  an  independent  contractor: 

(1)  judicial  precedent,  published  rulings,  or  letter  rulings  or  technical  advice  memoranda 
issued  to  or  with  respect  to  the  taxpayer; 

(2)  a  past  IRS  audit  in  which  there  was  no  assessment  attributable  to  the  employment  tax 
treatment  of  the  individual  or  of  individuals  holding  positions  substantially  similar  to  that 
of  the  individual;  or 

(3)  a  long-standing  recognized  practice  of  a  significant  segment  of  the  industry  in  which  the 
individual  was  engaged. 

The  IRS  has  issued  a  series  of  revenue  procedures  since  1978  explaining  the  application  of 
section  530.^° 

Section  530  was  originally  described  as  an  interim  measure  to  provide  relief  until 
"Congress  ha[d]  adequate  time  to  resolve  the  many  complex  issues  involved  in  this  area",^'  and 
was  scheduled  to  expire  after  1979.  It  was  instead  extended  through  a  series  of  public  laws,  and 
was  made  permanent  in  the  Tax  Equity  and  Fiscal  Responsibility  Act  of  1982  (TEFRA).^^ 

n.        SECTION  3509 

In  TEFRA,  Congress  added  section  3509  to  the  Code  to  mitigate  the  problem  of  large 
retroactive  employment  tax  assessments  faced  by  employers  who  were  not  entitled  to  relief  under 
section  530."  Under  prior  law,  in  the  event  of  a  misclassification  an  employer  could  be  held 
liable  for  the  full  amount  of  unwithheld  income  taxes  and  the  unwithheld  employee  share  of 
Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes.  In  addition,  the  employer  remained  liable  for  Federal 
unemployment  insurance  tax  and  the  employer  share  of  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes. 


^°    Rev.  Proc.  78-35,  1978-2  C.B.  536,  was  issued  soon  after  enactment.    The  current 
version  is  Rev.  Proc.  85-18,  1985-1  C.B.  518. 

^'    Staff  of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Taxation,  96th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.,  General  Explanation 
of  the  Revenue  Act  of  1978,  300-01  (Comm.  Print  1979). 

22   Pub.  L.  No.  96-167,  §  9(d),  93  Stat.  1275,  1278  (1979);  Pub.  L.  No.  96-541,  §  1,  94 
Stat.  3204  (1980);  Pub.  L.  No.  97-248,  §  269(c),  96  Stat.  325,  552-53  (1982). 

^  Pub.  L.  No.  97-248,  §  270(a),  96  Stat.  325,  553  (1982). 


32 

Penalties  and  interest  could  also  be  assessed.  The  employer  bore  the  burden  of  proving  that  the 
employee  had  paid  income  and  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  on  the  wages  in  order  to 
abate  any  liability.^ 

Section  3509  generally  limits  an  employer's  liability  for  failure  to  withhold  income, 
Social  Security  or  Medicare  taxes  on  payments  made  to  an  individual  whom  it  misclassified  as 
an  independent  contractor  to  1.5  percent  of  the  wages  paid  to  the  individual  plus  20  percent  of 
the  employee  portion  of  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  on  those  wages."  Section  3509 
has  no  effect  on  an  employer's  own  liability  for  Federal  unemployment  insurance  taxes  or  the 
employer  portion  of  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes;  it  also  does  not  apply  in  cases  of 
intentional  disregard  of  the  withholding  requirements.^*  As  a  quid  pro  quo  for  limiting  the 
employer's  liability  for  failure  to  withhold  employee  taxes,  section  3509  prohibits  the  employer 
from  reducing  its  liability  by  recovering  any  tax  determined  under  the  section  from  the 
employee,  and  gives  the  employer  no  credit  for  any  income  taxes  ultimately  paid  the 
employee.^ 

m.       SECTION  1706 

Section  530  affects  different  taxpayers  differently,  depending  on  whether  they  satisfy  the 
conditions  for  relief  contained  therein.  In  particular,  some  taxpayers  that  have  consistently 
misclassified  their  employees  as  independent  contractors  are  entitled  to  relief  under  section  530, 
while  other  taxpayers  in  the  same  industry  (that,  for  example,  have  sometimes  taken  more 


^  In  many  cases,  the  misclassified  employee  had  paid  SECA  taxes  on  the  wages.  The 
employer  could  not  require  the  employee  to  provide  evidence  of  this  payment,  however. 

"  If  the  employer  did  not  comply  with  the  information  reporting  requirements  associated 
with  the  treatment  of  an  individual  as  an  independent  contractor,  these  percentages  are  doubled 
to  3.0  and  40  percent,  respectively. 

^*  If  an  employer's  liability  is  determined  under  section  3509,  the  employee  is  liable  for  the 
entire  amount  of  unwithheld  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  unreduced  by  any  amount  paid 
by  the  employer.    Rev.  Rul.  86-111,  1986-2  C.B.  176. 

"  Code  §  3509(d)(1).  In  some  instances,  an  employer  would  be  better  off  under  the  old 
rules,  e.g.,  if  it  can  establish  that  its  workers  have  paid  their  income  taxes  in  full  despite  its 
failure  to  withhold,  and  therefore  have  its  liability  abated.  Section  3509  is  a  mandatory 
provision,  however. 


33 

conservative  positions  on  classification  issues)  are  not,  because  they  cannot  satisfy  the 
consistency  requirements  of  the  section. 

In  the  mid-1980s,  some  employers  in  the  technical  services  industry  complained  that  this 
difference  in  treatment  under  section  530  created  an  unfair  advantage  for  certain  of  their 
competitors.    According  to  the  staff  of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Taxation, 

Congress  was  informed  that  many  employers  in  the  technical  services  industry 
that  did  not  qualify  for  relief  under  section  530  nonetheless  had  claimed  that  their 
workers  were  independent  contractors,  despite  the  fact  that  such  workers  would 
be  classified  as  employees  under  the  common-law  test.  It  is  further  contended 
that  some  of  these  employers  were  relying  on  erroneous  interpretations  of  section 
530,  while  others  simply  perceived  that  the  IRS  would  not  aggressively  enforce 
employment  tax  issues.^* 

The  dispute  was  primarily  between  two  groups  of  taxpayers,  both  of  which  were  engaged  in  the 
business  of  arranging  for  the  provision  of  services  by  technical  services  personnel  to  other 
companies.  One  group  (sometimes  called  "technical  service  firms")  generally  treated  the 
service-providers  as  their  employees,  and  they  argued  that  the  other  group  (sometimes  called 
"brokerage  firms"  or  "job-shops")  achieved  unfair  cost  savings  by  treating  the  service-providers 
as  independent  contractors.^'  As  explained  in  Chapter  2,  however,  misclassification  of  an 
employee  as  an  independent  contractor  does  not  necessarily  result  in  any  cost  savings  unless  the 
misclassification  is  accompanied  by  underreporting  of  income  or  similar  compliance  problems 
by  the  independent  contractors,  or  unless  the  client  is  able  to  pay  the  independent  contractor  less 
than  the  sum  of  the  cash  compensation  and  fringe  benefits  it  would  have  paid  to  an  employee. 

As  a  result  of  these  complaints.  Congress  in  TRA  1986  excluded  taxpayers  that  broker 
the  services  of  engineers,  designers,  drafters,  computer  programmers,  systems  analysts  and 
"other  similarly  skilled  workers  engaged  in  a  similar  line  of  work"  from  the  safe  harbor 


2*  Staff  of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Taxation,  100th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.,  General  Explanation 
of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986,  1344  (Comm.  Print  1987). 

^'  The  first  group  is  represented  in  part  by  two  trade  associations,  ADAPSO  and  the 
National  Technical  Services  Association  (NTSA).  The  second  group  is  represented  in  part  by 
the  National  Association  of  Computer  Consultant  Businesses  (NACCB). 


34 

provided  by  section  530,  effective  for  payments  made  after  December  31,  1986.'*'  Section 
1706  applies  exclusively  to  multi-party  situations,  i.e.,  those  involving  (1)  technical  services 
workers,  (2)  a  company  that  uses  the  workers,  and  (3)  a  firm  that  supplies  the  workers.  The 
effect  of  section  1706  is  to  deny  relief  solely  to  the  firm  that  supplies  the  workers.  Section  1706 
did  not  affect  the  application  of  section  3509  to  such  firms. 

Congress  may  have  believed  that  the  denial  of  section  530  relief  to  this  group  of 
taxpayers  would  cause  most  or  all  technical  services  workers  to  be  reclassified  as  employees.^' 
Section  1706  does  not,  however,  actually  require  that  the  individuals  listed  in  the  provision  be 
treated  as  employees:  it  merely  requires  them  to  be  classified  as  employees  or  independent 
contractors  for  employment  tax  purposes  under  the  usual  common  law  tests,  and  permits  the  IRS 
to  issue  guidance  with  respect  to  such  classification.'^ 

Since  the  enactment  of  section  1706,  the  IRS  has  increased  its  enforcement  activity  in  the 
employment  tax  area  across  the  board,  including  the  technical  services  industry.  It  has  also 
issued  guidance  on  the  proper  classification  of  technical  services  workers  as  employees  or 
independent  contractors.'' 


30 


Pub.  L.  No.  99-514,  §  1706,  100  Stat.  2095,  2781  (1986). 


"  See  H.R.  Conf.  Rep.  No.  841,  99th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  11-834  (1986);  132  Cong.  Rec. 
S8088-89  (June  20,  1986)  (floor  Statement  by  Sen.  Moynihan  introducing  predecessor  to  section 
1706). 

'^  Notice  87-19,  1987-1  C.B.  455.  As  described  in  footnote  57,  however,  there  was  some 
initial  confusion  over  this  point  after  the  enactment  of  section  1706. 


33 


Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296. 


PART  THREE 


DISCUSSION  OF  ISSUES 


CHAPTER  4:   GENERAL  POLICY  ISSUES 

I.         OVERVIEW 

Differences  in  treatment  between  employees  and  independent  contractors  under  Federal 
and  State  tax  and  other  laws  were  described  in  Chapter  2.  This  chapter  addresses  the  policy 
issues  underlying  these  differences  in  treatment.  This  report  proceeds  from  the  assumption  that 
the  government's  basic  role  is  to  maintain  the  efficiency  of  labor  markets  by  not  interfering  in 
the  natural  diversity  of  firm/worker  arrangements  unless  specific  policy  goals  require 
intervention.  The  source  of  this  diversity  and  its  importance  to  the  efficient  functioning  of  labor 
markets  is  discussed  in  Section  II  of  this  chapter.  Neutrality  in  the  tax  treatment  of  employees 
and  independent  contractors,  addressed  in  Section  HI,  in  most  circumstances  is  necessary  to 
maintain  the  efficiency  of  labor  markets  and  is  required  to  insure  tax  equity  between  the  two 
groups  of  workers.  These  tax  policy  issues  are  illustrated  using  the  examples  presented  in 
Chapter  2.  An  additional  goal  of  tax  policy,  addressed  in  Section  IV,  is  to  minimize  tax 
compliance  costs  for  firms,  workers,  and  tax  administration  agencies  while  maximizing  taxpayer 
compliance.  Finally,  the  non-tax  policies  of  the  Federal  and  State  governments  affecting  labor 
markets  are  described  in  Section  V. 

n.        EFFICIENCY  OF  LABOR  MARKETS 

Well-functioning  labor  markets  have  a  diversity  of  arrangements  between  workers  and 
firms.  The  diversity  arises  naturally  from  differences  in  workers'  skills  and  preferences  and 
differences  in  firms'  organizations  and  production  processes.  Workers  search  out  firms  that 
offer  arrangements  that  best  match  the  worker's  skills  and  preferences.  Likewise,  firms  search 
out  workers  whose  skills  and  preferences  best  match  the  firms'  needs.  Searching  by  workers 
and  firms  is  accomplished  through  labor  markets,  which  may  be  informal  or  well  organized. 
However  organized,  the  more  efficiently  labor  markets  work— that  is,  the  more  closely  workers' 
skills  and  preferences  are  matched  to  firms'  needs-the  greater  will  be  workers'  real  income  and 
firms'  productivity. 

A.        Arrangements  Between  Workers  and  Firms 

Workers'  Skills  and  Preferences.  The  significant  differences  in  the  level  and  range  of 
workers'  skills  are  important  determinants  of  the  occupations  and  industries  that  workers  enter, 
as  well  as  the  particular  firms  for  which  they  choose  to  work.  There  are  also  significant 
differences  in  preferences  across  workers.     For  example,   some  workers  prefer  a  stable 

37 


38 

relationship  with  a  firm,  with  a  low  risk  of  being  laid  off,  while  other  workers  prefer  greater 
variety  in  their  work  or  greater  autonomy  over  their  work,  than  could  normally  be  provided  by 
a  single  employer.  Other  things  being  the  same,  workers  with  the  first  set  of  preferences  are 
more  likely  to  enter  long-term  employer/employee  arrangements  with  firms.  Workers  with  the 
second  set  of  preferences,  in  contrast,  are  more  likely  to  work  as  independent  contractors  for 
a  number  of  firms  (service-recipients),  perhaps  working  for  none  of  the  firms  for  any  extended 
period  of  time,  and  perhaps  working  for  more  than  one  simultaneously.  It  is  important  to 
recognize  that  these  differences  in  arrangements  between  workers  and  firms  would  arise  in  a 
well-functioning  labor  market  even  in  the  absence  of  any  government  policies  that  affect  the 
labor  market.  The  different  arrangements  exist  because  they  are  to  the  mutual  benefit  of 
workers  and  firms. 

Workers'  preferences  vary  in  many  other  respects.  Workers  may  differ  in  their 
preferences  about  the  timing  of  work.  For  example,  some  workers  may  want  to  alternate 
between  long  periods  of  intense  work  effort  and  leisure  rather  than  working  conventional  40- 
hour  weeks. 

Workers  may  also  have  different  preferences  over  the  form  of  compensation  they  receive. 
Workers  may  prefer  cash  compensation  because  they  place  a  low  value  on  the  fringe  benefits 
supplied  by  the  employer,  or  because  employers  provide  more  of  the  fringe  benefits  than 
workers  prefer.  For  example,  some  workers  may  consider  themselves  unlikely  to  need  medical 
care,  so  place  little  value  on  employer-paid  health  insurance.  Other  workers  may  already  have 
health  insurance  coverage  through  a  spouse's  employer  and  as  an  employee  be  unable  to  decline 
the  coverage  and  receive  the  employer's  savings  in  the  form  of  cash  compensation.  Workers 
may  also  value  pensions  quite  differently.  A  worker  who  knows  she  will  change  employers 
before  eligibility  for  pension  benefits  becomes  vested  would  place  no  value  on  the  employer's 
pension  contributions.  Each  of  these  preferences  increases  the  likelihood  that  a  worker  would 
prefer  to  be  an  independent  contractor.** 

Finally,  workers  may  differ  in  their  aversion  to  possible  health  and  safety  risks  associated 
with  certain  jobs.  Since  the  insurability  of  such  risks  are  quite  different  for  employees  and 
independent  contractors,  workers  who  are  risk-averse  are  more  likely  to  be  employees. 


*•  Note  that  cafeteria  plans  blur  the  distinction  between  the  benefit  flexibility  of  employees 
and  independent  contractors. 


39 

Finns'  Organization  and  Production  Processes.  Just  as  individuals  have  preferences 
about  the  characteristics  of  firms,  firms  have  preferences  about  the  characteristics  of  workers. 
These  preferences  are  determined  by  a  firm's  organization  and  production  processes  and 
therefore  vary  widely  across  firms.  A  firm's  preference  for  workers  determines  the  mix  of 
worker  skills  and  preferences  best  suited  to  the  firm. 

Firms  may  differ  in  the  amount  of  firm-specific  knowledge  they  require  of  their  workers. 
Firms  that  require  relatively  little  firm-specific  knowledge  may  be  less  willing  to  make  long-term 
employment  commitments  to  their  workers  than  firms  that  require  relatively  high  levels.  Firms 
may  also  have  different  costs  of  providing  fringe  benefits  to  their  employees;  larger  firms 
generally  can  provide  benefits  at  lower  costs. 

Variability  in  the  demand  for  their  product  may  also  differ  among  firms.  Firms 
experiencing  greater  variability  may  be  less  willing  to  make  long-term  employment  commitments 
to  their  workers,  or  at  least  to  some  of  their  workers,  than  firms  with  relatively  more  stable 
product  demand.  Firms  may  differ  in  the  production  processes  they  use  to  produce  similar 
goods,  leading  to  differences  in  the  most  suitable  skill  levels  of  their  workers.  Differences  in 
the  way  that  firms  organize  themselves  also  can  result  in  differences  in  the  firms'  abilities  to 
determine  whether  their  workers  actually  accomplish  the  tasks  for  which  they  are  paid.  Firms 
with  higher  monitoring  costs  may  hire  those  workers  they  believe  will  require  less  monitoring 
and  supervision,  or  workers  who  are  more  willing  to  be  monitored. 

Arrangements  Between  Workers  and  Firms.  The  differences  in  workers'  skills  and 
preferences  and  in  firms'  organization  and  production  processes  will  lead  to  a  diversity  of 
arrangements  between  workers  and  firms.  These  differences  in  workers  and  firms  are  found  in 
numerous  combinations,  so  that  a  simple  characterization  of  the  diversity  in  firm/worker 
arrangements  is  not  possible. 

Generally,  firms  that  demand  a  high  degree  of  control  over  their  production  process  or 
require  workers  to  have  a  high  level  of  firm-specific  knowledge  are  more  likely  to  enter  into 
long-term  employer/employee  arrangements  with  workers.  Such  arrangements  are  also  more 
likely  for  firms  that  have  a  sufficient  scale  to  provide  fringe  benefits  to  workers  at  a  lower  cost 
than  the  worker  faces  purchasing  similar  benefits  directly.  The  workers  who  enter  such 
arrangements  are  likely  to  be  more  risk-averse,  or  to  have  higher  preferences  for  fringe  benefits. 
Conversely,  firms  that  can  provide  fringe  benefits  only  at  high  costs  or  that  have  high  costs  of 
monitoring  and  supervising  workers  are  more  likely  to  prefer  independent  contractor 
arrangements  with  workers.     Firms  are  also  more  likely  to  enter  independent  contractor 


40 

arrangements  in  circumstances  where  they  have  a  high  degree  of  variability  over  time  in  their 
need  for  workers  with  specific  skills.  The  workers  who  enter  such  arrangements  generally 
prefer  more  variety  and  autonomy,  greater  flexibility  in  scheduling  work,  and  more  cash 
compensation  than  they  would  receive  as  employees. 

Although  firms  generally  enter  into  arrangements  with  workers  directly,  third  parties  may 
be  involved  in  certain  circumstances.  For  example,  short-term  arrangements  for  experienced 
or  higher-skilled  workers  are  often  a  small  segment  of  these  labor  markets,  so  the  cost  to  firms 
and  workers  of  locating  each  other  and  making  matches  may  be  quite  high.  Third  parties  such 
as  temporary  worker  organizations  and  brokers  reduce  such  costs  by  gathering  the  necessary 
information  and  making  it  available  to  firms  and  workers. 

B.        Government  Policy 

The  diversity  of  arrangements  between  workers  and  firms  reflects  the  outcome  of  well 
functioning  labor  markets.  This  report  proceeds  from  the  assumption  that  a  fundamental  goal 
of  government  policy  should  be  to  maintain  the  efficiency  of  labor  markets,  which  generally 
requires  noninterference  with  diversity.  Government  intervention  in  labor  markets  is  warranted 
only  in  those  relatively  narrow  and  well-defined  instances  in  which  imperfections  in  the  markets 
result  in  inefficiencies  or  in  which  overriding  social  goals  can  be  achieved,  cost  effectively, 
through  such  intervention.  Section  V  of  this  chapter  briefly  discusses  such  government 
interventions. 

m.   NEUTRALITY  IN  TAX  TREATMENT 

A.        Maintaining  Labor  Market  Efficiency 

Tax  treatment  that  is  neutral  between  employee  and  independent  contractor  status  is 
necessary  to  maintain  labor  market  efficiency.  Tax  treatment  that  is  not  neutral  creates  artificial 
incentives  for  workers  to  be  classified  as  employees  rather  than  independent  contractors,  or  vice 
versa.  Although  particular  firms  and  workers  may  gain  by  responding  to  such  artificial 
incentives,  the  economy  as  a  whole  does  not;  aggregate  labor  market  efficiency  is  reduced,  as 
are  aggregate  worker  real  income  and  firm  production. 

Determining  the  efficiency  effects  of  section  1706  on  the  market  for  technical  services 
workers  is  difficult  because  the  underlying  efficiency  of  the  market  to  which  section  1706  applies 
is  unknown,  and  because  that  market  had  already  been  affected  by  prior  legislation  by  the  time 


41 

section  1706  was  enacted.^*  Thus,  the  previous  efficiency  of  the  market  could  not  be  taken  for 
granted. 

Determining  the  efficiency  effect  of  section  1706  is  also  complicated  by  the  fact  that 
section  1706  is  limited  to  situations  involving  a  third-party  broker.  The  limitation  creates  a 
separate  category  of  workers  for  employment  tax  purposes;  depending  on  the  effect  of  prior 
legislation,  the  limitation  could  cause  a  non-neutrality  in  the  market. 

Section  1706  may  also  have  indirectly  affected  worker  classification.  Publicity 
surrounding  section  1706  made  workers  and  firms  aware  of  the  common  law  tests  and  the 
correct  interpretation  of  section  530.  Workers  and  firms  that  had  incorrectly  believed  that 
section  530  required  certain  workers  to  be  classified  as  independent  contractors  learned  that  it 
did  not.  At  the  same  time,  by  removing  the  relief  in  section  530  from  employer  penalties  for 
misclassifying  technical  services  workers  as  independent  contractors,  section  1706  increased  the 
risk  to  some  employers  of  misclassification. 

It  is  reasonably  certain  that  section  1706  reduced  efficiency  in  some  cases  and  increased 
it  in  others.  There  is  not  enough  information,  however,  to  reach  any  conclusions  about  the 
overall  effect  of  section  1706  on  labor  market  efficiency. 

The  TAMRA  conferees  requested  an  evaluation  of  the  extent  to  which  Section  1706  has 
had  a  chilling  effect  on  the  ability  of  technical  services  personnel  to  get  work.  Assuming  that, 
prior  to  the  enactment  of  section  1706,  the  compensation  level  of  technical  services  workers  did 
not  depend  on  their  worker  classification  (although  the  compensation  mix  may  have  varied), 
section  1706  should  not  have  affected  the  total  demand  for  technical  services  workers.  As  long 
as  the  total  compensation  of  independent  contractors  and  employees  is  the  same  (although 
perhaps  paid  in  different  forms),  there  is  no  reason  to  expect  the  total  demand  for  technical 
services  workers  to  decline. 

Although  section  1706  probably  did  not  reduce  the  overall  demand  for  technical  services 
workers,  it  may  have  resulted  in  some  workers  being  unable  to  find  work  with  their  accustomed 
form  of  compensation  and  working  conditions.   Removing  the  safe  harbor  provision  of  section 


^^  The  prior  legislation  includes  income  and  employment  tax  and  labor  law,  section  530 
restrictions  on  issuing  guidance  about  classification  under  employment  laws,  and  section  3509 
reductions  in  employer  costs  for  misclassification.  Each  of  these  pieces  of  legislation  may  have 
reduced  or  increased  the  underlying  market  efficiency. 


42 

530  for  technical  services  workers  focused  employers'  attention  on  the  need  to  classify  workers 
correctly.  Some  independent  contractors  may  have  been  able  to  continue  their  current  work  only 
as  employees.  If  the  classification  change  required  the  workers  to  accept  a  package  of  fringe 
benefits  in  lieu  of  some  amount  of  cash  compensation,  the  value  to  them  of  their  entire 
compensation  package  may  have  changed.  They  would  have  been  better  off  to  the  extent  that 
they  considered  the  fringe  benefit  package  and  its  accompanying  tax-preferred  benefits  more 
valuable  than  the  loss  in  cash  income.  For  example,  workers  who  would  previously  have 
preferred  to  be  classified  as  employees,  but  were  not  because  of  resistance  from  service- 
recipients,  would  be  better  off.  Conversely,  workers  who  did  not  find  the  substituted  fringe 
benefit  package  more  valuable  may  have  found  the  value  of  their  income  reduced.  Similarly, 
workers  who  would  not  have  preferred  to  be  classified  as  employees  include  those  with 
considerable  trade  or  business  expenses,  whose  opportunity  to  deduct  these  expenses  would  have 
become  constrained,  and  those  who  tended  to  understate  receipts  or  overstate  deductions.  In 
addition,  workers  whose  classification  was  questionable  and  who  were  used  to  working  through 
brokers  may  have  found  that  work  as  independent  contractors  could  no  longer  be  secured 
through  a  broker;  these  workers  may  have  been  able  to  continue  work  as  independent  contractors 
by  contacting  service-recipients  directiy. 

B.        Tax  Equity 

Equitable  tax  treatment  requires  that  taxpayers  in  equivalent  situations,  with  the  same 
incomes,  be  taxed  equally.  Thus,  providing  equivalent  tax  treatment  to  employees  and  indepen- 
dent contractors  is  required  to  insure  tax  equity  between  the  two  groups  of  workers.  The 
examples  presented  in  Chapter  2  can  be  used  to  illustrate  potential  inequities  in  the  tax  treatment 
of  employees  and  independent  contractors.^'  As  the  discussion  in  Chapter  2  concluded,  section 
1706  does  not  systematically  favor  either  status. 

Worker  with  Typical  Mix  of  Fringe  Benefits.  Example  1 ,  which  is  summarized  in  Table 
2-2  in  Chapter  2,  shows  the  situation  of  an  employee  who  receives  total  compensation  of  $1,000, 
consisting  of  wages  and  a  typical  mix  of  fringe  benefits.  The  worker  does  not  have  any 
potentially  deductible  work-related  expenses,  such  as  union  dues,  home  office  expenses,  or  travel 
expenses.  The  independent  contractor  receives  the  entire  $1,000  in  cash,  out  of  which  Federal 
and  State  income  taxes  and  the  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  for  self-employed  workers 


^*  See  Section  in.C  of  Chapter  2  for  a  description  of  the  approach  taken  in  developing  these 
examples. 


43 

are  paid,  health  insurance  is  purchased,  and  contributions  to  a  tax-favored  "Keogh"  retirement 
plan  are  made. 

As  shown  in  the  bottom  portion  of  Table  2-2,  the  money  income  of  the  self-employed 
worker,  after  paying  taxes  and  purchasing  medical  and  retirement  benefits,  is  $22  or  about  five 
percent  ($22/$475)  lower  than  that  of  the  employee.  The  $22  is  the  net  of  $34  of  additional 
taxes  less  $12  saved  by  not  purchasing  unemployment  insurance  and  workers'  compensation. 
Thus,  the  self-employed  worker'  has  $22  less  money  income  despite  not  having  the  protection 
of  either  unemployment  insurance  or  workers'  compensation.  As  explained  in  Chapter  2,  taxes 
are  higher  for  the  self-employed  worker  because  that  part  of  cash  income  which  would  have 
purchased  employer-paid  fringe  benefits  is  subject  to  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  and 
some  is  also  subject  to  income  taxes.  Thus,  in  Example  1,  the  differential  treatment  of  certain 
fringe  benefits  for  tax  purposes,  especially  for  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes,  causes  an 
inequitable  distribution  of  taxes  between  employees  and  independent  contractors." 

Noncompliance.  The  administrative  rules  governing  the  form  and  timing  of  tax  payments 
and  where  income  is  reported  on  tax  returns  differ  for  employees  and  independent  contractors, 
with  stricter  rules  generally  applying  to  employees  {see  Chapter  2  and  Appendix  A).  Thus, 
independent  contractors  may  have  greater  opportunity  than  employees  to  be  less  than  fully 
compliant  with  tax  laws.  If  the  situation  in  Example  1  is  maintained,  except  that  the  independent 
contractor  understates  net  income  from  self-employment  by  five  percent,  the  after-tax  money 
income  of  the  independent  contractor  and  the  employee  would  be  equal.  That  situation  is 
illustrated  in  Example  2  (Table  2-3).  If  the  underreporting  of  net  income  were  to  exceed  five 
percent,  the  independent  contractor  would  have  a  higher  after-tax  money  income  than  the 
employee. 

Worker  Expenses.  Because  worker  expenses  are  treated  more  favorably  for  independent 
contractors  than  for  employees,  workers  who  have  such  expenses  are  not  taxed  equally. 
Example  3  (Table  2-4)  illustrates  the  same  situation  as  Example  1,  except  that  the  worker  has 
work-related  expenses  equal  to  ten  percent  of  gross  compensation.  This  level  of  worker 
expenses  is  just  sufficient  to  make  the  money  income  net  of  taxes  and  worker  expenses  of  the 
independent  contractor  equal  to  that  of  the  employee.  At  higher  levels  of  worker  expenses,  the 
independent  contractor  would  have  a  higher  after-tax  income. 


"  Note,  however  that  because  the  independent  contractor's  Social  Security  taxes  are  being 
paid  on  a  higher  level  of  income,  his  or  her  future  Social  Security  benefits  might  also  be  slightly 
higher. 


44 

No  Voluntary  Fringe  Benefits.  In  Example  4  (Table  2-5),  the  employer  provides  only 
those  fringe  benefits  mandated  by  Federal  or  State  law:  Social  Security  and  Medicare; 
unemployment  insurance,  and  workers'  compensation.  Otherwise,  the  facts  are  the  same  as  in 
Example  1.  In  Example  1,  the  net  after- tax  income  of  the  independent  contractor  was  $22,  or 
about  five  percent,  lower  than  that  of  the  employee.  In  Example  4,  with  no  voluntary  fringe 
benefits,  the  results  are  reversed;  the  independent  contractor's  money  income  is  $8,  or  1  percent, 
greater  than  the  income  of  the  employee.  The  independent  contractor's  greater  after-tax  income 
is  due  to  the  cost  of  the  employee's  coverage  under  unemployment  insurance  and  workers' 
compensation  and  the  income  tax  treatment  of  the  employer's  payments  for  that  coverage. 
Inequity  does  not  arise  directly  from  the  difference  in  income  stemming  from  the  cost  of 
unemployment  insurance  and  workers'  compensation.  Although  the  independent  contractor  has 
a  higher  after-tax  income  because  she  does  not  make  payments  for  such  coverage,  the 
independent  contractor  also  is  not  eligible  for  the  benefits  from  these  programs.  The  inequity 
is  due  to  the  exclusion  from  the  employee's  taxable  income  of  the  employer  payments  for 
unemployment  insurance  and  workers'  compensation. 

Summary.  The  examples  indicate  that  the  difference  in  after-tax  income  between 
employees  and  independent  contractors  would  typically  be  quite  small,  if  firms  classify  workers 
correctly.  The  differences  may  be  significant,  however,  for  certain  sets  of  worker  preferences. 
Thus,  a  worker  who  has  substantial  business  expenses  and  no  desire  for  employee  benefits  may 
have  much  higher  after-tax  income  as  an  independent  contractor.  Conversely,  a  worker  who  has 
few  business  expenses  and  a  strong  desire  for  all  the  employee  benefits  that  a  firm  offers  may 
have  much  higher  after-tax  income  as  an  employee. 

While  it  is  possible  for  one  set  of  tax  differentials  to  offset  another  exactly,  as  Examples 
2  and  3  illustrate,  such  exact  offsets  are  unlikely  in  practice.  The  typical  situation  is  for  the 
combined  effects  of  the  various  differentials  in  tax  treatment  not  to  leave  employees  and 
independent  contractors  treated  exactly  equally,  and,  therefore,  to  create  inequities. 

Even  in  cases  where  differences  in  the  after-tax  income  of  the  worker  are  small,  the 
consequences  of  a  retroactive  IRS  determination  of  misclassification  may  be  significant  for  the 
firm.  Because  the  firm  did  not  provide  employee  benefits  to  the  independent  contractor,  the  cash 
compensation  to  the  independent  contractor  generally  had  equalled  the  sum  of  the  wage  payment 
which  would  have  been  received  by  an  employee  and  the  amount  the  employer  would  have  spent 
for  employee  benefits.  With  reclassification,  the  entire  amount  of  cash  compensation  paid  to  the 
independent  contractor  is  deemed  to  have  been  wages  that  the  firm  would  have  paid  to  the 
worker  as  an  employee,  and  the  employer's  liability  for  Social  Security  and  Medicare  taxes  and 


45 

for  the  withholding  of  income  taxes  is  larger  than  if  the  firm  had  treated  the  worker  as  an 
employee  and  divided  the  worker's  compensation  into  taxable  wages  and  non-taxable  fringe 
benefits. 

Classifying  workers  as  employees  nominally  shifts  much  of  the  tax  compliance  burden 
to  employers  and  permits  tax  collection  through  withholding,  which  is  extremely  efficient. 
Similarly,  employers  incur  the  direct  compliance  costs  of  supplying  legally-required  as  well  as 
voluntary,  but  somewhat  regulated,  fringe  benefits.  However,  the  extent  to  which  such 
compliance  burdens  are  shifted  to  employees  through  reduced  levels  of  compensation  is  not 
known. 

IV.       ADMINISTRATIVE  COSTS 

Although  compliance  with  tax  laws  is  necessary,  the  administrative  costs  of  compliance 
divert  resources  from  other  uses.  A  goal  of  tax  policy  is,  therefore,  to  minimize  tax  compliance 
costs  while  achieving  the  desired  level  of  efficiency  and  equity  in  the  tax  system.  While  the 
principles  are  clear,  implementing  them  can  be  difficult.  The  inherent  tradeoffs  between  low 
compliance  costs,  efficiency,  and  equity  help  explain  some  of  the  differentials  in  the  tax 
treatment  of  employees  and  independent  contractors. 

For  example,  the  Federal  Social  Security  and  Medicare  system  generally  taxes  employees 
on  their  stated  salaries;  it  does  not  permit  adjustments  for  various  work-related  expenses  which 
employees  may  incur.  As  a  result  of  this  simplification,  the  income  to  which  the  Social  Security 
and  Medicare  taxes  are  applied  in  the  case  of  employees  may  be  mismeasured:  that  is,  it  may 
differ  from  their  economic  incomes.  The  mismeasurement  may  be  significant  in  a  small 
percentage  of  cases,  and  both  the  tax  liability  and  the  effective  tax  rate  may  be  higher  than  if 
employees  were  taxed,  as  independent  contractors  are,  on  their  net  income  from  employment. 
In  this  situation,  the  compliance  burdens  of  employees  are  greatly  reduced  as  a  result  of  the 
simplification,  but  at  the  cost  of  a  certain  degree  of  equity.^* 


'*  However,  the  benefits  of  excluding  employer-paid  fringe  benefits  from  Social  Security 
and  Medicare  income  bases  for  employees  but  not  completely  for  independent  contractors  may 
reduce  or  even  outweigh  the  extra  tax  burden  on  employees  from  the  failure  to  exclude 
employees'  work-related  expenses  from  the  employee's  Social  Security,  Medicare,  and  income 
tax  bases.  Moreover,  workers'  eventual  disability  or  retirement  benefits  may  be  increased  as 
the  result  of  the  differential  in  Social  Security  tax  treatment,  thus  partially  offsetting  any 
potential  equity  loss. 


46 

Similarly,  for  income  tax  purposes,  an  employee  cannot  deduct  any  employment-related 
expenses  unless  she  itemizes  deductions  on  her  income  tax  return  and  unless  these  expenses 
exceed  two  percent  of  income  from  all  sources.  Moreover,  there  are  classes  of  expenses  for 
which  a  deduction  is  further  limited  or  effectively  prohibited.  In  contrast,  an  independent 
contractor  has  much  greater  freedom  to  take  such  deductions  for  income  (and  Social  Security 
and  Medicare)  tax  purposes.  There  are,  however,  compliance  costs  to  the  independent 
contractor  associated  with  this  freedom.  The  costs  include  the  burden  of  maintaining  complete 
sets  of  records  which  might  not  otherwise  have  to  be  maintained,  the  burdens  and  expense  of 
filing  more  complicated  tax  returns,  and  the  costs  of  being  excluded  from  using  the  highly 
efficient  payment  system  provided  by  the  withholding  of  taxes  by,  and  payment  through,  an 
employer.  In  addition,  the  costs  to  the  government  of  assuring  compliance  with  tax  laws  through 
examination  of  a  sample  of  workers'  tax  returns  and  matching  information  from  various 
information  documents  against  the  information  reported  on  workers'  tax  returns  is  usually  higher 
for  self-employed  taxpayers. 

V.        NON-TAX  POLICIES 

Federal  and  State  governments  have  a  number  of  non-tax  policy  objectives  which  affect 
labor  markets.  Some  of  these  may  increase  the  efficiency  of  labor  markets  by  reducing  or 
removing  imperfections,  and  others  may  achieve  various  politically-determined  goals.  While 
these  policies  may  have  important  effects  on  workers'  choices  of  arrangements  with  firms, 
because  this  report  focuses  on  specific  tax  policies,  these  non-tax  policies  are  merely  listed  here. 
The  policies  are:  retirement  security;  access  to  health  care;  protection  of  workers  (occupational 
health  and  safety);  unemployment  security;  employment  standards  (minimum  wage  and  hours); 
and  nondiscrimination  in  employment  practices. '* 

Much  of  the  legislation  implementing  non-tax  policies  applies  only  to  employees,  not  to 
independent  contractors  or  other  self-employed  workers.  The  definition  of  an  employee  may 
vary  under  different  legislation,  however,  so  that,  for  example,  a  limited  number  of  workers 
might  be  deemed  independent  contractors  for  tax  purposes,  while  being  deemed  employees  under 
wage  and  hours  legislation.  Such  differences  may  be  warranted  by  the  differences  in  policies 
of  the  various  legislation,  but  they  do  impose  additional  compliance  costs  on  both  firms  and 
workers.  Much  of  the  additional  cost  stems  from  the  confusion  caused  by  seemingly  inconsistent 
treatment,  as  Examples  2  and  3  illustrate. 


39 


Legislation  implementing  these  policies  is  summarized  in  Chapter  2  and  Appendix  A. 


CHAPTERS:   TAX  COMPLIANCE  ISSUES 

I.         OVERVIEW 

The  TAMRA  conferees  questioned  whether  there  were  abuses  in  the  reporting  of  income 
by  independent  contractors  (as  compared  to  employees)  that  justified  the  adoption  of  section 
1706.  This  question  has  been  evaluated  in  terms  of  whether  there  was  a  significant  revenue  loss 
attributable  to  noncompliance  that  section  1706  could  have  been  expected  to  reduce.'"'  Whether 
this  is  true  depends  in  part  on  (1)  the  extent  of  the  misclassification  of  technical  services  workers 
covered  by  section  1706  and  (2)  the  noncompliance  rate  of  such  misclassified  employees  relative 
to  the  rate  that  would  be  expected  if  they  were  properly  classified.  This  chapter  provides  data 
relevant  to  these  questions.^' 

n.        RATE  OF  MISCLASSmCATION 

IRS  studies  suggest  that  misclassification  of  employees  as  independent  contractors  is 
significant."*^  Recent  studies  of  this  problem  include  the  IRS'  Strategic  Initiative  on  Withhold- 
ing Noncompliance  (SVC-1). 


^°  The  revenue  effect  also  depends  on  the  existence  of  other  differences  in  the  level  of  tax 
paid  by  employees  and  independent  contractors,  e.g.,  the  proportionately  larger  tax  expenditures 
associated  with  employee  fringe  benefits.  These  differences  are  discussed  in  Chapter  2  and 
Appendix  A  to  this  report.  They  are  not  taken  into  account  here,  however,  because  their  use 
is  not  considered  abusive  within  the  meaning  of  the  TAMRA  conferees. 

^'  At  the  initial  stage  of  this  study,  it  was  determined  that  existing  IRS  data  would  be  used 
in  addressing  these  questions,  and  that  no  new  surveys  would  be  undertaken  to  measure  the 
compliance  of  technical  services  workers  or  the  population  of  those  who  had  been  affected  by 
section  1706. 

^^  See  also  GAG,  Information  Returns  Can  Be  Used  to  Identify  Employers  Who  Misclassify 
Workers  Appendix  II,  GGD-89-107  (1989).  In  that  study,  individuals  receiving  more  than 
$10,000  in  income  reportable  on  Form  1099  from  one  payor  were  identified.  A  random  sample 
of  408  of  the  payors  was  interviewed.  The  interviews  indicated  that  157  (138-176  at  a  95 
percent  confidence  level),  or  38  percent,  misclassified  at  least  some  of  their  employees  as 
independent  contractors. 

47 


48 

The  employer  portion  of  SVC-1  examined  employment  tax  and  withholding  compliance 
for  tax  year  1984  for  a  sample  of  3,331  employers/'  It  includes  an  estimate  of  the  percentage 
of  employers  that  misclassified  at  least  some  of  their  employees  as  independent  contractors.** 
Some  of  the  results  for  different  sectors  are  shown  in  Table  5-1.  For  purposes  of  the  table, 
employees  were  considered  misclassified  if  they  were  determined  to  be  employees  under  the 
common  law  tests  (regardless  of  whether  section  530  applied),  but  had  been  treated  as 
independent  contractors  by  their  employers.  Employers  were  considered  to  have  misclassified 
employees  if  they  misclassified  one  or  more  of  their  employees,  regardless  of  the  total  number 
they  misclassified. 

Table  5-1  does  not  provide  definitive  proof  that  misclassification  is  a  bigger  problem 
among  employers  subject  to  section  1706  than  among  other  employers.  The  table  indicates  that 
misclassification  rates  among  employers  in  the  service  sector  were  not  much  higher  than  among 
employers  in  other  sectors  in  the  sample  population.^*  It  is  difficult  to  estimate  the  percentage 
of  misclassified  employees  in  each  sector  reliably  because  the  SVC-1  survey  was  designed  to 
determine  the  frequency  of  employers  that  misclassify,  rather  than  the  frequency  of  misclassified 
employees.  It  appears,  however,  that  the  percentage  of  service  sector  employees  who  were 
misclassified  was  higher  than  in  other  sectors  in  the  sample  population,  suggesting  that 
employers  in  the  service  sector  that  had  misclassified  employees  tended  to  misclassify  a  larger 


^^  The  employers  were  selected  at  random  from  employers  with  previous  employment  tax 
records  (Form  940  or  941E)  listed  on  the  business  master  file  (BMF)  for  1984.  Form  941  is 
the  Employer's  Quarterly  Federal  Tax  Return.  State  and  local  governments  and  other  employers 
that  generally  only  withhold  income  taxes  and  do  not  pay  FICA  or  FUTA  taxes  instead  file 
Form  94 IE,  Quarterly  Return  of  Withheld  Federal  Income  Tax.  Thus,  the  employer  sample 
does  not  include  organizations  with  no  employees  or  those  that  were  legally  required  to  file  a 
Form  941  or  941E  for  1984,  but  had  no  previous  records  on  the  BMF. 

*•  The  employer  portion  of  SVC-1  also  measured  compliance  with  reporting  requirements 
with  respect  to  employment  tax  returns  and  W-4  submittals,  and  compliance  of  U.S.  citizens 
claiming  exemption  from  withholding  on  foreign-source  income. 

*^  Misclassification  rates  were  not  separately  calculated  for  the  section  1706  group  because 
the  SVC-1  sample  contained  very  few  workers  in  technical  fields  (only  about  0.4  percent),  and 
because  the  SVC-1  survey  did  not  gather  sufficient  data  to  identify  employers  in  these  fields  that 
were  actually  subject  to  section  1706. 


in 

3 
H 


u 

•*^ 

s 
a 

0) 

o 


'35 
"3 


O 


"a 

o 

G 
1) 
U 


5^ 

■~  s  s  >■ 

uj  .2  2  ^ 

S    *•    w  u  1 


^P  ^P  ^>  ^p  ^p         wp 

(^       lyv       (^       (^t       (^       ^^ 

r-     00     —     o\     rj     00 


<^0 

f 


£  £ 


i2      -5 

E  i  :^  -  ® 

w  is  ^  c  '-s 

f.'S   n.  ■" 
f  E  2 
z     w 


V 
E     D 

u 
o  to 


vOOv>0     —     0>r)0\0 


)^   MP   1^  1^  tf  t^  MP 

o»k   (^   tyi  (y^  O^  1^  (^ 

0»   ©V   VO  f^  ^  VO  >0 

o\  o\  >o  On  ri 


t^ 


o 

00 

o 


•*   00   — 

ts  fS  r~ 
m  ts  wi 


«^ 

o 

in 

OS 

00 

U-l 

<N 

o 

in 

»N 

(N 

0\ 

\r> 

r- 

00 

»o 

00 

U-1 

vo  m 


—  —  o  r~ 


o 


O 


ON 
00 


On 
NO 


>ri   On   •*   l»- 
m  —  fs  •* 

•*   00   NO   (S 


s 


mtsirir-iii^'*  —  00 

ONNOONfSNO       —       csiri 

iriNOON     —     NOl/^>nON 


NO   NO 


m   On 


IT) 


«s 


On   —   "-   00   00   On 
p*   00   rf   Tt   NO   NO 

r~-  t^i  00     \n 


vn 


NO   O   NO   00   IT)    —   fS 

00  NO  r—  00  o  NO  r- 
rs  (S  (S  cN  es  fN  ra 


Tj-  —  in  Tt  rJ  t~ 
NO  ts  m  r^  00  ro 
ts  —  ts  —  r4  rr 


1 

« 

•2 

3 

VI 

D 

u 

_o 

■s 

8 

2 

OS 

•T3 

1 

>^ 

•a 

— 

§ 

> 

i 

5 

t> 

eo 

k« 

2 

O 

60 

w 

•a 

i 

u 

_. 

1 

g* 

c 

a 
•c 

■^ 

O 

g 

3 

^ 

1) 

(U 

2 

2 

c 

c 

J= 

s 

u 

•c 

o 

c 
'5 

o 

eo 
_c 

'S 

5 

§ 
u 

u 

E 

§ 
u 

2 

3 

■c 

E. 

tf 

"o 

.5 

u 

'E 

CI 
!>0 

i 

E 

u 

> 
o 
U 

5 

UJ 

o 
Z 

V 

> 


I 

o 


■- 


< 

H 
O 


50 

percentage  of  their  employees.**  This  may  reflect  the  fact  that  the  service  sector  contains  a 
disproportionate  number  of  smaller  employers,  and  studies  suggest  that  smaller  employers 
misclassify  a  larger  percentage  of  their  employees.  (It  may  also  reflect  somewhat  greater 
difficulty  in  applying  the  common  law  tests  of  employee  status  in  the  service  sector.) 

For  several  reasons,  no  strong  conclusions  can  be  drawn  from  the  SVC-1  data  regarding 
current  misclassification  patterns  among  employers  subject  to  section  1706.  First,  there  have 
been  significant  changes  in  the  tax  laws  and  IRS  enforcement  activity  since  1984,  which  may 
have  affected  employers'  abilities  and  incentives  to  misclassify  workers.*'  Second,  the  SVC-1 
survey  covered  a  relatively  small  sample  of  employers  and  has  a  relatively  high  sampling  error 
for  small  populations.  Third,  the  population  from  which  the  sample  was  drawn  included  mainly 
service-recipients  that  reported  having  at  least  some  employees,  and  did  not  include  service- 
recipients  that  treated  all  of  their  workers  as  independent  contractors. 

Finally,  misclassification  rates  for  employers  subject  to  section  1706  could  not  be 
specifically  determined  from  the  data.  The  service  sector  misclassification  rate  may  be 
indicative  of  the  rate  for  employers  subject  to  section  1706,  since  service  brokers  would  tend 
to  be  classified  in  the  service  sector.  The  service-recipients  may  be  in  any  industry,  however, 
including  manufacturing  or  government.  There  may  be  reason  to  believe  that,  regardless  of  the 
sector  to  which  they  are  allocated,  the  relatively  independent  nature  of  the  work  done  by 
employees  covered  by  section  1706,  and  the  frequently  temporary  nature  of  the  employment 
relationship,  may  create  a  misleading  appearance  of  independent  contractor  status  under  the 
common  law  tests.  In  addition,  the  particular  importance  of  computers  in  this  area,  and  the 
greater  ease  with  which  independent  contractors  can  deduct  their  legitimate  computer-related 
expenses,  may  create  an  incentive  to  misclassify  such  employees  as  independent  contractors. 

in.      RATE  OF  NONCOMPLIANCE 

Misclassification  can  cause  compliance  problems  if  misclassified  employees  have  a 
greater  tendency  to  underpay  their  taxes,  whether  due  to  underreporting  of  income,  overstate- 


**  Service  firms  in  the  SVC-1  sample  accounted  for  about  19  percent  of  reclassified  workers 
but  only  ten  percent  of  W-2  forms.  In  contrast,  the  percentage  of  employers  in  the  service 
sector  that  had  at  least  one  misclassified  employee  was  only  slightly  higher  than  for  all 
employers  in  the  survey  (Table  5-1). 

*'  See  generally  Appendix  A. 


51 

ment  of  deductions,  nonpayment  of  reported  liabilities,  or  other  factors.  In  fact,  IRS  studies 
consistently  find  lower  compliance  rates  for  non-wage  compensation  income  than  for  wage 
income.**  Recent  studies  include  the  1985  Tax  Compliance  Measurement  Program  (TCMP) 
and  the  employee  portion  of  the  1984  SVC-1  survey.  The  1985  TCMP  is  more  comprehensive, 
but  is  less  useful  for  the  specific  purposes  of  this  report  than  the  1984  SVC-1  survey  because 
the  former  covers  all  workers  rather  than  just  misclassified  employees— the  only  group  actually 
affected  by  section  1706. 

A.        1985  TCMP 

The  1985  TCMP  measured  wages.  Schedule  C  gross  profit,  and  other  categories  of 
income  and  deduction  reported  by  a  randomly-selected  sample  of  50,000  individual  taxpayers, 
compared  them  to  the  correct  amounts  (determined  after  an  examinations  of  the  taxpayers' 
returns),  and  expressed  the  ratios  as  voluntary  reporting  percentages  (VRP).*'  Data  from  the 
survey  were  then  used  to  estimate  the  values  for  the  entire  population  of  taxpayers  from  which 
the  sample  was  selected.  The  results  are  shown  in  Table  5-2.  For  purposes  of  this  table,  the 
sample  data  have  been  divided  between  employees  and  independent  contractors, *°  and  between 
technical  services  workers  and  other  workers.*' 


**  In  addition  to  the  IRS  and  GAO  studies  cited  above,  these  include  IRS  studies  of  (1)  1975 
and  1976  information  returns  (covering  filers  receiving  commissions  or  fees);  (2)  1979  Forms 
1099-NEC  (covering  filers  receiving  nonemployee  compensation);  and  (3)  1977  delinquent 
Forms  1099-MISC  (follow-up  study  covering  U.S.  residents  required  to  file  Form  1040). 

*'  See  generally  Fratanduono  &  Bucci,  Trends  in  the  Voluntary  Compliance  of  Taxpayers 
Who  File  Individual  Income  Tax  Returns,  in  Department  of  the  Treasury,  Internal  Revenue 
Service,  1989  Update,  Trend  Analyses  and  Related  Statistics,  Document  6011  (1989). 

*°  For  this  purpose,  employees  are  defined  as  individuals  with  over  $10,000  in  wage  income 
(as  examined),  and  more  wages  than  Schedule  C  income,  while  independent  contractors  are 
defined  as  those  with  over  $10,000  in  Schedule  C  income  (as  examined),  more  Schedule  C 
income  than  wage  income,  and  less  than  $5,000  in  wage  payments.  Using  this  definition, 
approximately  three  percent  of  the  taxpayers  in  the  entire  weighted  TCMP  sample  were 
independent  contractors,  55  percent  were  employees,  and  41  percent  did  not  fall  into  either 
category.  For  technical  services  workers,  two  percent  of  the  sample  were  independent 
contractors,  92  percent  were  employees,  and  six  percent  did  not  fall  into  either  category. 

*'   See  Appendix  C  for  a  definition  of  technical  services  worker  used  for  this  purpose. 


09 

fa 

u 
o 


a 

fa 

u      I 

**       o 

s 

•o 

B 
0) 

a 
« 

S 
hN 

s 
es 


a 

S 

1 

u 

1 

►> 

^ 

.£ 

£ 

w 

u 

1^ 

r 

(A 

e 

i 

V 

^ 

a 

^ 

X 

c 

s 
es 

s 

o 
u 


DC 

a 

'■*^ 

fa 
o 
a 


<«-|  .2 


<«  |.2 

8*  IS 

0£  i£ 


O    01    E 


II 


<«  r  .2 


t^    (^   (^   t>;   (^    t^   t>S 
«M    >ri    —    ov    r^    ^    t~- 


C^     C^     C^     v^     C^     v^     ^^ 
O    P-)    00    O    —    m    O 


S^ 


^ 

S' 

to 

00 

00 

00 

^.« 

•«r 

o 

o 

«s 

r- 

o\ 

0\ 

o\ 

^ 

«^ 

Ov 

0\ 

o 

Ov 

0\ 

r~ 

t»- 

t- 

—    n    ■*    Ov    00    o    o 


in 


9>     to     00 


t^   rs   o 

OS     vo 
>0     SO 


On     O  OS    >0     vO 

vd    r4  '      '      ■ 
o 

rM  — 


_      -  .      vi     IT)     IT)     o 

—    p    «M    so    »o    o»    o 


OS  OS  On  ^*  O     0\  ^ 

—  r-  »»s  rj  *^    NO  00 

r^  m  (s  p^  \o  T^ 

>o  <o  so 


<s    <s    ■^    — 


o    — 


r~    O    fn    p^    t~-    ^    OS 
—    OS    —    r~    ^    t~    r-- 


1 

E 
U 


E 

I 

B 

e 


^^^      ^^^  ^9  ^^  ^^  ^^  ^^ 

^^      ^^  ^^  ^^  ^^  ^^  ^r^ 

O    (S  m  m  so  00  o 

8"     «X  •^  P^  O  00  OS 

Os  OS  —  IT)  OS  OS 


—     —    TT     so     OS     O     * 


c 


^^^      ^Xk       ^^       fcJS^       ^^       ^^       ^^ 
Wv       (T*.       ^S       U"»       ^N.       (^       On 

■^       O       OS       Tt       Tf       OS       — 


8 


m    m    r^    ro    m 
OS     —     00     00     00 


—    m    <s    — 


O    r^    O 
t~     00 


—  m    O    00    in    r^    O 

—  ^    ^    —    fsi    i»i    ^ 


—    q    rj    os    ^    ov    so 

--    rn    rj    — <    O    O    00 


--    ^    00    o    —    —    ^ 
--    •^    rn    rj    CS    r^    p^ 


e 

W 

_o 

CA 

Q. 

c 

u 

'u 

u: 

s 

4) 

(A 

2 

S 

Ou 
en 

2 

O 
1 

o 

1 

i 
1 

■c 
"5 

o 
u 

u 

u 

Z 

u 

2 
o 

C/} 

_« 

JD 

JU 

JJ 

1 

fid 

VD 

"5 

"s 

"5 

^ 

H 

& 

•s 

•s 

"S 

•s 

S 

1 

flO 

f 

^ 

f 

^ 

f 

^ 

^ 

(^ 

cJ5 

^ 

{2 

g 

w 

O 

te 

c 

•^ 

Q. 

u 

"C 

C 

3 

4i 

t- 

^ 

2 

"S 

iH 

E 

0 
u 

i 

en 

0 

cu 

Q 

3 

2 
a. 

o 
o 

c 

i> 

k. 

o 

u 

t/3 

•c 

u 

O 

i- 

Z 

o 

u 

u 

u 

U 

u 

U4 

V) 

u 

V 

JD 

_u 

;s 

ed 

VI 

3 

"a 

"a 

3 

H 

00 

•s 

■B 

•2 

•B 

3 

2 

a 

J= 

f 

^ 

f 

< 

^ 

o 

o 
60 

to 

^ 

c 

E 

e 

I 


E 
o 
U 


53 

Table  5-2  shows  that  the  VRPs  for  the  Schedule  C  income  (and  total  taxable  income)  of 
the  independent  contractors  included  in  the  1985  TCMP  were  generally  worse  than  the 
comparable  VRPs  for  the  wages  (and  total  taxable  income)  of  employees,  but  that  both  measures 
were  generally  better  for  technical  services  workers  than  for  other  workers.  It  also  shows  that 
underreporting  of  income  was  not  the  only  reason  for  the  independent  contractors'  low  VRPs: 
in  particular,  the  low  VRPs  for  their  net  Schedule  C  income  also  resulted  from  the  overstatement 
of  the  cost  of  goods  sold  and/or  operations  (resulting  in  underreporting  of  Schedule  C  gross 
profit),  and  the  overstatement  of  other  Schedule  C  deductions  (resulting  in  underreporting  of 
Schedule  C  net  profit).  The  overstatement  of  Schedule  C  deductions  contributes  about  two-thirds 
of  the  total  understatement  of  net  profit  shown  for  technical  services  independent  contractors. 
Some  of  the  reported  overstatement  of  deductions  may  have  been  attributable  to  inadequate 
record-keeping. 

For  independent  contractors,  the  actual  reporting  of  Schedule  C  income  may  have  been 
slightly  better  than  indicated.  Table  5-2  shows  that  wages  and  salaries  tend  to  be  slighdy 
overreported  by  independent  contractors,  whereas  Schedule  C  gross  receipts  tend  to  be  slightly 
underreported.  Some  of  the  wage  and  salary  overreporting  may  be  due  to  Schedule  C  income 
being  reported  incorrectly  as  wage  or  salary  income,  however,  which  may  lead  to  failure  to 
collect  any  Social  security  or  Medicare  tax  on  that  income.  Thus,  actual  Schedule  C  VRPs  may 
be  somewhat  higher  than  shown  on  Table  5-2.  Also,  it  may  be  particularly  hard  for  IRS 
examiners  to  detect  wage  and  salary  underreporting  when  the  underreporting  is  due  to  collusion 
between  employers  and  employees.  Thus,  actual  wage  and  salary  VRPs  may  not  be  as  high  as 
reported  as  shown  on  Table  5-2. 

General  conclusions  drawn  from  the  TCMP  data  with  respect  to  workers  actually  covered 
by  section  1706  are  subject  to  several  reservations.  First,  it  was  impossible  to  calculate  separate 
VRPs  for  such  workers,  so  a  broader  group  of  technical  services  workers  was  used  a  proxy. *^ 
The  compliance  patterns  in  the  two  groups  may  have  been  different.  Second,  there  have  been 
significant  changes  in  the  tax  laws  and  IRS  enforcement  activity  since  1985  that  may  have 
affected  individuals'  incentive  and  ability  to  underreport  their  income  or  overstate  their 
deductions.  Specifically,  the  tightening  of  the  requirements  for  certain  business  deductions  in 
TRA  1986  may  have  reduced  the  extent  to  which  itemized  deductions  and  Schedule  C  deductions 


"   See  Appendix  C  for  a  description  of  the  occupations  included  in  this  group. 


54 

are  overstated.*'  Third,  the  population  from  which  the  sample  was  drawn  includes  only 
individuals  for  whom  a  return  was  filed,  and  thus  the  data  do  not  measure  compliance  in  the  so- 
called  "underground"  economy.  Fourth,  as  indicated  above,  it  was  not  possible  to  distinguish 
misclassified  workers  from  other  workers  in  the  TCMP  sample.  Therefore,  the  data  relates  to 
the  relative  compliance  of  independent  contractors  generally,  rather  than  the  narrower  group  of 
misclassified  employees  actually  affected  by  section  1706.  Finally,  the  VRPs  are  not  adjusted 
to  reflect  TCMP  audit  sustension  rates  and,  therefore,  may  not  indicate  the  actual  revenue 
potential  from  legislative  or  administrative  changes  affecting  compliance. 

B.        1984  SVC-1  Employee  Survey 

As  explained  above,  the  SVC-1  survey  examined  employment  tax  and  withholding 
compliance  for  a  sample  of  businesses  for  tax  year  1984.  The  employer  portion  of  the  survey 
identified  employees  who  were  misclassified  (by  their  employers)  as  independent  contractors. 
A  follow-up  survey  of  3,260  misclassified  employees  was  also  conducted  to  determine  their  level 
of  individual  reporting  compliance.  Data  covering  the  2,406  employees  for  whom  a  Form  1099 
had  been  filed  were  then  weighted  to  represent  values  for  the  entire  population  of  misclassified 
employees.*^  Misclassified  technical  services  workers  were  found  to  have  reported  92.6 
percent  of  their  misclassified  compensation.  For  other  workers,  the  VRP  was  77  percent  of 
misclassified  compensation.  Other  data  from  the  employee  portion  of  the  SVC-1  survey  suggest 
that  information  reporting  may  also  play  a  substantial  role  in  subsequent  compliance  by 
misclassified  employees." 


"  See,  e.g.,  the  discussion  of  the  two-percent  floor  on  itemized  deductions  and  sections 
280A  and  280F  in  Appendix  A. 

^  Forms  1099  had  been  filed  for  37  of  the  43  technical  services  workers  and  2,369  of  the 
3,217  other  workers  in  the  misclassified  employee  sample.  The  sub-sample  used  to  generate  the 
estimates  in  the  table  was  limited  to  employees  for  whom  a  Form  1099  had  been  filed  because 
these  are  the  only  employees  covered  by  section  530,  and  the  issue  for  resolution  is  whether 
section  530  protection  for  misclassified  workers  has  permitted  significant  compliance  problems 
to  develop. 

'*  The  survey  found  that  information  returns  were  filed  for  84  percent  of  misclassified 
employees  in  the  sample  whose  payments  exceeded  $600.  While  77.2  percent  of  the 
misclassified  compensation  for  which  a  Form  1099  was  filed  was  reported,  only  28.8  percent 
of  the  misclassified  compensation  for  which  no  Form  1099  was  filed  was  reported.  This 
contrasts  with  the  results  of  a  1977  study,  in  which  misclassification  was  not  an  issue,  which 


55 

The  data  from  the  employee  portion  of  the  SVC-1  generally  suffer  from  the  same 
problems  as  the  TCMP  data  described  above.  In  addition,  the  small  number  of  technical 
services  workers  covered  by  the  survey  means  that  any  differences  found  between  them  and 
other  workers  have  a  high  sampling  error.  The  TCMP  data  also  indicate  that  Schedule  C 
reporting  of  both  income  and  deductions  for  workers  whose  primary  source  of  income  is 
Schedule  C  income  is  superior  to  that  of  workers  who  have  only  occasional  Schedule  C  income. 
This  is  true  for  both  technical  services  workers  and  other  workers.  There  is  no  way  to 
determine  from  the  data  whether  there  are  differences  in  Schedule  C  reporting  for  correctly 
classified  independent  contractors  and  those  who  are  incorrectly  classified.  Furthermore, 
workers  covered  by  section  1706  may  have  more  than  one  job  during  a  year,  and  may  be 
misclassified  in  one  job  but  not  another.  Thus,  correct  classification  may  not  result  in  correct 
reporting  of  the  entire  Schedule  C  amount. 

C.        Summary 

The  1985  TCMP  and  the  1984  SVC-1  misclassified  employee  survey  suggest  that  there 
is  more  underreporting  of  income  by  independent  contractors  than  by  employees.  They  do  not, 
however,  support  assertions  that  technical  services  workers  are  less  compliant  than  other 
workers.  Taken  together,  the  1985  TCMP  and  1984  SVC-1  data  suggest  that  the  reporting  of 
non-wage  income  by  workers  covered  by  section  1706  is  at  least  as  good  as,  and  perhaps 
superior  to,  reporting  by  other  misclassified  workers,  but  not  as  good  as  the  reporting  of  wage 
and  salary  income.  The  1985  TCMP  also  indicates  that  overstatement  of  deductions  is 
responsible  for  much  of  the  understatement  of  net  profit  for  independent  contractors  in  technical 
services  (and  independent  contractors  in  general). 


found  that  83.2  percent  of  the  compensation  for  which  no  Form  1099  MISC  was  filed  was 
reported. 


CHAPTER  6:    TAX  ADMINISTRATION  ISSUES 

I.  OVERVIEW 

The  TAMRA  conferees  questioned  whether  there  were  problems  with  the  administration 
of  section  1706  itself,  or  with  the  common  law  tests  that  employers  subject  to  section  1706  must 
generally  use  in  classifying  workers  as  employees  or  independent  contractors.  This  chapter 
addresses  these  issues  and  concludes  that  both  the  scope  of  section  1706  and  the  common  law 
tests  could  be  further  clarified. 

n.        ADMINISTRATIVE  PROBLEMS  WITH  SECTION  1706 

Compared  to  section  530,  section  1706  raises  few  administrative  or  interpretive  issues. 
Those  that  have  arisen  concern  primarily  its  effect  (including  its  relationship  to  the  common  law 
tests  for  determining  employee  status)  and  its  scope  (including  the  occupations  covered  under 
it). 

Many  taxpayers  were  initially  confused  about  the  effect  of  section  1706,  believing  that 
it  required  that  the  individuals  covered  by  the  provision  be  treated  as  employees.  Apparently, 
some  service-recipients  reacted  by  treating  all  their  technical  services  workers  as  employees, 
even  though  that  was  sometimes  contrary  to  the  results  under  the  common  law  tests.  This 
misconception  probably  sprang  from  some  imprecise  language  in  the  legislative  history  of  the 
provision"  and  an  IRS  publication  issued  soon  after  enactment,"  plus  the  common  misconcep- 
tion that  section  530  had  previously  required  that  these  individuals  be  treated  as  independent 
contractors  regardless  of  whether  there  was  a  basis  for  doing  so.  This  misconception  has  been 
largely  corrected  through  a  combination  of  industry  education  and  IRS  guidance,  which 


"  See  footnote  3 1  above. 


"  In  January,  1987,  the  IRS  published  a  revised  Publication  15  (Circular  E)  which 
discussed  section  530  and  Stated  that  "[i]f  you  have  any  reason  for  treating  a  worker  other  than 
as  an  employee  you  will  not  be  liable  for  employment  taxes  on  payments  to  the  worker.  This 
relief  is  not  available,  however,  for  any  arrangement  you  may  have  for  services  provided  to  you 
by  certain  technical  personnel,  such  as  engineers,  computer  programmers,  and  systems  analysts." 
In  Resource  Technical  Consultants  (U.S.A.),  Inc.  v.  Baker,  88-1  U.S.T.C.  1  9111  at  83,033 
(S.D.N. Y.  1987),  the  district  court  found  that  "the  Circular  makes  no  misstatements  and  is  at 
worst  confusing." 

57 


58 

explained  that  technical  services  workers  would  "be  classified  as  independent  contractors  or 
employees  under  generally  applicable  common  law  standards."" 

Many  taxpayers  are  still  confused  about  the  scope  of  section  1706,  in  particular  about  the 
occupations  it  covers.  The  provision  mentions  "engineers,  designers,  drafters,  computer 
programmers,  systems  analysts  and  other  similarly  skilled  workers  engaged  in  a  similar  line  of 
work."  These  terms  are  not  defined  in  the  legislative  history,  however,  and  are  not  well  defined 
in  other  sources.*'  Nor  do  they  correspond  well  to  industry  usage  or  to  the  occupational 
categories  used  by  the  IRS  for  Schedule  C  purposes.  The  phrase  "similarly  skilled  workers 
engaged  in  a  similar  line  of  work"  is  particularly  vague,  since  it  is  not  clear  how  much  similarity 
is  required.  For  example,  are  scientists  included  if  they  are  engaged  in  engineering-type 
activities,  such  as  oil  exploration,  or  are  they  excluded  because  they  do  not  have  similar  skills 
to  engineers?  Are  architects  included  because  they  often  perform  drafting,  or  was  the  term 
"drafting"  meant  to  be  read  more  narrowly  for  purposes  of  section  1706?  These  problems  have 
made  it  difficult  in  some  cases  for  employers  to  identify  covered  workers  and  for  the  IRS 
systematically  to  target  such  workers  for  enforcement  or  even  to  gather  sufficient  data  on  their 
levels  of  compliance. 

m.       ADMINISTRATIVE  PROBLEMS  WITH  COMMON  LAW  TESTS  OF  EMPLOYEE 
STATUS 

As  explained  in  Chapter  2,  whether  an  individual  is  an  employee  for  Federal  tax  purposes 
is  generally  determined  under  the  common  law  tests  for  determining  whether  an  employment 
relationship  exists.  As  explained  in  Chapter  3,  section  530  allows  employers  to  rely  on  their 
own  erroneous  classification  under  some  circumstances.  Section  1706  denies  this  relief  to 
certain  employers  in  the  technical  services  field,  and  thus  requires  these  employers  to  apply  the 
common  law  tests  in  all  cases.  In  a  sense,  section  1706  restores  pre-section  530  law  for  these 
employers. 


"  Notice  87-19,  1987-1  C.B.  455;  News  Release  IR-87-8  (January  21,  1987);  News  Release 
IR-87-68  (May  21,  1987).  This  guidance  also  clarified  that  section  1706  applies  only  to  brokers 
or  job-shops,  and  does  not  apply  to  service-recipients  generally, 

*'  See,  e.g.,  U.S.  Department  of  Labor,  Employment  &.  Training  Administration, 
Dictionary  of  Occupational  Tides  (4th  ed.  1977  &.  Supp.  1986). 


59 

The  common  law  tests,  like  most  facts-and-circumstances  tests,  lack  precision  and 
predictability.  Since  they  were  developed  in  an  entirely  different  context  from  Federal  tax  law 
(primarily  the  law  of  employer  liability  for  employee  torts),  they  may  also  produce  inappropriate 
results  for  some  tax  purposes.  As  then-Assistant  Secretary  (Tax  Policy)  John  Chapoton  stated 
in  1982,  "[i]n  many  cases,  applying  the  common  law  test  in  employment  tax  issues  does  not 
yield  clear,  consistent,  or  satisfactory  answers[,]  and  reasonable  persons  may  differ  as  to  the 
correct  classification.  "*° 

Although  the  subjectivity  of  the  common  law  tests  is  no  doubt  one  problem,*'  a  bigger 
problem  may  be  the  large  number  of  factors  with  which  taxpayers  and  the  IRS  must  contend, 
and  the  consequent  difficulty  in  determining  the  relative  weight  of  any  one  factor."  Thus,  an 
important  feature  of  many  proposed  legislative  solutions  has  been  to  limit  the  number  of  factors 
to  be  taken  into  account.*' 

The  common  law  tests  may  be  particularly  difficult  to  apply  in  the  multi-party  contract 
situations,  which  are  the  only  situations  covered  by  section  1706.  This  is  because  the  service- 
broker  and  the  service-recipient  often  share  control  over  the  service-provider's  performance  of 


*°  Hearings  Before  the  Subcommittee  on  Oversight  of  the  Internal  Revenue  Service  of  the 
Committee  on  Finance,  97th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  (April  26,  1982).  See  also  Hearings  Before  the 
Subcommittee  on  Commerce,  Consumer  and  Monetary  Affairs  of  the  Committee  on  Government 
Operations,  101st  Cong.,  1st  Sess.  (May  16,  1989)  (acting  Commissioner  of  Internal  Revenue 
stating  that  "[o]ne  of  the  most  difficult  and  controversial  issues  in  the  employment  tax  area  is 
the  definition  of  'employee'  under  the  so-called  'common  law  rules'  ....  IRS'  preference  has 
been  and  continues  to  be  for  a  legislative  solution."). 

*'  See,  e.g. ,  GAO,  Information  Returns  Can  Be  Used  to  Identify  Employers  Who  Misclassifi/ 
Workers  3,  GGD-89-107  (1989). 

*^  In  an  August  5,  1987  letter  to  Lawrence  B.  Gibbs,  Commissioner  of  Internal  Revenue, 
Frank  S.  Swain,  the  U.S.  Small  Business  Administration  Chief  Counsel  for  Advocacy,  requested 
that  the  IRS  clarify  which  factors  are  important,  and  which  are  not  important,  in  determining 
employee  status  in  the  technical  services  area. 

"  See,  e.g.,  the  proposals  described  in  Hearings  Before  the  Subcommittee  on  Select 
Revenue  Measures  of  the  Committee  on  Ways  and  Means,  97th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  (June  11,  1982) 
(joint  Statement  of  John  E.  Chapoton,  Assistant  Secretary  of  the  Treasury  (Tax  Policy),  and 
Roscoe  L.  Egger,  Jr.,  Commissioner  of  Internal  Revenue). 


60 

services,  as  well  as  sharing  other  incidents  of  employment.**  In  some  cases,  both  may 
legitimately  be  considered  the  individual's  employer.  While  the  parties  may  request  a 
determination  letter  from  the  IRS,  this  may  be  too  difficult  and  time-consuming  to  be 
practical."  Moreover,  even  if  the  service-recipient  is  considered  the  individual's  sole 
employer,  the  broker  may  have  sufficient  control  over  payments  made  to  the  individual  to  be 
treated  as  her  "imputed  employer"  and  be  subject  to  a  withholding  requirement.**  Finally,  even 
if  the  broker  is  considered  the  sole  employer,  the  client  may  be  treated  as  the  employer  for 
certain  employee  fringe  benefit  purposes  under  the  leased  employee  rules. *^ 

Problems  with  the  common  law  tests  have  been  exacerbated  by  the  fact  that  labor  markets 
have  undergone  significant  changes-including  the  proliferation  of  multi-party  arrangements- 
since  the  enactment  of  section  530  in  1978,  during  which  period  section  530  has  virtually 
prevented  the  IRS  from  issuing  any  general  guidance  reflecting  its  interpretation  of  the  common 
law  tests.  This  has  made  it  very  difficult  for  taxpayers  and  IRS  personnel  alike  to  analyze 
employment  relationships  consistently,  and  has  greatly  reduced  employers'  ability  to  predict 
when  the  common  law  tests  require  a  particular  worker  to  be  treated  as  an  employee  or 
independent  contractor.  The  enactment  of  section  1706  has  permitted  the  IRS  to  issue 
guidance**  in  some  very  narrow  circumstances,  only,  and  significant  gaps  therefore  remain. 


**  The  situation  becomes  even  more  complicated  when  the  individual  operates  through  a 
corporation.  See  Appendix  A  for  a  discussion  of  the  relevance  of  incorporation  in  this  context. 

**  For  a  third-party  broker  with  dozens  of  independent  contractors  at  many  different  clients, 
the  number  of  determination  letter  requests  (Form  SS-8)  to  be  completed—even  if  a  sampling  is 
used— can  be  very  large  if  the  firm  wants  to  cover  all  typical  factual  settings.  Moreover,  client 
projects  often  last  only  weeks  or  months,  making  it  difficult  to  obtain  a  ruling  before  the 
independent  contractor  changes  job  settings. 

**  Code  §  3401(d)(1);  Treas.  Reg.  §  31.3401(d)-l(f).  See  One  v.  United  States,  419  U.S. 
43  (1974). 

*^  See  Code  §  414(n).  Section  1706  does  not  affect  the  application  of  section  414(n).  Staff 
of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Taxation,  100th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.,  General  Explanation  of  the  Tax 
Reform  Act  of  1986,  1345  (Comm.  Print  1987). 

*'   See,  e.g.,  Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296. 


PART  FOUR 


APPENDICES 


APPENDIX  A 

DIFFERENCES  IN  TREATMENT  OF  EMPLOYEES  AND 
INDEPENDENT  CONTRACTORS-DETAILED  ANALYSIS 

I.  OVERVIEW 

Employees  and  employers  face  significantly  different  treatment  from  independent 
contractors  and  their  clients  under  a  wide  range  of  laws,  including  Federal  and  State  employment 
tax,  income  tax  and  labor  laws.  Differences  that  significantly  favor  one  group  over  the  other 
may  encourage  deliberate  misclassification  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  or  independent 
contractor.  This  appendix  describes  the  major  differences  in  treatment  between  employees  and 
employers  on  the  one  hand  and  independent  contractors  and  their  clients  on  the  other,  and  the 
factors  used  to  distinguish  between  them.  It  also  compares  the  relative  advantages  of  both  types 
of  treatment  and  attempts  to  determine  whether  current  law  creates  unnecessary  incentives  for 
misclassification.  It  concludes  that  current  law  does  not  consistently  favor  one  classification 
over  the  other. 

n.        FEDERAL  TAX  LAW 

A.        Employment  Taxes 

Social  Security  and  Medicare.  Wages  paid  to  employees  are  generally  subject  to  Social 
Security  and  Medicare  taxes  under  the  Federal  Insurance  Contribution  Act  (FICA). 
Compensation  paid  to  independent  contractors,  by  contrast,  is  generally  subject  to  Social 
Security  and  Medicare  taxes  under  the  Self-Employment  Contributions  Act  (SEC A). 


69 


Since  1990,  the  combined  tax  rates  on  employees  and  their  employers  on  the  one  hand 
and  independent  contractors  and  their  clients  on  the  other  have  been  virtually  identical  under 
both  FICA  and  SEC  A.™     Prior  to   1983,  the  tax  rates  on  independent  contractors  were 


<*'  See  Code  Subtitle  A,  Chapter  2,  and  Subtitle  C,  Chapter  21. 

''"  The  combined  Social  Security  and  Medicare  tax  rate  for  1991  is  the  same  (15.3  percent) 
underboth.  Code  §§  1401,  3101  and  3111.  Under  both,  only  the  first  $53,400  of  compensation 
is  subject  to  Social  Security  tax,  while  the  first  $125,000  is  subject  to  Medicare  tax.  Code 
§§  1402(k)  and  3121(x),  as  added  by  the  Omnibus  Budget  Reconciliation  Act  of  1990  (OBRA 
1990),  Pub.  L.  No.  101-508,  104  Stat.  1388  (1990);  Notice,  55  Fed.  Reg.  45856  (October  31, 

63 


64 

significantly  lower,  even  though  they  were  generally  eligible  for  the  same  Social  Security  and 
Medicare  benefits  as  employees."  In  1982  testimony,  Treasury  recommended  that  the  rate 
differential  be  reduced  to  "help  neutralize  the  decision  whether  to  hire  an  independent  contractor 
or  an  employee,  and  relieve  pressure  on  the  question  of  employment  status."^  1983  legislation 
mostly  eliminated  the  rate  differential  effective  in  1984,  and  made  other  conforming  changes  that 
became  fully  effective  in  1990." 

Some  differences  still  remain,  however.  In  some  cases  they  can  be  significant.  While 
the  gross  tax  base  is  generally  the  same  under  PICA  and  SEC  A,''''  items  that  reduce  PICA 
wages  generally  do  not  reduce  compensation  subject  to  SECA  tax  unless  they  are  deductible  on 
Schedule  C  for  income  tax  purposes.  In  particular,  contributions  to  a  qualified  pension  plan  or 
an  accident  and  health  plan  generally  are  not  includible  in  employee  PICA  wages,  but  are  subject 
to  SECA  tax.'*   Contributions  to  certain  nonqualified  plans  may  also  receive  more  favorable 


1990).  While,  technically,  the  employer  pays  half  of  the  PICA  taxes  imposed  on  an  employee's 
wages,  the  economic  effect  is  the  same  as  if  the  employee  paid  the  entire  amount.  Special 
deductions  are  also  provided  to  self-employed  individuals  subject  to  SECA,  which  produce 
nearly  the  same  effect  as  the  fact  that  employees  are  not  subject  to  income  or  PICA  taxes  on  the 
employer's  share  of  PICA.    Code  §§  164(f)  and  1402(a)(12). 

""  In  1980,  for  example,  the  combined  PICA  tax  rate  (employer  and  employee)  was  12.26 
percent,  while  the  combined  SECA  tax  rate  was  8.1  percent. 

'^  Hearings  Before  the  Subcommittee  on  Oversight  of  the  Internal  Revenue  Service  of  the 
Committee  on  Pinance,  97th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  (April  26,  1982)  (Statement  of  John  E.  Chapoton, 
Assistant  Secretary  of  the  Treasury  (Tax  Policy)). 

"  Social  Security  Amendments  of  1983,  Pub.  L.  No.  98-21,  §  124,  97  Stat.  65,  89  (1983). 
See  also  H.R.  Conf.  Rep.  No.  47,  98th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.  125-26  (1983). 


74 


Commissioner  v.  Braddock,  95  T.C.  No.  45  (1990). 


''*  Compare  Code  ^%  1402(a)  and  3121(a)(5);  5ee  Code  §  62(a)(6).  Health  and  accident  plan 
contributions  are  included  in  SECA  compensation  even  though  they  are  partially  deductible  for 
income  tax  purposes.  See  Code  §§  162(1)(4).  The  treatment  of  pension  plan  contributions  may 
be  explained  by  viewing  contributions  by  self-employed  persons  as  essentially  elective. 
Employee  elective  contributions  are  includible  in  PICA  wages.  Code  §  3121(v)(l).  This 
explanation  does  not  apply  to  accident  and  health  plan  contributions,  however,  since  these  may 
be  excluded  from  PICA  wages  even  when  provided  under  an  elective  arrangement.  Code 
§  3121(a)(5)(G). 


65 

treatment  under  FICA.'*  These  advantages  are  to  a  limited  extent  offset,  however,  by  the  fact 
that  trade  or  business  expenses  may  be  deducted  from  compensation  before  SECA  compensation 
is  calculated,  but  cannot  be  so  deducted  for  PICA  purposes,  and  that  excess  PICA  taxes  may  be 
imposed  on  the  employer  when  an  employee  changes  jobs  in  mid-year.^  Pinally,  unlike 
employees,  independent  contractors  who  are  eligible  for  Social  Security  benefits  can  sometimes 
avoid  application  of  the  Social  Security  earnings  test  through  the  use  of  deferred  compensa- 
tion.''* 

Unemployment  Insurance.  The  first  $7,000  of  wages  paid  to  an  employee  is  generally 
subject  to  tax  under  the  Pederal  Unemployment  Tax  Act  (PUTA).''  Under  the  integrated 
Pederal/State  system,  part  of  the  tax  is  ordinarily  paid  to  the  State  of  employment,  while  part 
is  paid  to  the  Federal  government;  the  combined  rate  averaged  approximately  2.8  percent  in 


■'^  There  is  no  analogue  to  section  3121(v)(2)  in  SECA.  OBRA  1990  deleted  an  analogous 
rule  for  corporate  directors  in  section  1402(a)  for  tax  purposes;  however,  a  similar  rule  still 
exists  for  purposes  of  the  Social  Security  earnings  test.  See  Social  Security  Act  §  211(a),  42 
U.S.C.  §  411(a). 

^  This  results  from  the  fact  that,  in  computing  PICA  taxes  on  a  new  employee's  wages, 
an  employer  generally  may  not  take  into  account  the  fact  that  the  employee  has  already  earned 
wages  in  excess  of  the  taxable  wage  base.  Treas.  Reg.  §  31.3121(a)(l)-l(a)(3).  If  this  results 
in  an  overpayment,  the  employee  may  be  entitled  to  a  refund,  but  not  the  employer.  Code 
§  6413(b);  Treas.  Reg.  §  31.6413(c)-l;  Rev.  Rul.  55-584,  1955-2  C.B.  394.  SECA  taxes  are 
also  considered  income  taxes,  which  are  collected  through  the  estimated  tax  system.  Thus,  while 
PICA  taxes  are  generally  collected  and  deposited  with  the  Federal  government  every  pay  period, 
SECA  taxes  are  generally  paid  quarterly.  Compare  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1. 1401-l(a)  and  31.6302(c)- 
1.    Similarly,  SECA  taxes  may  be  contested  in  the  Tax  Court,  while  PICA  taxes  may  not. 

'*  Under  the  Social  Security  earnings  test,  benefits  through  age  69  are  reduced  by  a  fraction 
of  the  payee's  other  earnings  in  excess  of  an  exemption  amount.  Social  Security  Act  §  203,  42 
U.S.C.  §  403.  In  the  case  of  an  independent  contractor,  deferred  compensation  is  generally 
taken  into  account  for  this  purpose  when  it  is  received,  whereas,  in  the  case  of  an  employee, 
deferred  compensation  is  generally  taken  into  account  when  earned.  Compare  Social  Security 
Act  §§  209  and  211,  42  U.S.C.  §§  409  and  411  (as  noted  above,  an  exception  is  provided  for 
deferred  directors'  fees).  Therefore,  some  independent  contractors  defer  receipt  of  compensation 
that  would  otherwise  reduce  their  Social  Security  benefits  until  after  age  70. 


79 


See  generally  Code  Subtitle  C,  Chapter  23. 


66 

1990.  The  Federal  portion  of  the  tax  is  paid  quarterly.  Independent  contractors  are  not  subject 
to  FUTA  tax,  but  likewise  generally  are  not  eligible  to  receive  any  unemployment  benefits.*" 

B.        Income  Taxes 

Collection  Mechanisms.  Income  taxes  on  employees  are  collected  mainly  through  the 
withholding  system,  whereas  income  taxes  on  independent  contractors  are  collected  mainly 
through  the  estimated  tax  system.  Both  systems  are  backed  up  by  information  reporting 
requirements  imposed  on  service-recipients. 

Employers  are  generally  required  to  withhold  a  portion  of  their  employees'  wages  as  they 
are  paid  and  remit  it  to  the  Federal  government  as  payment  of  the  employees'  income  taxes.*' 
Withholding  rates  are  specified  in  tables  and  procedures  published  by  the  IRS,  and  are  calculated 
to  collect  approximately  the  same  amount  of  tax  as  the  employees  will  ultimately  owe  with 
respect  to  the  wages  if  they  work  all  year  at  the  same  wage  level. *^  Withholding  must 
generally  be  done  at  the  same  rate  each  pay  period,'^  and  the  amounts  withheld  must  generally 
be  deposited,  along  with  FICA  taxes,  soon  thereafter  in  a  Federal  depositary.*^  Withholding 
can  generate   significant  overhead   expenses.**      Independent  contractors  and  their  clients 


*°  Eligibility  is  a  matter  of  State  rather  than  Federal  law.  See  footnotes  140  and  143  below 
for  a  discussion  of  State  eligibility  standards. 

*'  See  generally  Code  §  31  and  Subtitle  C,  Chapter  24. 

*^  See  generally  Code  §  3402;  IRS  Publication  15  (Circular  E),  Employer's  Tax  Guide  (Rev. 
January,  1991).  Withholding  rates  are  generally  based  on  the  employee's  rate  of  compensation, 
marital  status,  and  the  number  of  allowances  claimed  on  Form  W-4.  Withholding  rates  may  be 
increased  if  an  employee  anticipates  receiving  additional  income  during  a  taxable  year  that  is  not 
subject  to  withholding,  or  reduced  if  large  deductions  are  anticipated. 

*'  But  see,  e.g..  Announcement  85-113,  1985-31  I.R.B.  31  (special  accounting  rule  for 
fringe  benefits);  cf.  Code  §  3501(b). 

^  The  actual  schedule  depends  on  the  size  of  the  payroll.  See  Treas.  Reg.  §  31.6302(c)-l. 

**  Some  argue  that  the  government  is  the  main  beneficiary  of  withholding,  in  that  it  enables 
tax  authorities  to  shift  a  large  portion  of  the  collection  burden  to  the  private  sector.  On  the  other 
hand,  it  is  not  clear  that  withholding  is  any  more  burdensome  on  employers  than  increased 
estimated  tax  payments  (which  would  be  necessary  without  withholding)  would  be  on  employees. 
Withholding  may  also  provide  benefits  to  some  employers  because  they  have  the  use  of  withheld 
funds  for  a  short  period  of  time  before  they  must  remit  them  to  the  government.    Moreover, 


67 

generally  are  not  subject  to  a  withholding  requirement  with  respect  to  their  compensation 
income. 

Unless  certain  exceptions  apply,  both  employees  and  independent  contractors  must  pay 
their  estimated  income  tax  liabilities  for  the  current  year  in  quarterly  installments  throughout  the 
year.*"^  The  installments  are  due  on  April  15,  June  15,  September  15,  and  January  15  of  the 
following  year.  The  amount  of  each  installment  is  generally  one  quarter  of  the  lesser  of  the 
taxpayer's  income  tax  liability  for  the  prior  year,  or  90  percent  of  her  liability  for  the  current 
year.  Because  of  withholding,  however,  employees  generally  do  not  have  to  make  any  estimated 
tax  payments.  This  is  because  withholding  generally  requires  earlier  payments  than  would  be 
necessary  under  the  estimated  tax  system,  and  these  amounts  are  credited  towards  employees' 
estimated  tax  obligations.*'  Thus,  employees  are  generally  only  required  to  make  estimated 
tax  payments  if  they  have  significant  non-wage  income. 

Employers  generally  must  report  all  wages  paid  to  an  employee  annually  on  Forms 
W-2.**  Similarly,  clients  must  generally  report  all  compensation  paid  to  independent 
contractors  annually  on  Form  1099-MISC;  no  Form  1099-MISC  is  generally  required,  however, 
for  payments  to  a  corporation,  payments  that  are  not  made  by  a  business  (e.g.,  homeowners' 
payments  to  a  house  painter),  or  payments  to  a  service-provider  aggregate  less  than  $600  in  a 
calendar  year.*'  The  administrative  burden  is  about  the  same  for  each. 

Copies  of  Form  W-2  must  be  sent  to  the  employee  and  to  the  Social  Security 
Administration. '^  The  Social  Security  Administration  subsequently  sends  information  from  the 
forms  to  the  IRS.  Also,  the  employee  is  required  to  attach  any  copies  she  receives  to  her 
income  tax  return.    Using  this  information,  the  IRS  can  determine  whether  wages  have  been 


employers  may  be  able  to  shift  some  of  their  administrative  costs  of  withholding  to  the  worker 
in  the  form  of  lower  compensation. 


86 


See  generally  Code  §§  6315  and  6654. 
"  Code  §  6654(g). 

Code  §  6041  A;  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1.6041-l(a)  and  1.6041-2. 
Code  §  6041;  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1.6041-1  and  1.6041-3. 
Code  §  6051;  Treas.  Reg.  §§  31.6051-1  and  31.6051-2. 


88 


89 


90 


68 

underreported.    While  1099s  must  be  sent  to  the  independent  contractor  and  the  IRS,  there  is 
no  requirement  that  they  be  attached  to  an  individual's  return. 

Trade  or  Business  Expense  Deductions.  Under  current  law,  independent  contractors  face 
significantly  fewer  restrictions  on  their  ability  to  deduct  trade  or  business  expenses  than 
employees.  In  particular,  employees  (but  not  independent  contractors)  generally  may  not  deduct 
their  trade  or  business  expenses  unless  they  itemize  their  deductions  on  their  Federal  income  tax 
returns,  and  even  then  only  to  the  extent  they  exceed  two  percent  of  their  adjusted  gross  income 
from  all  sources.  Also,  they  must  satisfy  additional  requirements  before  they  may  deduct  their 
automobile,  home  office  and  certain  other  expenses. 

Independent  contractors'  trade  or  business  expenses  are  generally  deductible  "above-the- 
line",  i.e.,  as  a  direct  reduction  in  their  business  income  reported  on  Schedule  C.  Employees' 
trade  or  business  expenses,  by  contrast,  are  generally  only  deductible  "below-the-line",  i.e.,  as 
itemized  expenses."  Especially  for  lower-income  employees,  use  of  the  standard  deduction 
is  often  more  favorable  than  itemization  of  expenses;  such  individuals  effectively  get  no  tax 
benefit  from  their  trade  or  business  expenses.*^  In  addition,  since  1986,  employees'  trade  or 
business  expenses  have  generally  been  deductible  only  to  the  extent  they  (plus  any  other 
miscellaneous  itemized  deductions)  exceed  two  percent  of  the  employee's  adjusted  gross  income 
from  all  sources.'^ 

The  two-percent  floor  generally  does  not  apply  to  an  employee's  trade  or  business 
expenses  to  the  extent  they  are  reimbursed  by  her  employer:  in  such  case,  generally  no 
deduction  is  necessary,  because  the  reimbursement  is  not  included  in  the  employee's  taxable 
income  in  the  first  place.  Only  reimbursement  arrangements  that  require  the  employee  to 
account  to  the  employer  for  any  expenditures  are  eligible  for  this  treatment,  however.**   This 


"  Code  §  62(a). 

^  See  Rev.  Proc.  90-64,  1990-53  I.R.B.  27,  for  the  standard  deductions  in  effect  for  1991. 

'^  Code  §  67.  This  requirement  reversed  the  earlier  trend  to  conform  the  treatment  of 
employees  and  self-employed  persons  as  much  as  possible. 

^  Code  §  62(c);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.62-2;  cf.  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.132-5(a)(l)(v)  (similar  rules  for 
working-condition  fringe  benefits).  Somewhat  different  accounting  rules  apply  depending  on 
whether  the  expense  is  subject  to  the  substantiation  requirements  of  section  274(d),  and  whether 
the  arrangement  is  a  per  diem  or  mileage  plan.  See  Code  §  62(c);  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1.62 -2(e)  and 
1.274-5T(g)and  0). 


69 

prevents  employees  from  excluding  from  income  amounts  greater  than  that  which  they  could 
have  deducted.'^  Client  reimbursements  are  always  included  in  an  independent  contractor's 
gross  income,  and  the  expenses  for  which  they  are  made  must  be  deducted.  Inadequate 
accounting  by  the  independent  contractor  to  the  client  is  therefore  generally  irrelevant  in  this 
context.  ** 

Unlike  independent  contractors,  employees  may  not  deduct  interest  expenses  incurred  in 
their  trade  or  business  of  being  an  employee:   such  interest  is  considered  a  personal  expense.'" 

Entertainment  expenses  generally  may  not  be  deducted  unless  they  satisfy  the  business 
purpose  requirements  of  section  274(a).  The  rules  applicable  to  employees  and  their  employers 
on  the  one  hand  and  independent  contractors  and  their  clients  on  the  other  are  about  the  same 
for  this  purpose.'*  Special  exemptions  are  provided,  however,  for  food  or  beverages  furnished 
on  an  employer's  business  premises  primarily  for  its  own  employees,  and  for  recreational  or 


'*  Excess  reimbursements  must  be  returned  to  the  employer.  If  the  accounting  requirements 
are  not  met,  the  employee  may  still  be  able  to  deduct  the  underlying  expenses.  They  will, 
however,  be  subject  to  the  two-percent  floor.  In  addition,  failure  to  account  will  shift  the  burden 
of  complying  with  various  requirements  of  section  274,  including  the  business  purpose 
requirement  of  section  274(a),  the  substantiation  requirement  of  section  274(d),  and  the  80- 
percent  deduction  limit  of  section  274(n),  from  the  employer  to  the  employee.  Code 
§  274(e)(2),  (e)(3)(A)  and  (n)(2)(A);  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1. 274-2 (f)(iv),  1.274-5T(0(2)  and 
31.3401(a)-4. 

^  As  with  employees,  however,  if  an  independent  contractor  does  not  adequately  account 
to  her  client,  the  burden  of  complying  with  various  requirements  of  section  274  will  shift  from 
the  client  to  her.  Code  §  274(e)(3)(B)  and  (e)(9);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.274-2(f)(2)(iv);  see  Treas. 
Reg.  §  1.274-5T(h)(3)  for  the  definition  of  an  adequate  accounting  for  this  purpose;  see  also 
Treas.  Reg.  §  1.274-2(f)(2)(iv)(a)  and  (c)(1)  (definitions  of  adequate  accounting  and 
reimbursement  arrangement).  The  substantiation  requirements  of  section  274(d)  are  an 
exception;  an  independent  contractor  continues  to  be  subject  to  these  requirements  even  if  she 
makes  an  adequate  accounting  to  her  client.  See  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.274-5T(h)(2);  Rev.  Proc.  63-4, 
Q&A-28  and  29,  1963-1  C.B.  474;  Smith  v.  Commissioner,  80  T.C.  1165  (1983).  This 
distinction  presumably  reflects  the  fact  that,  while  employees  generally  need  not  deduct 
reimbursed  expenses  because  the  reimbursements  are  simply  excluded  from  their  gross  income, 
independent  contractors  must  generally  deduct  the  amounts. 


97 


Code  §  163(h)(2)(A). 


'*    See  footnotes  95  and  96  above  for  rules  relating  to  the  allocation  of  the  burden  of 
substantiation  in  the  case  of  reimbursed  expenses. 


70 

social  activities  primarily  for  their  benefit.''    Independent  contractors  may,  however,  benefit 
ft-om  both  as  long  as  they  are  not  provided  primarily  for  the  contractors'  benefit. 

Travel  and  entertainment  expenses,  business  gifts,  and  expenses  associated  with  "listed 
property"  (including  automobiles,  computers,  cellular  telephones  and  property  used  for 
entertainment)  also  may  not  be  deducted  unless  the  taxpayer  has  adequate  records  or  other 
evidence  to  substantiate  their  amount  and  business  purpose,  within  the  meaning  of  section 
274(d).""  Again,  the  rules  applicable  to  employees  and  their  employers  on  the  one  hand  and 
independent  contractors  and  their  clients  on  the  other  are  about  the  same.  Employers  may  use 
certain  simplified  substantiation  methods  that  are  unavailable  to  clients  of  independent 
contractors,  however.  In  particular,  they  may  rely  on  records  maintained  by  their  employees 
with  respect  to  the  use  of  listed  property,  and  they  can  avoid  any  substantiation  requirements 
with  respect  to  the  use  of  vehicles  by  adopting  a  policy  statement  prohibiting  personal  use  and 
meeting  certain  other  requirements.'"'  Presumably,  these  methods  are  denied  to  clients  of 
independent  contractors  because  clients  generally  do  not  provide  them  with  the  property 
necessary  to  perform  their  jobs,  and,  in  any  event,  cannot  supervise  their  use  of  the  property 
very  closely. 

Finally,  business  meal  expenses  generally  may  not  be  deducted  unless  the  taxpayer  or  one 
of  its  employees  is  present.  Independent  contractors  may  be  treated  as  employees  for  this 
purpose  only  if  they  render  "significant  services"  to  the  taxpayer.'"^ 

Home  office  expenses  and  rental  and  depreciation  expenses  associated  with  listed  property 
(as  described  above)  may  be  subject  to  special  deduction  limits  unless  they  meet  certain  business 


"  Code  §  274(e)(1)  and  (e)(4). 
'°°  See  footnotes  95  and  96. 


""  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1.274-5T(e)(2)and  1.274-6T.  The  latter  rule  applies  to  both  employees 
and  sole-proprietors.  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.274-6T(e)(2)(i).  The  employer  can  also  shift  the  burden 
of  compliance  to  its  employees  by  treating  the  use  of  listed  property  as  personal  use  and 
including  it  in  the  employees'  incomes  without  regard  to  the  working  condition  fringe  benefit 
rules  of  section  132. 

""  Code  §  274(k);  Staff  of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Taxation,  l(X)th  Cong.,  1st  Sess., 
General  Explanation  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986,  69  (Comm.  Print  1987). 


71 

use  requirements.""  These  limits  were  significantly  tightened  in  TRA  1986.  The  limits  for 
employees  and  independent  contractors  are  generally  the  same  except  that,  in  the  case  of  home 
office  expenses,  the  employee's  business  use  must  also  be  "for  the  convenience  of  the 
employer",'**  and,  in  the  case  of  listed  property  such  as  home  computers,  such  use  must  be 
"for  the  convenience  of  the  employer  and  required  as  a  condition  of  employment."'"*  These 
standards  are  difficult  for  many  employees  to  meet.'* 

Fringe  Benefits.  Independent  contractors  are  generally  not  taken  into  account  under  the 
employee  fringe  benefit  provisions  of  the  Code.  On  the  one  hand,  this  means  that  independent 
contractors'  clients  generally  are  not  required  to  include  them  in  any  pension  or  welfare  benefit 
plans  they  provide  for  their  employees  in  order  to  maintain  the  plans'  tax-qualified  status,  and 
the  independent  contractors  have  correspondingly  greater  freedom  to  structure  their  own  benefit 
arrangements.  On  the  other  hand,  this  means  that  independent  contractors  may  be  unable  to 
participate  in  such  plans  even  if  they  want  to  (and  their  clients  agree),  and  some  of  the  benefit 
arrangements  they  establish  for  themselves  as  sole  proprietors  or  partners  may  not  be  tax- 
favored.  (Such  arrangements  may  also  be  more  costly,  since  they  usually  cannot  benefit  from 
the  economies  that  some  employers  able  to  achieve  through  group  purchase  arrangements.) 

The  Code  provides  tax-favored  treatment  for  a  wide  range  of  common  employee  fringe 
benefits,  including  pension  plans,  life  insurance  and  health  and  accident  plans.  In  many  cases, 
such  treatment  is  not  available  for  benefits  provided  to  highly  compensated  workers  unless  the 
employer  also  provides  comparable  benefits  to  a  minimum  number  of  its  nonhighly  compensated 
workers.  Generally,  only  an  employer's  common  law  employees  (and  individuals  treated  as  such 


'°'  See  generally  Code  §§  280A  and  280F.  Generally,  in  the  case  of  a  home  office,  the 
space  must  be  used  exclusively  on  a  regular  basis  as  the  taxpayer's  principal  place  of  business. 
In  the  case  of  listed  property,  the  property  must  be  used  predominantly  (i.e.,  more  than  50 
percent  of  the  time)  in  the  taxpayer's  trade  or  business. 


'»*  See  Code  §  280A(c)(l). 

"»  See  §  280F(d)(3)(A);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.280F-6T(a)(2). 


'°*  See,  e.g. ,  Rev.  Rul.  86-129,  1986-2  C.B.  48.  On  the  other  hand,  the  Tax  Court's  "focal 
point"  test  has  made  it  difficult  for  independent  contractors  to  establish  their  home  office  as  their 
principal  place  of  business  if  they  render  services  elsewhere.  E.g.,  Bate  v.  Commissioner,  lA 
T.C.  105  (1980);  but  see  Soliman  v.  Commissioner,  94  T.C.  20  (1990)  (apparent  abandonment 
of  "focal  point"  test). 


72 

under  the  Code)''"  are  taken  into  account  for  this  purpose.  In  addition,  these  same  provisions 
generally  prohibit  an  employer  from  offering  tax-favored  benefits  to  its  independent  contractors. 
A  list  of  tax-favored  benefits,  and  the  conditions  under  which  they  may  be  offered  to  employees 
and  independent  contractors,  are  shown  in  Table  A-1."*  (The  table  does  not  include 
statutorily-required  benefits  such  as  workers'  compensation.) 

Taken  together,  these  rules  tend  to  encourage  employers  to  admit  a  new  worker  into  an 
existing  fringe  benefit  plan  if  she  is  classified  as  an  employee,  and  to  discourage  (if  not  actually 
prohibit)  them  from  doing  so  if  she  is  classified  as  an  independent  contractor.  Classification  as 
an  independent  contractor  may,  therefore,  be  beneficial  to  the  client;  in  cases  where  the  worker 
would  prefer  additional  cash  or  a  different  benefit  package  to  the  fringe  benefits  offered  under 
the  employer's  plan  and  can  negotiate  to  receive  some  or  all  of  the  compensation  the  client 
would  otherwise  have  spent  on  the  benefits,  classification  as  an  independent  contractor  may  also 
be  beneficial  to  the  worker. 

An  independent  contractor  who  is  unable  to  participate  in  her  client's  plans  generally  can 
establish  her  own  benefit  arrangements  in  her  capacity  as  a  sole  proprietor  (or  as  a  partner,  if 
she  is  in  business  with  other  individuals).""  As  indicated  in  Table  A-1,  the  most  significant 
types  of  fringe  benefits  may  be  available  on  a  tax-favored  basis.  For  example,  sole  proprietors 
can  generally  establish  their  own  pension  plans,  subject  to  essentially  the  same  rules  as 


'"^  These  include  leased  employees  subject  to  section  414(n)  and  so-called  "statutory 
employees"  treated  under  sections  3121(d)  and  7701(a)(20)  as  employees  for  purposes  of  PICA 
and  certain  employee  benefit  provisions  of  the  Code.  Cf.  Staff  of  the  Joint  Committee  on 
Taxation,  100th  Cong.,  1st  Sess.,  General  Explanation  of  the  Tax  Reform  Act  of  1986,  1345 
(Comm.  Print  1987)  (section  1706  not  to  affect  application  of  section  414(n)).  Note  that,  in 
some  cases  employees  may  also  be  deemed  to  be  self-employed.  See,  e.g. ,  Code  §  1372  (certain 
S  corporation  shareholders  treated  as  partners). 

108  Provisions  that  merely  specify  the  accounting  treatment  of  benefits  provided  to 
employees,  and  do  not  grant  tax-favored  treatment,  generally  also  apply  to  independent 
contractors.  E.g.,  Code  §§  83,  280G  and  457;  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1.83-l(a)(l)  and  1.457-2(d); 
Prop.  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.280G-1,  Q&A-15. 

""  Sole  proprietors  and  partners  are  proprietors  of  unincorporated  businesses.  The 
treatment  of  proprietors  of  incorporated  businesses  is  discussed  in  section  II. C.  below. 


Table  A-1 
Tax-Favored  Benefits  Available  to  Employees  and  Independent  Contractors 


Availability 


Benefits 

To  Employee 
in  Emnlover's  Plan 

May  be  required 

To  Independent 

Contractor  in  Client's 

Plan 

To  Independent 
Contractor  in  Own  Plan 

Employee  achievement  awards' 

Group-term  life  insurance'' 

May  be  required 

Death  benefits" 

Generally  optional 

Accident  and  health  insurance' 

Generally  optional 

Limited  deduction  only 

Tuition  remission* 

May  be  required 

Meals  and  lodging' 

Optional 

Group  legal  services' 

May  be  required 

Optional 

Cafeteria  plans' 

May  be  required 

Educational  assistance* 

May  be  required 

Optional 

Dependent  care^ 

May  be  required 

Optional 

No-additional-cost  fringes' 

May  be  required 

Optional 

Qualified  employee  discount^ 

May  be  required 

Optional 

Working  condition  fringes" 

Optional 

Optional 

Optional 

De  minimis  fringes" 

Generally  optional 

Optional 

Optional 

Free  parking 

Optional 

Optional 

On-premises  athletic  facilities'' 

Optional 

Optional 

New-product  testing 

Optional 

Optional 

Qualified  pensions  and  annuities 

May  be  required 

Optional 

Tax-sheltered  annuities 

May  be  required 

Qualified  and  incentive  stock  option^ 

Optional 

Employee  stock  purchase  plans' 

May  be  required 

Voluntary  employees'  beneficiary 
associations" 

May  be  required 

Dqjanmcnt  of  Ibc  Treasury 
Office  of  Tax  Policy 


In  this  table,  "optional"  means  that  the  benefit  is  not  required  to  be  provided  under  any  minimum  coverage  or  nondiscrimination  rules, 
while  "may  be  required"  means  that  it  may  have  to  be  provided. 


Notes 


a.  Code  §§  74(c)  and  2740)(3)(B). 

b.  Code  §  79(d);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.79-0(b). 

c.  Code  §  101(b)(3)(A);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.101-2(0(1).   Discrimination  rules  may  apply  if  the  benefiU  are  provided  under  a  qualified 
pension  plan,  however. 


d.  Code  §§  105(g),  106,  and  162(1)(1);  Trcas.  Reg.  5  1.105-l(a).   Coverage  and  discrimination  requirements  may  apply  if  the  plan 
is  self-funded.   Code  §  lOS(h). 

e.  Codes  117(d)(2)(A). 

f.  Code§  119. 

g.  Code  §  120(c)(1),  (c)(2)  and  (d)(1). 

h.  Code  §  125(b)(1)  and  (d)(1)(A);  Prop.  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.125-1,  Q&A-4. 

i.  Code  §  127(b)(2)  and  (c)(2);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.127-2(h)(l)(iii). 

j.  Code  §  129(d)(2).  (d)(3),  (d)(8)  and  (e)(3). 

k.  Code  §  132(b),  (f)  and  (h)(1);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.132-l(b)(l)and  (3). 

1.  Code  §  132(c),  (0  and  (h)(1);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.132-l(b)(l)and  (3). 

m.  Code  §  132(d);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.1 32- 1(b)(2)  and  (4). 

n.  Code  §  132(e);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1 .  132-l(b)(2)  and  (4).    Certain  nondiscr'miination  rules  apply  to  eating  facilities,  however. 

o.  Code  §  132(h)(4);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.132-(b)(2)  (Hush  language). 

p.  Code  §  132(h)(5);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.132-l(b)(l)and  (3). 

q.  Treas.  Reg.  §§  1.132- 1(b)(2)  (Hush  language)  and  1.132-5(n). 

r.  Code  §§  401(a)(4),  401(c)  and  410(b);  Treas.  Reg.  |§  I.72-17(a)  and  1.401-10(b). 

s.  Code  §  403(b);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.403(b)-l(a)(l). 

t.  Code  §§  421-22A;  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.421-7(h). 

u.  Code  §  423;  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.423-2(e)(2). 

V.  Code  §  501(c)(9);  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.501(c)(9)-2(b). 


75 

employer- sponsored  plans. "°  In  lieu  of  the  exclusion  from  income  for  employer-provided 
accident  and  health  insurance,  they  can  often  deduct  up  to  one-quarter  of  their  medical  insurance 
expenses,  without  regard  to  the  7.5  percent  floor  in  section  213  (unless  they  are  covered  under 
an  employer- sponsored  plan  directly  or  through  their  spouse).'"  They  can  also  provide 
themselves  certain  fringe  benefits,  including  working  condition  and  de  minimis  fringes,  on  a  pre- 
tax basis.  Other  benefits  must  generally  be  purchased  out  of  after-tax  income.  In  addition,  as 
explained  in  Section  II  above,  the  tax  benefits  for  sole  proprietor  and  partnership  plans  are 
generally  limited  to  the  income  tax  provisions  of  the  Code,  and  do  not  apply  for  Social  Security 
and  Medicare  tax  purposes. 

C.        Determination  of  Employee  Status 

The  status  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor  for  purposes  of  the 
Federal  tax  laws  is,  with  few  exceptions,  determined  under  the  common  law  tests  for 
determining  whether  a  master- servant  (employment)  relationship  exists. 

Background.  The  common  law  tests  first  assumed  importance  under  the  employment  tax 
provisions  of  the  Code.  The  original  Social  Security  Act  simply  defined  an  "employee"  as 
including  "an  officer  of  a  corporation"."^  Treasury  regulations  issued  in  1936  used  common 
law  standards  to  determine  employee  status."^  The  lower  courts,  however,  applied  a  variety 
of  different  standards,  some  relying  less  than  others  on  common  law  precedents."*    In  1947 


"°  In  a  sense  these  rules  are  more  favorable:  plans  of  sole  proprietors  who  have  no 
nonhighly  compensated  employees  resemble  elective  arrangements  like  IRAs  and  section  401(k) 
plans,  but  are  subject  to  higher  dollar  limits  on  contributions. 

"*  Code  §  1620)(6),  as  amended  by  OBRA  1990  §  11410.  This  provision  is  due  to  expire 
December  31,  1991,  however. 

"2  Social  Security  Act  §  1101(a)(6),  Pub.  L.  No.  74-271,  49  Stat.  620,  647  (1935).  PICA 
was  in  Title  VIII  of  the  original  act.    SECA  was  enacted  on  August  28,  1950. 

"'  Reg.  91,  article  3,  1  Fed.  Reg.  2049,  2052  (Nov.  11,  1936).  The  regulations  state,  inter 
alia,  that  "[i]n  general,  if  an  individual  is  subject  to  the  control  or  direction  of  another  merely 
as  to  the  result  to  be  accomplished  by  the  work  and  not  as  to  the  means  and  methods  for 
accomplishing  the  result,  he  is  an  independent  contractor.  An  individual  performing  services 
as  an  independent  contractor  is  not  as  to  such  services  an  employee."  This  closely  resembles 
the  language  in  the  current  regulations. 

""  See  United  States  v.  Webb,  397  U.S.  179  (1969),  for  a  description  of  this  case  law. 


76 

the  Supreme  Court  issued  a  pair  of  opinions  that  attempted  to  clarify  the  governing  stan- 
dards."* In  them,  the  Court  applied  an  "economic  reality"  test  that  resembled  the  common 
law  tests,  under  which  "employees  are  those  who  as  a  matter  of  economic  reality  are  dependent 
on  the  business  to  which  they  render  services.""* 

The  IRS  (and  the  Social  Security  Administration)  proposed  amendments  to  their 
regulations  to  incorporate  the  Court's  new  economic  reality  test,  but  these  never  took  effect: 
Congress  reacted  immediately  by  passing  (over  President  Truman's  veto)  the  so-called  Gearhart 
Resolution,  endorsing  the  use  of  common  law  tests.'" 

Current  Rules.  Current  Treasury  regulations  provide  that  an  individual  is  generally  an 
employee  if,  under  the  usual  common  law  tests,  the  relationship  between  the  individual  and  the 
person  for  whom  she  performs  services  is  the  legal  relationship  of  employer  and  employee. 
Such  a  relationship  generally  exists  if  the  person  for  whom  the  services  are  performed 

has  the  right  to  control  and  direct  the  individual  who  performs  the  services,  not 
only  as  to  the  result  to  be  accomplished  by  the  work  but  also  as  to  the  details  and 
means  by  which  that  result  is  accomplished.  That  is,  an  employee  is  subject  to 
the  will  and  control  of  the  employer  not  only  as  to  what  shall  be  done  but  [also] 
how  it  shall  be  done."* 

Over  the  years,  the  IRS  has  identified  20  important  factors  for  determining  when  the  common 
law  tests  are  satisfied."'  These  factors,  which  are  listed  in  Appendix  B,  are  used  in  resolving 
issues  raised  in  rulings  and  other  guidance,  including  guidance  on  the  status  of  tech..ical  services 


"'  Banks  v.  Birmingham,  332  U.S.  126  (1947),  and  United  States  v.  Silk,  331  U.S.  704 
(1947).  See  also  Harrison  v.  Greyvan  Lines,  331  U.S.  126  (1947). 

"*  Bartles,  332  U.S.  at  130. 

"^   H.R.J.  Res.  296,  Pub.  L.  No.  642,  62  Stat.  438  (1948). 

"»  Treas.  Reg.  §§  3 1.3 12 1(d)- 1(a)(2),  31.3306(i)-l(b)  and  31.3401(c)-l(b). 

"'  Internal  Revenue  Manual  4600  (Employment  Tax  Procedures),  Exhibit  4640-1;  see  also 
Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296.  These  factors  were  originally  compiled  by  the  Social 
Security  Administration  in  determining  entitlement  to  benefits. 


77 

workers  issued  after  the  enactment  of  section  1706.'^°  No  one  factor  on  this  list  is  determina- 
tive, though  some  are  more  important  than  others. 

Congress  and  the  courts  have  overridden  the  common  law  tests  in  some  situations.  For 
example,  certain  occupations  generally  performed  by  employees  are  nevertheless  treated  as 
performed  by  independent  contractors  under  the  Code;  these  include  certain  door-to-door 
salesmen  and  real  estate  agents.'^'  Conversely,  certain  occupations  generally  performed  by 
independent  contractors  are  nevertheless  treated  as  performed  by  employees  for  employment  tax 
purposes.  These  "statutory  employees"  include  certain  full-time  life  insurance  salesmen,  agent- 
drivers  and  commission-drivers  engaged  in  the  distribution  of  specific  kinds  of  products, 
homeworkers  and  traveling  or  city  salesmen.'^ 

Relevance  of  Incorporation.  An  employee  generally  cannot  change  her  status  for  Federal 
tax  purposes  to  that  of  an  independent  contractor  via  incorporation.  The  common  law  tests  focus 
on  the  relationship  between  the  individual  performing  the  services  and  the  service-recipient;  if 
an  employment  relationship  exists,  it  is  generally  irrelevant  whether  payments  are  made  directly 
or  through  a  corporation  controlled  by  the  individual.'^  The  legislative  history  of  section 
1706  reiterates  this  point. '^^ 


'^°  See  Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296.  See  also  Moore,  Defining  the  Employee: 
Common-Law  Rules,  Direction,  February,  1988,  at  13.  Mr.  Moore  is  the  technical  assistant  for 
Federal  employment  tax  in  the  Office  of  the  Assistant  Chief  Counsel  (Employee  Benefits  and 
Exempt  Organizations)  of  the  IRS.  See  generally  Annotation,  Determination  of  Employer- 
Employee  Relationship  for  Social  Securiry  Contribution  and  Unemployment  Tax  Purposes,  37 
A.L.R.  Fed.  95  (1978),  and  Annotation,  What  Constitutes  Employer-Employee  Relationship  for 
Purposes  of  Federal  Income  Tax  Withholding,  51  A.L.R.  Fed.  59  (1981). 

'2'  See  Code  §  3508;  see  also  Code  §  1372. 

'22  See  Code  §  3121(d);  Treas.  Reg.  §  31.3121(d)-l(d);  Rev.  Rul.  90-93,  1990-45  I.R.B. 
4.  Full-time  life  insurance  salesmen  may  also  be  treated  as  employees  for  certain  fringe  benefit 
purposes.    Code  §  7701(a)(20). 

'23  E.g.,  Sargent  v.  Commissioner,  93  T.C.  572  (1989);  Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296; 
and  Rev.  Rul.  74-330,  1974-2  C.B.  278  (examples  (1)  and  (2)). 

'2^  H.R.  Conf  Rep.  No.  841,  99th  Cong.,  2d  Sess.  11-835  (1986);  132  Cong.  Rec.  S8088- 
89  (June  20,  1986);  see  Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296;  and  Private  Letter  Ruling  9002017 
(October  12,  1989). 


78 

An  independent  contractor  also  generally  cannot  change  her  status  for  Federal  tax 
purposes  to  that  of  an  employee  of  her  client  via  incorporation;  she  may,  however,  be  treated 
as  an  employee  of  her  own  personal  service  corporation  for  certain  purposes,  and  derive  certain 
tax  benefits  as  a  result.  The  effect  depends  on  whether  the  personal  service  corporation  elects 
to  be  taxed  as  a  Subchapter  S  corporation  under  section  1362  of  the  Code.  If  it  does  not,  the 
individual  will  generally  be  treated  as  an  employee  of  the  corporation  for  tax  purposes,  and  can 
thus  take  advantage,  imer  alia,  of  various  employee  benefit  provisions  of  the  Code.  She  will, 
moreover,  not  be  subject  to  the  two-percent  floor  on  itemized  deductions  or  other  limits  on 
employee  trade  or  business  expense  deductions  to  the  extent  she  causes  such  expenses  to  be 
deducted  at  the  corporate  level.  Although  any  income  received  and  retained  by  the  corporation 
will  be  taxed  at  (usually  higher)  corporate  rates,  in  practice  this  problem  can  be  minimized  by 
distributing  as  much  income  as  possible  in  the  form  of  compensation. 

If  the  personal  service  corporation  does  elect  to  be  taxed  as  an  S  corporation,  the 
individual  will  also  generally  be  treated  as  an  employee  of  the  corporation  for  tax  purposes,'^* 
but  with  one  important  exception:  assuming  her  ownership  interest  exceeds  two  percent,  she 
will  not  be  treated  as  a  employee  for  purposes  of  the  employee  benefit  provisions  of  the 
Code.'^*  The  treatment  of  trade  or  business  expenses  is  roughly  the  same  as  for  a  C 
corporation.'^ 

m.       OTHER  LAWS 

A.        Federal  Labor  Laws 

Most  Federal  labor  laws  apply  only  to  employees  and  do  not  protect  independent 
contractors.  This  is  generally  beneficial  to  the  independent  contractors'  clients,  who  may  save 
the  direct  costs  of  providing  additional  benefits  to  the  individuals  plus  any  associated 
administrative  costs,  but  may  not  be  beneficial  to  the  independent  contractors  unless  they  do  not 
need  the  protection  and  can  share  in  their  clients'  cost  savings. 


125 


126 


127 


See  Spicer  Accounting,  Inc.  v.  Vnited  States,  918  F.2d  90  (9th  Cir.  1990). 

Code  §  1372. 

Code  §  67(c);  Temp.  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.67-2T(b). 


79 

COBRA.  Employers  must  generally  give  their  employees  and  the  employees' 
beneficiaries  the  right  to  continue  coverage  under  an  employer-sponsored  health  plan  after  their 
coverage  has  ceased,  if  coverage  ceases  on  account  of  certain  qualifying  events.'^*  This 
requirement  applies  to  employees  and  independent  contractors  (provided  the  plan  covers  at  least 
some  common  law  employees).'^' 

ERISA.  Pension  and  welfare  benefit  plans  are  subject  to  various  coverage,  funding, 
fiduciary,  reporting,  and  other  requirements  under  the  Employee  Retirement  Income  Security 
Act  of  1974.''°  These  labor  provisions  of  ERISA  do  not  apply  to  plans  benefiting  self- 
employed  individuals  (including  independent  contractors)  unless  they  also  cover  employees,  and 
many  of  the  specific  protections  provided  under  ERISA  extend  only  to  employee-partici- 
pants."' The  tax  provisions  of  ERISA  are  included  in  the  Code. 

Other  Labor  Laws.  Independent  contractors  are  generally  not  covered  by  the  National 
Labor  Relations  Act,  and  therefore  generally  may  not  engage  in  collective  bargaining  or  similar 
protected  activities.''^  They  also  receive  no  protection  under  the  nondiscrimination  require- 
ments of  the  Age  Discrimination  in  Employment  Act'"  or  Title  VII  of  the  Civil  Rights  Act 


'^*  Code  §  4980B,  as  added  by  the  Consolidated  Omnibus  Budget  Reconciliation  Act  of 
1985  (COBRA),  Pub.  L.  No.  99-272,  Title  X,  100  Stat.  222  (1986),  and  amended  by  TAMRA 
§3011. 

'^'   Code  §  4980B(f)(7);  Prop.  Treas.  Reg.  §  1.162-26,  Q«&A-16(b). 

"°  Pub.  L.  No.  93-406,  88  Stat.  829  (1974),  codified  at  29  U.S.C.  §§  1001  et  seq. 

'"  ERISA  §§  3(3)  and  (6),  4(a)  and  4021(a),  29  U.S.C.  §§  1002(3)  and  (6),  1003(a)  and 
1321(a);  29  C.F.R.  §  2510.3-3. 

"2  NLRA  §  7,  29  U.S.C.  §  157.  See  North  American  Van  Lines,  Inc.  v.  NLRB,  869  F.2d 
596  (2d  Cir.  1989). 

'"  ADEA  §§  4(a)  and  (11),  29  U.S.C.  §§  623(a)  and  630(0-  See  Hyland  v.  New  Haven 
Radiology  Assocs.,  P.C,  794  F.2d  793  (2d  Cir.  1986). 


80 

of  1964,''*  the  safety  requirements  of  the  Occupational  Safety  and  Health  Act,"^  or  the 
minimum  wage  and  overtime  requirements  of  the  Fair  Labor  Standards  Act,'^  among  others. 

B.  Patent  and  Copyright  Laws 

An  employer  is  generally  considered  the  author  of  any  work  prepared  during  the  course 
of  an  employee's  employment  for  purposes  of  the  Federal  copyright  laws;  no  such  presumption 
exists  with  respect  to  work  prepared  by  independent  contractors."'  By  contrast,  generally  no 
legal  distinction  is  drawn  between  employees  and  independent  contractors  under  the  Federal 
patent  laws.''*  In  practice,  however,  independent  contractors  may  find  it  somewhat  easier  to 
secure  patent  protection  for  on-the-job  creations  than  employees,  since  this  issue  often  turns  on 
a  court's  analysis  of  the  implicit  bargain  struck  between  the  parties.''' 

C.  State  Laws 

Many  State  laws  also  impose  different  requirements  on  employers  and  employees  on  the 
one  hand  and  independent  contractors  and  their  clients  on  the  other.  In  particular,  employers 
are  generally  required  to  contribute  a  portion  of  the  wages  paid  to  each  of  their  employees  to 


"*  CivU  Rights  Act  (1964)  §  701(f),  42  U.S.C.  §§  2000e(f).  See  Wheeler  v.  Hurdman,  825 
F.2d  257  (10th  Cir.),  cert,  denied,  484  U.S.  986  (1987). 

'"  OSHA  §§  3(6)  and  5(a)(1),  29  U.S.C.  §§  652(6)  and  654(a)(1). 

"*  FLSA  §§  3(e)(1),  6  and  7,  29  U.S.C.  §§  203(e)(1),  206  and  207.  See  Walling  v. 
Portland  Terminal  Co. ,  330  U.S.  148  (1947).  Recent  legislation  has  created  an  exemption  from 
FLSA  for  technical  services  workers  who  are  employees.  Pub.  L.  No.  101-583,  104  Stat.  2781 
(1990). 

'"  Copyright  Act  §§  101  and  201(b),  17  U.S.C.  §§  101  and  201(b)  (work-for-hire).  See. 
e.g.,  CCNVv.  Reid,  104  L.Ed.2d  831  (1989);  and  Aldon  Accessories  Ltd.  v.  Speigel,  Inc.,  738 
F.2d  548,  552  (2d  Cir.),  cert,  denied,  469  U.S.  982  (1984). 

"*  See,  e.g.,  Francklyn  v.  Guilford  Packing  Co.,  695  F.2d  1158,  1160-61  (9th  Cir.  1983); 
and  B.F.  Gladding  <&.  Co.  v.  Scientific  Anglers,  Inc.,  248  F.2d  483  (6th  Cir.  1957). 

'"  This  is  especially  true  of  the  so-called  "shop  right"  doctrine,  under  which  an  employer 
or  client  may  claim  royalty-free  use  of  an  invention.  See,  e.g.,  Hobbs  v.  United  States,  376 
F.2d  488,  495  (5th  Cir.  1967),  and  Crom  v.  Cement  Gun  Co.,  46  F.  Supp.  403,  404  (D.  Del. 
1942). 


81 

State  workers'  compensation  and  unemployment  funds. '^  Clients  of  independent  contractors 
generally  are  not  required  to  do  so,  and,  as  a  consequence,  independent  contractors  generally 
are  not  eligible  for  benefits  under  these  systems.  Employee  wages  may  also  be  protected  under 
State  wage  payment  laws,  while  payments  to  independent  contractors  are  not.'""  As  with 
Federal  labor  laws,  this  exclusion  is  generally  beneficial  to  the  clients  of  independent 
contractors,  but  may  not  be  beneficial  to  the  independent  contractors  themselves  unless  they  do 
not  need  the  protection  and  can  share  in  their  clients'  cost  savings. 

D.        Determination  of  Employee  Status 

The  status  of  an  individual  as  an  employee  or  independent  contractor  for  purposes  of 
Federal  and  State  labor  and  other  laws  is  generally  determined  under  standards  that  resemble  the 
control-based  common  law  standards  applied  under  the  Code.'''^  Depending  on  the  purpose 
of  the  law  involved,  however,  different  factors  are  often  emphasized  in  making  this  determina- 
tion.'''^    Thus,   IRS  determinations  of  employee  status  are  generally  persuasive  but  not 


""^  See,  e.g.,  N.Y.  Workmen's  Compensation  Law  §  210  (McKinney  1965),  and  N.Y. 
Labor  Law  §§  560  and  570  (McKinney  1988)  (unemployment  insurance).  See  also  text 
accompanying  footnote  80  above. 

"'  See,  e.g.,  N.Y.  Workmen's  Compensation  Law  §  50  (McKinney  1965)  (requirement  that 
employer  provide  security  for  payment  of  wage  compensation). 

'"•^  See  generally  Annotation,  Trucker  as  Indepeiident  Contractor  or  Employee  Under  §  2(3) 
of  the  National  Labor  Relations  Act  (29  U.S.C.S.  §  152(3)),  55  A.L.R.  Fed.  20  (1990); 
Annotation,  Determination  of  "Independent  Contractor'  and  "Employee'  Status  for  Purposes  of 
§  3(e)(1)  of  the  Fair  Labor  Standards  Act  (29  U.S.C.S.  §  203(e)(1)),  51  A.L.R.  Fed.  702 
(1990);  Annotation,  Who  is  'Employee"  Within  the  Meaning  of  Age  Discrimination  in 
Employment  Act  (29  U.S.C.S.  §§  621-634),  69  A.L.R.  Fed.  700  (1990);  Annotation,  Who  is 
"Employee"  as  Defined  in  §  701(f)  of  the  Civil  Rights  Act  of  1964,  42  U.S.C.S.  §  2000e(f),  72 
A.L.R.  Fed.  522  (1990);  and  Annotation,  Right  to  unemployment  compensation  or  social  security 
of  one  working  on  his  own  projects  or  activities,  65  A.L.R.2d  1182  (1990). 

"'  Federal  law:  see,  e.g.,  Darden  v.  Nationwide  Mutual  Ins.  Co.,  796  F.2d  701  (4th  Cir. 
1986)  (ERISA);  Weisel  v.  Singapore  Joint  Vemure,  Inc.,  602  F.2d  1185  (5th  Cir.  1979);  Dunlop 
V.  Dr.  Pepper-Pepsi  Cola  Bottling  Co.,  529  F.2d  298  (6th  Cir.  1976)  (NLRA);  Brennan  v. 
Gilles  <&  Cotting,  Inc.,  504  F.2d  1255  (4th  Cir.  1974)  (OSHA);  Spirides  v.  Reinhardt,  613  F.2d 
826  (D.C.  Cir.  1979)  (Title  VII);  and  EEOC  v.  Zippo  Mfg.  Co.,  713  F.2d  32  (3d  Cir.  1983) 
(ADEA). 

State  law:     see,  e.g.,  Taylor  v.  Employmem  Division,  597  P.2d  780  (Or.   1978); 
Starinieri,  v.  Unemployment  Compensation  Board  of  Review,  289  A. 2d  726  (Pa.  1972);  and 


82 

determinative,  and,  in  some  cases,  a  worker  can  simultaneously  be  an  employee  for  some 
purposes  and  an  independent  contractor  for  others. 

IV.       SUMMARY 

Current  law  does  not  consistently  favor  employee  or  independent  contractor  status. 
Independent  contractors  and  their  clients  are  treated  somewhat  more  favorably  with  respect  to 
employment  taxes,  and  significantly  more  favorably  with  respect  to  their  trade  or  business 
expense  deductions.  On  the  other  hand,  employees  and  employers  are  treated  more  favorably 
with  respect  to  the  taxation  of  some  fringe  benefits.  Similarly,  clients  of  independent  contractors 
do  not  bear  as  great  a  burden  as  employers  under  Federal  and  State  labor  laws,  but  independent 
contractors  also  do  not  enjoy  the  same  benefits  or  protections  under  those  laws  as  do  employees. 


Laeng  v.  Workmen's  Compensation  Appeals  Board,  494  P. 2d  1100  (Cal.  1972);  cf.  Gumming 
V.  District  Unemployment  Compensation  Board,  382  A.2d  1010  (D.C.  1977)  (self-employed 
status  does  noi  per  se  disqualify  claimant). 


APPENDIX  B 
COMMON  LAW  FACTORS  USED  TO  DETERMINE  EMPLOYEE  STATUS 

Workers  are  generally  considered  employees  for  Federal  tax  purposes  if  they: 

1.  Must  comply  with  employer's  instructions  about  the  work. 

2.  Receive  training  from  or  at  the  direction  of  the  employer. 

3.  Provide  services  that  are  integrated  into  the  business. 

4.  Provide  services  that  must  be  rendered  personally. 

5.  Hire,  supervise,  and  pay  assistants  for  the  employer. 

6.  Have  a  continuing  working  relationship  with  the  employer. 

7.  Must  follow  set  hours  of  work. 

8.  Work  full-time  for  an  employer. 

9.  Do  their  work  on  the  employer's  premises. 

10.  Must  do  their  work  in  a  sequence  set  by  the  employer. 

1 1 .  Must  submit  regular  reports  to  the  employer. 

12.  Receive  payments  of  regular  amounts  at  set  intervals. 

13.  Receive  payments  for  business  and/or  travelling  expenses. 

14.  Rely  on  the  employer  to  furnish  tools  and  materials. 

15.  Lack  a  major  investment  in  facilities  used  to  perform  the  service. 

16.  Cannot  make  a  profit  or  suffer  a  loss  from  their  services. 

17.  Work  for  one  employer  at  a  time. 

18.  Do  not  offer  their  services  to  the  general  public. 

19.  Can  be  fired  by  the  employer. 

20.  May  quit  work  at  any  time  without  incurring  liability. 

Source:    Exhibit  4640-1,  Internal  Revenue  Manual  4600  (Employment  Tax  Procedures),  and 
Rev.  Rul.  87-41,  1987-1  C.B.  296. 


83 


APPENDIX  C 
ADDITIONAL  BACKGROUND  TO  TCMP  AND  SVC-1 
I.  TCMP 

The  definition  of  "technical  services  worker"  for  purposes  of  Table  5-2  is  based  on  the 
occupation  of  the  primary  taxpayer  determined  in  the  course  of  the  TCMP  audit.  Unweighted 
frequencies  for  the  occupations  included  in  the  analysis  are  as  follows: 

Frequency  Occupation 

102  Architects 

1,327  Engineers 

27  Surveyors  and  Mapping  Scientists 

79  Computer  Scientists 

204  Operations  and  Systems  Researchers  and  Analysts 

8  Mathematical  Scientists 

182  Physical  Scientists 

27  Life  Scientists 

176  Engineering  Technologists  and  Technicians 

94  Drafting  Occupations 

1 1  Survey  and  Mapping  Technicians 

8  Biological  Technologists  and  Technicians  (Except  Health) 

39  Chemical  and  Nuclear  Technologists  and  Technicians 

4  Mathematical  Technicians 

47  Science  Technologists  and  Technicians,  Not  Elsewhere  Classi- 
fied 

12  Air  Traffic  Controllers 

13  Radio  and  Related  Operators 
6  Legal  Technicians 

98  Programmers 

4  Technical  Writers 

216  Technicians,  Not  Elsewhere  Classified 

2,684  Total 


85 


86 


n.     svc-i 


Unweighted  frequencies  for  the  "technical  services"  occupations  included  in  the  SVC-1 
survey  are  as  follows: 


Frequency 


Occupation 


1 
8 
4 

10 
5 

15 


43 


Architects 

Engineers 

Physical  Scientists 

Engineering  Technologists  and  Technicians 

Air  and  Ship  Officers  and  Technicians 

Technicians,  e.g.,  Embalmer/Morticians,  Radio  Operator, 

Computer  Programmer 

Total 


The  following  occupations  were  included  in  the  TCMP  analysis,  but  did  not  appear  in  the  SVC-1 
sample  of  misclassified  employees: 

Computer  Scientists  and  Specialists; 

Operations  and  System  Researchers  and  Analysts; 

Mathematical  Scientists  including  Mathematicians,  Actuaries  and  Statisticians, 

Life  Scientists; 

Science  Technologists  and  Mathematical  Technicians. 


■  ■IT  UP 


HAHY 


Department  of  the  Treasury 

Washington,  D.C.  20220 

Official  Business 
Penalty  for  Private  Use,  $300 


us,  TREASURY  LIBRARY 


1    0085479